Background Knowledge (Christianity)
In Plutarch’s biography of Romulus, the founder of Rome, we are told he was the son of god, born of a virgin; an attempt is made to kill him as a baby, and he is saved, and raised by a poor family, becoming a lowly shepherd; then as a man he becomes beloved by the people, hailed as king, and killed by the conniving elite; then he rises from the dead, appears to a friend to tell the good news to his people, and ascends to heaven to rule from on high. Just like Jesus.
Plutarch also tells us about annual public ceremonies that were still being performed, which celebrated the day Romulus ascended to heaven. The sacred story told at this event went basically as follows: at the end of his life, amid rumors he was murdered by a conspiracy of the Senate (just as Jesus was ‘murdered’ by a conspiracy of the Jews—in fact by the Sanhedrin, the Jewish equivalent of the Senate), the sun went dark (just as it did when Jesus died), and Romulus’s body vanished (just as Jesus’ did). The people wanted to search for him but the Senate told them not to, ‘for he had risen to join the gods’ (much as a mysterious young man tells the women in Mark’s Gospel). Most went away happy, hoping for good things from their new god, but ‘some doubted’ (just as all later Gospels say of Jesus: Mt. 28.17; Lk. 24.11; Jn 20.24-25; even Mk 16.8 implies this). Soon after, Proculus, a close friend of Romulus, reported that he met Romulus ‘on the road’ between Rome and a nearby town and asked him, ‘Why have you abandoned us?’, to which Romulus replied that he had been a god all along but had come down to earth and become incarnate to establish a great kingdom, and now had to return to his home in heaven (pretty much as happens to Cleopas in Lk. 24.13-32; see Chapter 10, §6). Then Romulus told his friend to tell the Romans that if they are virtuous they will have all worldly power.1
Plutarch tells us that the annual Roman ceremony of the Romulan ascent involved a recitation of the names of those who fled his vanishing in fear, and the acting out of their fear and flight in public, a scene suspiciously paralleling the pre-redacted ending of Mark’s Gospel (at 16.8).2 Which would make sense of his otherwise bizarre ending—we are then to assume what followed his story is just what followed the story he is emulating: an appearance of the Lord, delivering the gospel, which is then proclaimed to the people (the very thing Mark tells us to anticipate: 14.28 and 16.7). In fact, Livy’s account, just like Mark’s, emphasizes that ‘fear and bereavement’ kept the people ‘silent for a long time’, and only later did they proclaim Romulus ‘God, Son of God, King, and Father’, thus matching Mark’s ‘they said nothing to anyone’, yet obviously assuming that somehow word got out.
It certainly seems as if Mark is fashioning Jesus into the new Romulus, with a new, superior message, establishing a new, superior kingdom. This Romulan tale looks a lot like a skeletal model for the passion narrative: a great man, founder of a great kingdom, despite coming from lowly origins and of suspect parentage, is actually an incarnated son of god, but dies as a result of a conspiracy of the ruling council, then a darkness covers the land at his death and his body vanishes, at which those who followed him flee in fear (just like the Gospel women, Mk 16.8; and men, Mk 14.50-52), and like them, too, we look for his body but are told he is not here, he has risen; and some doubt, but then the risen god ‘appears’ to select followers to deliver his gospel.3
There are many differences in the two stories, surely. But the similarities are too numerous to be a coincidence—and the differences are likely deliberate. For instance, Romulus’s material kingdom favoring the mighty is transformed into a spiritual one favoring the humble. It certainly looks like the Christian passion narrative is an intentional transvaluation of the Roman Empire’s ceremony of their own founding savior’s incarnation, death and resurrection (see Element 47). Other elements have been added to the Gospels—the story heavily Judaized, and many other symbols and motifs pulled in to transform it—and the narrative has been modified, in structure and content, to suit the Christians’ own moral and spiritual agenda. But the basic structure is not original.
There were, in fact, numerous pre-Christian savior gods who became incarnate and underwent sufferings or trials, even deaths and resurrections.4 None of them actually existed. Neither did Romulus. Yet all were placed in history, and often given detailed biographies. Just like Plutarch’s.
We cannot claim to understand the Christian religion and its documents if we ignore such background knowledge as this. We cannot estimate what was likely or typical unless we know everything relevant we can know about the context of the time, including comparative evidence, from religions and movements of that time and place and religions and movements throughout history.
Knowing the background of the Romulus myths and rituals drastically changes what we will consider possible or likely in the case of Jesus, and yet that’s just one single item. Think how much difference will be made by knowing a hundred such items. We also cannot arrive at accurate judgments if we ignore all the data we actually have from Christianity’s earliest documents, yet many scholars ignore a surprising amount of that data when formulating theories and estimates of likelihood. We can’t do that. We need to attend to as complete and secure a body of background knowledge as possible so we can correctly condition all our probability estimates on it as Bayes’s Theorem requires.5
Background knowledge should consist of facts beyond reasonable dispute. Some of these facts are theoretical, but are so well established from the facts available that we can treat them as tantamount to established facts. Most of this body of material is not specific to Christianity (e.g. the laws of physics), and most that is specific to Christianity is (or ought to be) already well known by experts in Jesus studies. Which is why experts are more qualified to judge theories in ancient history: a thorough knowledge of the evidence and contextual background is necessary to make credible estimates of likelihood (I’ve already said enough about this in Chapter 2 of Proving History). But no one can be an expert in everything. And evaluating claims about Jesus requires understanding the modern science of hallucination and psychosomatic illness, as well as the established findings of modern sociology, psychology and cultural anthropology. But even some of the historical material is surprisingly not known to many experts. I have selected the most important of those elements to present here, which will play a significant part in evaluating the remaining evidence in following chapters. In fact, everything here to follow is what any theory of the origins of Christianity must fit and take into account. For what follows is true regardless of whether Jesus existed as a historical person or not. Hence even a historical Jesus can only be understood in this context.
As I explained in Proving History, in science, usually background knowledge (or b) includes all previous data while evidence (or e) is limited to new data (from a single experiment or study). History only occasionally gets new data. What historians are keen to know is not just whether new data changes what we should believe, but more often what a particular body of evidence warrants believing. And historians examine both questions in terms of causal explanation: determining what happened (the events of history) is a function of determining what caused the evidence we now have, and determining why that happened requires determining what caused the events thus discerned (I provided all the logical demonstrations and explanations of these points in Proving History). Thus what goes in e is ordinarily what historians believe stands in need of a causal explanation (‘How did that evidence come about?’). Everything else goes in b. Data can be moved between these two sets however you desire as long as you are consistent (e.g. what you put in e stays in e throughout a single equation). That this demarcation is arbitrary makes no difference to the method, since the mathematics must work out the same (if it doesn’t, you’ve made a mistake somewhere). Thus some of what follows could be moved from b to e if you so desired, but doing so can make no difference to the final outcome.
I must first define some terms I will frequently use. Other terms I define as I present them, including a few already in Chapter 1, presenting each word in bold where it is defined. These definitions are not intended to be normative. So there is no sense in arguing whether my definitions are ‘right’ or ‘wrong’. They merely specify what I mean when I use those terms, regardless of what anyone else might mean, or what any dictionaries say, or any other conventions. As long as you treat my definitions as nothing more than explanations of what I mean, confusion will be forestalled.
I shall use god to mean any celestial being with supernatural power, and God to mean a supreme creator deity. Though by this definition angels and demons are indeed gods, I’ll sometimes (but not always) use angel or archangel to refer to ‘gods’ that are believed to be acting as messengers or servants of God and demon to refer to ‘gods’ who are believed to be acting in opposition to God (the terminology was already this fluid even among early Christians: e.g. 2 Cor. 4.4; 1 Cor. 8.5; Gal. 4.8-9), although I will also on occasion use ‘demon’ more neutrally in the context of pagan belief (in which there were both good and evil demons, all of whom gods).6 I shall mean by Jesus Christ the name given by the earliest known Christians to a man who was believed to have historically existed (whether on earth or only in heaven—or both) and to have in some sense originated the Christian religion (for the meaning of his name see Chapter 6, §2). I shall mean by Christianity (and all cognate terms) any cult venerating this Jesus Christ as a divine being. And by cult, of course, I do not mean the pejorative but the standard anthropological term for any community of worship distinguished by a system of religious rituals and doctrines.
I shall mean by messiah (the Hebrew word of which ‘Christ’ is a translation) any man in fact, myth, or prophecy who is (a) anointed by the Hebrew God to (b) play a part in God’s plan to liberate his Chosen People from their oppressors and (c) restore or institute God’s true religion. This means ‘anointed’ in any sense then understood (literally, figuratively, cosmically or symbolically), ‘liberate’ in any sense then claimed (physically or spiritually), ‘oppressors’ in any sense then identified (whoever or whatever they may be) and ‘religion’ in the fullest sense (cult, mores, sacred knowledge, and the resulting social order)—and I specify only ‘play a part’, not necessarily bring to fruition. All Jewish kings and high priests were, of course, ‘messiahs’ in the basic sense of being anointed to represent God. But here I shall mean a messiah conforming to (a) through (c). Yet I do not assume there must be only one messiah of that kind. Neither did the Jews (see scholarship cited in Elements 3 and 4).7
I’ve seen some scholars question or deny that the Jews had any prior notion of a messiah before the advent of Christianity. But such a denial is accomplished only by proposing an implausibly hyper-specific definition of ‘messiah’, then showing no such thing was previously imagined, and concluding ‘the Jews had no prior notion of a messiah’. This is a textbook fallacy of equivocation: start with a term defined one way, then end with the same term defined in a completely different way, often without noticing a switch has been made. To avoid this, I shall stick to my minimal definition, since I am certain anyone meeting criteria (a), (b) and (c) would have been regarded by at least some ancient Jews or Judaizers as a messiah. I attach no other baggage to the term—no particular eschatology or scheme of liberation. Jews of antiquity were clearly quite flexible in all such details, as everyone agrees (see Element 2).
I shall mean by crucifixion (and ‘being crucified’ and all other cognate terms and phrases) as any hanging up of the living or dead as a punishment, regardless of the exact details of how. The shape of the cross or fixture, the position of the body, whether the victim is killed first or hung while alive and left to die, even the manner of hanging, whether nailing or lashing, or whether to a rock or tree or stake or doorway or anything else, all of that can (and certainly did) vary, and yet the act still constitutes crucifixion if (a) a body is hanged by anything other than a noose around the neck and (b) this hanging is a punishment. Even the ancient terminology was no more specific than that (in fact it was less so), hence I see no valid reason ours should be.8 For example, the Bible described one method of execution as to ‘hang in the sun’ (in the Septuagint, literally, exēliazō = ex hēliou, ‘out in the sun’, or apenanti tou hēliou, ‘against the sun’), which implies the intent was for the hanged to die from exposure (Num. 25.4 and 2 Sam. 21.6, 9, 13). That is essentially a form of crucifixion, however it was effected. Likewise, when Joshua hung on trees the king of Ai and the kings of the Amorites (Josh. 8.29 and 10.26-27), and when the Law of Moses calls for the executed to be hanged on trees or planks (xulon in the Greek) even when already dead (Deut. 21.22-23), or when Haman and his sons are hung on a giant pole (xulon again in Greek translations of Est. 5.14; 7.9-10; and 8.7, these are all forms of crucifixion. Many scholars of Jewish antiquity agree.9
In using the term ‘crucifixion’ this way I do not mean to rule out finer distinctions for those who want to make them. Someone else, for example, may want to restrict the term to an actual means of killing, thus including only those hung up alive to die, rather than the hanging of corpses. But since I see no contradiction in the idea of crucifying a corpse (and the ancient terminology does not exclude it), I think such a restriction is too fastidious. Since there was no standard practice of crucifixion even among the Romans (we can’t be sure if everyone they crucified was nailed or merely tied up or even impaled, or exactly where or how or to what), if we are too particular we will anachronistically exceed the ideas and vocabulary of the period. The Greek word for crucify (stauroō) literally means ‘staked’ or ‘palisaded’, and frequently meant not just crucified but also impaled, or even setting up spiked walls around a fort. Hence ‘to stake (stauroō) someone on a pole (xulon)’ is what happens in the early Greek translation of Est. 7.9 using the exact same verb used of the crucifixion of Jesus in the New Testament, as well as the exact same word for ‘post’ or ‘tree’ used in the Septuagint text of the old Torah Law (that passage in Deuteronomy), which is also the same word used for the cross and crucifixion of Jesus in the New Testament. Thus, as the ambiguity existed then, I preserve it myself.
I shall mean by resurrection (and all similar terms) any restoration of life to the dead (whether permanent or not), though I shall distinguish when the term is used literally or figuratively. Merely the survival or ascension of an already-immortal soul does not count as a ‘restoration’ in this sense and thus is not a resurrection, but abandoning the corpse altogether and rising to life in a completely new body does count and thus is a resurrection. As with the term ‘messiah’, I’ve seen recent attempts to claim that pagans had no notion of resurrection, again by producing a hyper-specific definition of one particular kind of resurrection, proving they didn’t have or accept it, then concluding they had no notion of resurrection at all. But such specificity did not exist in ancient vocabulary. Many different Jewish and Christian sects believed in many different kinds of resurrection, and all were called ‘resurrection’.10 And there were yet more kinds of resurrection imagined among the pagans, and considerable overlap between their ideas and those of the Jews and Christians.11 I shall thus avoid any fallacy of anachronistic precision by using all words for ‘resurrection’ to mean just what they meant to everyone in antiquity, whether pagan, Jew, or Christian: rising from a state of death to be alive again. Nothing more.
I shall mean by outer space everything above the atmosphere as presently known. In ancient understanding this included (a) everything in or under the ‘firmament’ (also known as the aēr or ‘sublunar sphere’) extending above the highest visible clouds all the way to the orbit of the moon, and (b) all the heavens beyond (also then known as the ‘ether’ or ‘ethereal realm’). The notion that any of this region may have been a vacuum did exist at the time, but only as a controversial theory rejected by most religious cosmologists, and only embraced typically by atomists and others generally hostile to the supernatural. Most people of the time thought the aēr extended all the way to the moon (while everything beyond that was filled with a breathable ‘ether’), when in fact (as we now know) the real atmosphere extends only a minuscule fraction of that distance.
So when they spoke of beings and events ‘in the air’, they were often speaking of what we mean by outer space. This is even more obvious when they spoke of beings and events in the spheres of heaven above the moon. Accordingly, if an ancient author was speaking of what we call outer space, I will say ‘outer space’. This does not mean I attribute to them a modern knowledge of the extraterrestrial vacuum. It only means they were thinking of realms beyond the terrestrial domains of mountains, clouds, and birds. For it was already common knowledge among the educated of the time that the moon’s distance from the earth was hundreds of thousands of miles (see Element 34). So when they used terms that we often translate as ‘air’, they were often not referring to what we mean by ‘the air’ today but a far more vast and frightening realm of fantastic possibilities, which many thought was trafficked by gods and filled with strange animals or spirits (see Elements 36-38).
I shall use gospel for the general idea of the ‘good news’ or ‘salvific message’ that any group of Christians (or other savior cult) may have preached (and which may have varied in content from group to group), and Gospel for the actual written books of that title or genre (which attempted to convey ‘a gospel’ in some fashion or other). In accordance with growing convention, I shall also use Septuagint or the abbreviation lxx to mean, in fact, the translation of the OT into Greek made by the Jewish scholar Theodotion in the second century (whereas previous to Christianity was the similar but not always identical Old Greek translation, which is no longer completely extant); and I’ll use NT and OT for New Testament and Old Testament, respectively. I shall also use church to mean any Christian congregation (regardless of sect or state of organization) and the church as a stand-in for the whole Christian movement (in all its diversity), and Church to mean any major regional Christian institution (or all of them collectively) that had the political power to force compliance and suppress heresy among its own adherents. By this definition the Coptic, Eastern Orthodox, and Catholic Churches became the most prominent and powerful Churches, but Churches in this sense didn’t likely exist anywhere until the second century at the earliest. Before that ‘the church’ only consisted of diverse and loosely affiliated ‘churches’.
I shall use orthodox or orthodoxy to refer to all the churches, literature, and institutions (and their ideologies and interpretations) that eventually evolved over the course of the fourth century ce into the politically victorious sects that we now call Churches or the Church. I shall use heretical (and all related terms) for all other churches. Though no church of those later periods much resembled any churches of the first and second centuries (as most scholars agree, Christian ideology, institutions and beliefs had by then changed considerably), the consolidated sects that would later call their view ‘orthodoxy’ (and all others ‘heresy’) did each evolve from one particular lineage of the era (albeit with continual cross-fertilization with other Christian sects and pagan cults), and then kept or altered documents from that era that supported that, and destroyed or abandoned documents that did not, creating a selection bias in the preservation of literature that bears a particular (albeit anachronistic and often inconsistent) sectarian stamp (see Elements 20-21 and 44).
So when I speak of an orthodox sect in the first two centuries, I do not mean the sect that was closer or more faithful to the originating traditions of the religion. I believe all sects deviated from the original religion and innovated freely and in equal measure, and the victorious Churches of the early Middle Ages looked nothing at all like the original faith of Peter or even Paul. Rather, I mean the sects that evolved into those later Churches, bearing the closest ancestral relationship to them, in ideology and institutional continuity. Thus, I am not endorsing any Church’s claim to ‘orthodoxy’ (‘right doctrine’), nor am I using terms like ‘heretical’ pejoratively, but rather acknowledging that a small handful of Churches (such as the Orthodox, Coptic, and Catholic) gained dominance in certain regions and then called themselves ‘orthodox’. None of these Churches sprang out of nowhere, but all evolved from earlier sects that bear a closer resemblance to them than other sects did, and their selection, modification and endorsement of documents reflects what they chose to call ‘orthodoxy’. Hence, for convenience, so shall I.
Finally, my publisher requires me to employ bce (‘Before the Common Era’) and ce (‘Common Era’) in lieu of of bc (‘Before Christ’) and ad (‘Anno Domini’ = ‘In the Year of the Lord’), even though in my own opinion the original notation is more familiar and there is no good reason to change it.12
4. Elemental Background Knowledge
To make my assumptions more transparent, I will survey the often less-well-known background knowledge I shall be relying on in later chapters, and break it down into units or ‘elements’ that can be tested or debated individually. When elements agree with the near-universal consensus of contemporary scholarship I won’t exhaust any effort to survey the evidence but merely present them as given. I do not assume such elements are beyond any possibility of debate, only that the evidence is such that the burden must be on anyone who would deny them. The remaining elements I will demonstrate to be true with an adequate citation of evidence and scholarship, only because I keep encountering experts who deny them or don’t know of them (even when a majority of experts already agree with me).13 More elements will be enumerated in the next chapter (and we must add to all these the background facts already presented in the three chapters before and the six chapters after).
As I explained in Chapter 1, some readers might prefer to skip the rest of this and the next chapter, and only return to them later. Alternatively, you may be content to read only the first paragraph of every element—continuing only if you disagree with what is asserted there or want to see why I conclude it’s true (otherwise moving on to the next numbered element). Crucially, none of these elements assume or entail historicity is true or false, they are all compatible with both. They simply must all be taken into account when evaluating either.
5. Elements of Christian Origin
Element 1: The earliest form of Christianity definitely known to us originated as a Jewish sect in the region of Syria-Palestine in the early first century ce. Some historians would challenge this, but their theories have yet to survive peer review or persuade anything near a consensus agreement among experts. Rather than prove it true here, I will simply state it as a given fact of our background knowledge, to be revised only if it is clearly disproved.
Element 2: When Christianity began, Judaism was highly sectarian and diverse. There was no ‘normative’ set of Jewish beliefs, but a countless array of different Jewish belief systems vying for popularity. We know of at least ten competing sects, possibly more than thirty, and there could easily have been more. But we know very little about them, except that they differed from one another (sometimes radically) on various political, theological, metaphysical, moral and other issues. In fact the evidence we do have establishes that, contrary to common assumption, innovation and syncretism (even with non-Judaic theologies) was actually typical of early-first-century Judaism, even in Palestine, and thus Christianity looks much less like an aberration and more like just another innovating, syncretistic Jewish cult.14 Further support for this point is provided in Elements 30 and 33. No argument, therefore, can proceed from an assumption of any universally normative Judaism.
Element 3: (a) When Christianity began, many Jews had long been expecting a messiah: a divinely chosen leader or savior anointed (literally or figuratively ‘christened’, hence a ‘Christ’) to help usher in God’s supernatural kingdom, usually (but not always) by subjugating or destroying the enemies of the Jews and establishing an eternal paradise (see previous definition in §3, and following discussion in Elements 4 and 5). (b) We can reasonably infer that if those ‘enemies’ were ever considered to be invisible demons (rather than the actual Roman legions, for example) the way would have been open to imagine a messianic victory over Israel’s enemies that could only be perceived spiritually (see Element 28). Otherwise the messiah was typically expected to achieve a transparent military victory. Sometimes (as in the Enochic literature) it was both. (c) That Jewish expectations of some kind of messiah in the early Roman Empire were widespread, influential, and very diverse (and thus incapable of being fixed to any single view) has been well established by experts on ancient messianism.15
Element 4: (a) Palestine in the early first century ce was experiencing a rash of messianism. There was an evident clamoring of sects and individuals to announce they had found the messiah. (b) It is therefore no oddity or accident that this is exactly when Christianity arose. It was yet another messiah cult in the midst of a fad for just such cults. (c) That it among them would alone survive and spread can therefore be the product of natural selection: so many variations of the same theme were being tried, odds are one of them would by chance be successful, hitting all the right notes and dodging all the right bullets. The lucky winner in that contest just happened to be Christianity.16
This element is often denied, or its basis not well understood, so I will pause to establish it before moving on. ‘Messiah’, ‘Son of Man’, ‘the Righteous One’, and ‘the Elect [or Chosen] One’ were all popular titles for the expected messiah used by several groups in early-first-century Judaism, as attested, for instance, in the Book of the Parables of Enoch, a Jewish text composed before 70 ce.17 The Dead Sea Scrolls attest to one or several such cults around that same time. Indeed, messianic apocalypticism was intense at Qumran, where the keepers of the scrolls were already expecting the imminent end of the world, and attempting different calculations from the timetable provided in the book of Daniel (see Element 7) to predict when the first messiah would come—and many of their calculations came up ‘soon’. The early first century ce was in their prediction window.18 And many of their texts were used by other cults of the time. A copy of the so-called Damascus Document, for instance, turns up a thousand years later in a stash of Jewish texts at Cairo Geniza.19
Even the early-first-century Jewish philosopher Philo of Alexandria wrote an apocalyptic text sharing and adapting the messianic expectations of his generation.20 The Gospels likewise assume (or, depending on how much you trust them, report) that ‘messiah fever’ was so rampant in Judea then that countless people were expecting Elijah to be walking among them, some even believed that Jesus, or John the Baptist, was that very man, risen from the dead, which many Jews believed presaged the imminent coming of a messiah and the ensuing end of the present world order (which many believed had become corrupted beyond human repair), because this had been predicted in Mal. 4.5-6, the very last passage of the traditional OT.21
The only surviving historian of early-first-century Palestine confirms this picture. Josephus records the rise and popularity of several false messiahs in the same general period as Christianity was getting started. He does not explicitly call them messiahs—he probably wanted to avoid reminding his Gentile audience that this was the product of Jewish ideology, and instead claimed it was the product of fringe criminals and ruffians (he likewise catalogues various other rebel bandits and demagogues as well). But the descriptions he provides belie the truth of the matter. As David Rhoads put it, ‘Josephus tends to avoid messianism when he relates the history of the first century’; in fact he deliberately ‘suppressed the religious motivations of the revolutionaries by ascribing [to them] evil and dishonorable intentions’ instead. But their messianic basis remains unmistakable. Scholarly analysis confirms this.22 Josephus recounts at least four messianic figures of the early first century, and documents how enormously popular they were, compelling the Romans to mass military action to suppress them.23
‘The Samaritan’ gathered followers and said he would reveal the lost relics of the true Samaritan temple on Mount Gerizim—an act with obvious messianic meaning (the Samaritans believing themselves to be the true Jews; this is alluded to even in Jn 4.20-26, which attests the Samaritans also expected an imminent messiah). The original Jewish congregation led by Joshua had stood at God’s command ‘upon Mount Gerizim to bless the people’ after crossing the Jordan (Deut. 27.12), which is to say, when Joshua (the original Jesus—the names are identical: see Chapter 6, §3) crossed the Jordan on the day the nation of Israel was conceptually begun. Thus, the original Joshua inaugurated the nation of Israel by crossing the Jordan and congregating at Gerizim; and since the last messiah (the new Joshua) was to reconstitute Israel, he, too, could expect to begin the task by a blessing on Mount Gerizim.
‘Theudas’ gathered followers and said he would part the Jordan—another act with obvious messianic meaning: Joshua (the original Jesus) had also miraculously parted the Jordan upon beginning his conquest of Israel (Joshua 3), so this was another obvious symbolic starting point for the re-conquest of Israel. Similarly, the Christian Jesus (again, ‘Joshua’) is depicted as beginning his messianic career by symbolically parting (or passing through) the Jordan, in the form of his baptism.
‘The Egyptian’ (possibly a Jewish cult leader from Alexandria) also gathered followers and preached from the Mount of Olives (just as Jesus Christ does in the Gospels), claiming he would topple the walls of Jerusalem—an obvious allusion to the miraculous felling of the walls of Jericho, another deed of the first Jesus (the biblical Joshua), in fact in the first battle that followed his crossing of the Jordan, making this another symbol of beginning the conquest of Israel. Preaching from the Mount of Olives could also imply messianic pretensions—as it was commonly believed a messiah would stand there in the last days (Zech. 14.1-9). Thus, the Egyptian was preaching another metaphor for the re-conquest of Israel, again the very task only the Christ was expected to accomplish. Indeed, as Craig Evans argues, even the very name ‘Egyptian’ evokes the out-of-Egypt path of the original Joshua (hence ‘Jesus’).
Another (unnamed) ‘impostor’ mentioned by Josephus (‘impostor’ being obvious code for ‘false messiah’—who else would he be pretending to be?) gathered followers and promised them salvation if they followed him into the wilderness—an obvious reference to Moses, and, as Craig Evans shows, this ‘impostor’ created symbolic allusions to the temptation narrative in Exodus, promising rest in the wilderness and deliverance from evil. So just as those who tempted God in the wilderness lost their God-promised rest, those who ritually reversed this behavior could expect to see the restoration of God’s promise.24 The messianic intentions are evident here.
This means all four of these messiahs, as reported by Josephus, were equating themselves with Jesus (Joshua) and making veiled claims to be the Christ (messiah). In other words, here we have in Josephus four Jesus Christs. Ours simply makes five. The Gospel character of Jesus thus fits right into the trend documented by Josephus.25
Even ‘John the Baptist’ (at least as depicted in the Gospels) was a messianic figure (e.g. Jn 1.20; Lk. 3.15), or otherwise telling everyone the messiah would arrive in his lifetime (Mt. 3.1-12; Mk 1.1-8; Lk. 3.1-20; Jn 1.15-28). And he was enormously popular (the Gospels and Acts claim so, and Josephus confirms it), thus further exemplifying the trend of the time. This messianic Baptist cult may even have influenced or spawned Christianity itself (see Element 33). The cult of Simon Magus might likewise have been promoting its own messiah. Acts certainly depicts Simon Magus as a messianic pretender (Acts 8.9-11), again with enormous popularity, just like the others in Josephus. The historicity of this Simon has been questioned, but the historicity of his worship as a divine being has not.26 If the biblical account of him reflects the truth (of the historical man or the celestial demigod he once was) he would be another example confirming the same trend.
Even skeptical scholars agree there were many pretenders who:
[D]o not simply announce the will of God but (a) lead actions of deliverance (b) involving ‘revolutionary changes’ (c) in accord with God’s ‘design’ and (d) corresponding to one of the great historical formative acts of deliverance led by Moses or Joshua.27
There were other messianic pretenders after the first Jewish War as well. But already across the whole generation before that war numerous self-proclaimed ‘messiahs’ were gathering followers and making claims of miraculous powers and the coming end of the world-order at this very time, and we have no reason to assume Josephus has given us accounts of them all, only the most famous or a representative sample. Notably, again, all whom he recorded accounts of were pretending to be a new Jesus (‘Joshua’). Jesus would thus be symbolically recognized as a messianic name (see Chapter 6, §3; and Element 6). And all of them reenact Exodus-like events. Even John the Baptist is exploiting Exodus symbolism by baptizing in the Jordan: the waterway crossed from death to life (from the slavery of Egypt to the paradise of the Holy Land—by way of ‘the wilderness’ in between), using in his own case a baptismal re-birthing ceremony. In everyone’s view the messiah was to free the Jews from slavery. The Exodus narrative was an obvious and popular model for that. Hence the fact that the Exodus is often a key motif in the NT suggests similar thinking.
It is reasonable to infer that once the literal, militaristic versions of this idea had been seen to fail (or indeed to be impossible, given the unstoppable might of the legions), it would not be unthinkable to adapt the same idea to being freed from the slavery not of the Romans or the corrupt Jewish elite, but the slavery of invisible demons (and death itself) instead. Anyone who took that step would essentially end up with a movement like Christianity (see Elements 23-28). For the ‘gospel’ of Jesus was already seen as the symbolic Exodus ritual and narrative for every Christian’s escape from exactly that kind of spiritual slavery (e.g. Romans 7–8; 1 Corinthians 10). The only question is whether this Jesus was a real messianic pretender just like all these others, part of an established widespread trend (into which he would fit very well), who also failed just as they did, being killed by the authorities just as they were, but whose surviving followers merely came up with a successful way to repackage and sell his ideas, turning him into a spiritually victorious messiah, after his superficially material defeat—or whether Jesus was a spiritually conceived messiah right from the beginning.28
Regardless, all the evidence is clear enough on the general fact of the matter: the first century had exploded with messianic fervor, to the point that it’s not at all surprising one of these countless new messianic cults would become more successful than the rest (the others being wiped out or not adopting the right mix of popular attributes), even standing a fair chance of becoming a world religion (as any successful cult has a shot at doing). And Christianity is exactly such a messianic cult (as later elements establish), arising exactly when such cults were popular, and in the very same place.
Element 5: Even before Christianity arose, some Jews expected one of their messiahs heralding the end times would actually be killed, rather than be immediately victorious, and this would mark the key point of a timetable guaranteeing the end of the world soon thereafter. Such a concept was therefore not a Christian novelty wholly against the grain of Jewish thinking, but already exactly what some Jews were thinking—or could easily have thought. This is the most controversial element in our background knowledge, many scholars being so intent on denying it. So I must discuss the evidence at some length, although I shall do this more thoroughly elsewhere.29
First, the Talmud provides us with a proof of concept at the very least (and actual confirmation at the very most). It explicitly says the suffering servant who dies in Isaiah 53 is the messiah (and that this messiah will endure great suffering before his death).30 The Talmud likewise has a dying-and-rising ‘Christ son of Joseph’ ideology in it, even saying (quoting Zech. 12.10) that this messiah will be ‘pierced’ to death.31 Modern scholars are too quick to dismiss this text as late (dating as it does from the fourth to sixth century), since the doctrine it describes is unlikely to be. For only when Jews had no idea what Christians would do with this connection would they themselves have promoted it. There is no plausible way later Jews would invent interpretations of their scripture that supported and vindicated Christians. They would not invent a Christ with a father named Joseph who dies and is resurrected (as the Talmud does indeed describe). They would not proclaim Isaiah 53 to be about this messiah and admit that Isaiah had there predicted this messiah would die and be resurrected. That was the very biblical passage Christians were using to prove their case. Moreover, the presentation of this ideology in the Talmud makes no mention of Christianity and gives no evidence of being any kind of polemic or response to it. So we have evidence here of a Jewish belief that possibly predates Christian evangelizing, even if that evidence survives only in later sources.
The alternative is to assume a rather unbelievable coincidence: that Christians and Jews, completely independently of each other, just happened at some point to see Isaiah 53 as messianic and from that same passage preach an ideology of a messiah with a father named Joseph (literally or symbolically), who endures great suffering, dies and is resurrected (all in accord with the savior depicted in Isaiah 53, as by then understood). Such an amazing coincidence is simply improbable. But a causal connection is not: if this was a pre-Christian ideology that influenced (and thus caused) both the Christian and the Jewish ideologies, then we have only one element to explain (the rise of this idea once, being adapted in different ways), instead of having to believe the same idea arose twice, purely coincidentally. Two improbable events by definition are many times less likely than one.32 That means the invented-once theory is many times more likely than the invented-twice one. Conversely, if we choose instead to fall on this sword of improbability and insist, against all likelihood, that yes, the same ideas arose twice independently of each other within Judaism, then this entails the idea was very easy for Jews to arrive at (since rabbinical Jews, independently of Christians, clearly arrived at it), which then entails it was not an improbable development in the first place. And thus neither will it have been improbable for Christians (or their sectarian predecessors among the Jews), any more than it was for Talmudic Jews. Clearly dying messiahs were not anathema. Rabbinical Jews could be just as comfortable with the idea as Christians were (more on this point in Chapter 12, §4).
This dying-messiah doctrine is not only found in the Talmud but is more considerably spelled out in the seventh-century Apocalypse of Zerubbabel (Sefer Zerubbabel), which likewise prophesies that there will be two messiahs, a Messiah ben David and a Messiah ben Joseph, and that the latter messiah (the Son of Joseph) would come first and be killed by an evil tyrant named Armilus (whom some scholars conjecture is a Hebraicism for Romulus, i.e., Rome). But all would not be lost, because the second messiah (the Son of David) would soon appear and resurrect him, and the end of the world would soon follow.33
Quite simply, if anyone were to merge these two messiahs into a single person (the Son of Joseph and the Son of David, one who dies and rises and one who returns to bring victory), we would have Christianity: a messiah fathered by a Joseph who is killed by an evil power and is then resurrected and anointed ‘the Son of David’, destined to return triumphant. It is far more likely that Christians united two figures already imagined in earlier Jewish apocalyptic thought than that rabbinical Jews took a novel messiah from the heretical sect of Christianity and elaborately split it into two messiahs, with otherwise all the same attributes (and then make no mention of how this responds to Christianity or why they would even do that).34
But the Talmud and the Apocalypse of Zerubbabel are not our only evidence of a pre-Christian dying-messiah theme. The book of Daniel (written well before the rise of Christianity) explicitly says a messiah will die shortly before the end of the world (Dan. 9.2; 9.24-27; cf. 12.1-13). This is already conclusive. Given my definition of ‘messiah’ (in §3), Christianity looks exactly like an adaptation of the same eschatological dying-messiah motif in Daniel. And the Wisdom of Solomon, an important scripture to the first Christians, presents a son of God who is despised, killed, resurrected and crowned as a king in heaven (cf. 2.12-22; 5.1-23), a narrative that could easily have been taken by some as referring to the messiah—and even if not, it certainly established a heroic model that one could adapt into a dying messiah already within pre-Christian Judaism, which would thus already be intelligible to Jews. This Wisdom of Solomon archetype could even have been associated with the despised-and-dying servant of Isaiah 53, as they sound quite similar (innocent righteous men humiliated and killed by the wicked, but exalted and made triumphant). Isaiah 53 was already understood to contain an atonement–martyrdom framework applicable to dying heroes generally.35 And the whole concept of a suffering, martyred hero was an established Jewish archetype (see Element 43).
But of the more specific notion of a dying messiah, we also have other pre-Christian evidence in the form of a Dead Sea Scroll designated 11Q13, the Melchizedek Scroll.36 This is an apocalyptic pesher, a document attempting to discover hidden messages in the scriptures by finding secret links among disparate and previously unrelated verses (see Elements 8 and 16), which together communicate God’s plan, most commonly (and certainly in this case) his plans for the coming messiah, the defeat of evil and the end of the world. There are many such pesherim at Qumran. But this one tells us about the ‘messenger’ of Isaiah 52–53 who is linked in Isaiah with a ‘servant’ who will die to atone for everyone’s sins (presaging God’s final victory), which (as we have already seen) later Jews definitely regarded as the messiah. At Qumran, 11Q13 appears to say that this messenger is the same man as the ‘messiah’ of Daniel 9, who dies around the same time an end to sin is said to be accomplished (again presaging God’s final victory), and that the day on which this happens will be a great and final Day of Atonement, absolving the sins of all the elect, after which (11Q13 goes on to say) God and his savior will overthrow all demonic forces. And all this will proceed according to the timetable in Daniel 9. Thus, 11Q13 appears to predict that a messiah will die and that this will mark the final days before which God’s agent(s) will defeat Belial (Satan) and atone for the sins of the elect.
Not all scholars have recognized this in 11Q13 or conceded it. Though I find no sound basis for rejecting it, I’ll endeavor to prove it elsewhere.37 Regardless of how one chooses to understand the text of 11Q13, we still have Dan. 9.24-27, which is already unmistakably clear in predicting that a messiah will die shortly before the end of the world, when all sins will be forgiven; and Isaiah 53 is unmistakably clear in declaring that all sins will be forgiven by the death of God’s servant, whom the Talmud identifies as the messiah. So there is no reasonable basis for denying that some pre-Christian Jews would have expected at least one dying messiah, and some could well have expected his death to be an essential atoning death, just as the Christians believed of Jesus (Element 10).
Even apart from 11Q13 there is evidence the Dead Sea community may have already been thinking this, since one of their manuscripts of Isaiah explicitly says the suffering servant figure in Isaiah 53 shall be ‘anointed’ by God and then ‘pierced through for our transgressions’.38 Contrary to modern rhetoric, there is no actual evidence that Jews would have rejected such a notion (as I explain in Chapter 12, §4). Neither was such a thing incompatible with expectations of a victorious messiah, since God’s righteous were always expected to be resurrected, which included the messiah, and accordingly the earliest Christians expected their dying messiah to soon return victorious, even imagining his resurrection had already occurred to signal the end was nigh, being in fact ‘the firstfruits’ of the apocalyptic resurrection of the whole world (1 Cor. 15.20-23) and signaling his messianic victory over the powers of darkness (Element 37).
This should not surprise us. Even the original forgers of Daniel 9 were already imagining something along these lines. Modern scholars are generally agreed that its authors were saying that the then-high-priest Onias III was a Messiah (a Christ), and his death would presage a universal atonement, after which would come the end of the world—effected by the coming of the angel Michael.39 That’s already just one or two tweaks away from the Christian gospel. One of those tweaks would be simply equating the messiah who dies with the savior who returns to complete God’s plan (in other words, once again, combining the two figures into one): the second of which in Daniel is, again, the archangel Michael, called ‘the great prince’ in Dan. 12.1, whom a later interpreter could easily read as being the same ‘prince’ of Dan. 9.26-27 (the words are not identical but have a corresponding meaning), because the events of Dan. 12.9-12 are the same events, yet are assumed to follow the event of Michael’s ‘rising’ in 12.1 (which in the lxx employs exactly the same word used of Jesus’ resurrection in Mk 9.31 and 10.34). So it could appear Michael was meant to be the ‘prince’ in Dan. 9.26-27. Because in Dan. 12.9-12 Michael is the one doing the things the ‘prince’ does in Dan. 9.26-27.
That this Michael is ‘the resurrected messiah’ would thus have been an easy inference for a later interpreter to make, in which event 9.25-26 could easily be read as being not about a Christ and a Prince but a Princely Christ, all one and the same person, who dies (9.26) and then rises from the dead (9.26-27 and 12.1). The Christian gospel is thus already right there in Daniel, the more so if Daniel 9 had been linked with Isaiah 52–53, which is exactly what 11Q13 appears to do. But even without such a connection being made, the notion that a Christ was expected to die to presage the end of the world is already clearly intended in Daniel, even by its original authors’ intent, and would have been understood in the same way by subsequent readers of Daniel. The notion of a dying messiah was therefore already mainstream, well before Christianity arose. That this messiah did not correspond to any specific definition of any specific kind of messiah is not relevant, since we know the Jews had many diverse notions of a messiah, and frequently innovated.
Once the idea was out there, there would be no getting that cat back into the bag. In Daniel’s originally intended case, the end of the world did not come (in fact everything after the death of its intended messiah did not occur as the forgers’ prophecy predicted), so later Jews had only two options: either reject Daniel as a false prophecy (and we know the Jews who initiated Christianity had not done that) or conclude ‘Daniel’ wasn’t talking about Onias III but some other messiah in the future (necessitating attempts to reinterpret the 490-year timetable in Dan. 9.24 to figure out what time in history Daniel was actually talking about), which is clearly what many Jews did—the author of 11Q13 in particular. In other words, the authors of Daniel were plainly saying, and by many were read as saying, that the last Christ was to die—shortly before the final end when God’s chosen agent (in Daniel, the archangel Michael; in 11Q13, Melchizedek) would descend from heaven, defeat the forces of evil once and for all, and resurrect the dead. This means many Jews were expecting a dying messiah, as a sign the end was nigh.
I believe the force of all these arguments is strong, and resistance to them can only at this point be blindly dogmatic. But even if scholars remain obstinate against an established fact of a pre-Christian dying-christology, in the face of the same evidence they can no longer insist upon its implausibility. Because even if you are uncertain of the fact of it, this same evidence still conclusively proves that the proposition ‘Christianity arose from a sect of Jews that came to expect a dying messiah’ is a plausible hypothesis, even if we can’t prove such a sect existed, because (a) we know there were many diverse sects of Jews with many diverse notions against the leading orthodoxy, and we know nothing about most of them (Element 2); therefore (b) an argument from silence to the conclusion ‘no such sect existed’ cannot be sustained;40 whereas (c) the scriptural inspiration and logic for such an idea is easily discerned (so easy, in fact, that Talmudic Jews also discerned it)—and if it’s easy for us, it would have been easy for at least someone to have noticed it during centuries of hundreds of Jewish scholars and sectarians scrambling to look for God’s secret messages in scripture (Element 8). That later Talmudic Jews hit upon essentially the same conclusions verifies the point.
This means that in logical terms, ‘Christianity arose from a sect of Jews that came to expect a dying messiah’ is a plausible hypothesis that we can then test against the evidence. Because there is no evidence against that hypothesis or its plausibility. So if it explains the evidence better than alternatives, then it is more probably true than alternatives (and as a hypothesis it’s already more likely than, e.g., ‘Christians only started believing this because Jesus actually rose from the dead’). We therefore do not require direct evidence of ‘there was a sect of Jews that came to expect a dying messiah’. Because if all other evidence is better explained by that proposition, then that other evidence is evidence for that proposition. Such indirect inference is routine in historical argument. That Henry assassinated William II is a hypothesis, which we can argue for from whether it better explains the evidence of what subsequently happened, without requiring a confession by Henry or an eyewitness to the deed.41
Since we lack evidence detailing the beliefs of dozens of Jewish sects, and no evidence at all naming (much less describing in detail) which sect Christianity grew out of (e.g. what sect Peter was most enamored with or devoted to before he joined or launched the movement; or, on a historicist thesis, what sect or sects Jesus originally came from or was educated in; or even what sects Paul was influenced by, if any before the Christian sect, that led him to abandon the Pharisee sect). So we know it’s very likely we won’t have evidence of such a thing as that the sect Christianity grew out of was already expecting a dying messiah.42 Thus, whether it was or not is either unknowable (in which case it can’t be denied as a possibility nor even declared an improbability) or can be inferred from evidence we do have: such as that the crucifixion of the Christian messiah was always said to have been discovered in scripture (1 Cor. 15.3-4 and Rom. 16.25-26), combined with all the evidence we have surveyed here, from the book of Daniel, the Talmud, the Sefer Zerubbabel, and the Melchizedek Scroll.
I believe this amounts to ample evidence that at least some pre-Christian Jews were expecting a dying messiah to presage the end of the world; and even should anyone reject that conclusion, it still cannot be denied that the hypothesis (that some pre-Christian Jews were expecting a dying messiah to presage the end of the world) is at least plausible enough to take seriously, given all that same evidence. Its prior probability simply cannot be established as low, and from the evidence here surveyed, it looks more likely to be high.
Element 6: The suffering-and-dying servant of Isaiah 52–53 and the messiah of Daniel 9 (which, per the previous element, may already have been seen by some Jews as the same person) have numerous logical connections with a man in Zechariah 3 and 6 named ‘Jesus Rising’ who is confronted by Satan in God’s abode in heaven and there crowned king, given all of God’s authority, holds the office of high priest, and will build up ‘God’s house’ (which is how Christians described their church).43
In the Septuagint text, Zechariah is commanded in a vision to place the crown of kingship upon ‘Jesus’ (Zech. 6.11) and to say immediately upon doing so that ‘Jehovah declares’ that this Jesus is ‘the man named “Rising” and he shall rise up from his place below and he shall build the House of the Lord’. The key noun is anatolē, which is often translated ‘East’ because it refers to where the sun rises (hence ‘East’), but such a translation obscures the fact that the actual word used is the noun ‘rising’ or ‘rise’ (as in ‘sunrise’), which was not always used in reference to a compass point, and whose real connotations are more obvious when translated literally. In fact by immediately using the cognate verb ‘to rise up’ (anatelei, and that explicitly ‘from his place below’) it’s clear the Septuagint translator understood the word to mean ‘rise’ (and Philo echoes the same pun in his interpretation, and thus also understood: see Element 40). We know Zechariah meant this in some way to be Jesus ben Jehozadak, the legendary first high priest of the second temple (as I’ll discuss shortly). But by implying this event may have occurred in heaven, interpreters could think differently. And we know some did (Element 40).
If this ‘Jesus Rising’ were connected to the dying servant who atones for all sins in Isaiah (and perhaps also with Daniel or 11Q13), it would be easy to read out of this almost the entire core Christian gospel. Connecting the two figures in just that way would be natural to do: this same ‘Jesus’ who is named ‘Rising’ (or, in both places, ‘Branch’ in the extant Hebrew, as in ‘Davidic heir’, or so both contexts imply) appears earlier in Zechariah 3, where ‘Jesus’ is also implied to be the one called ‘Rising’ (in 3.8). Both are also called ‘Jesus the high priest’ throughout Zechariah 3 and 6, hence clearly the same person. And there he is also called God’s ‘servant’. And it is said that through him (in some unspecified way) all sin in the world will be cleansed ‘in a single day’ (Zech. 3.9). Both concepts converge with Isaiah 52–53, which is also about God’s ‘servant’, whose death cleanses the world’s sins (Isa. 52.13 and 53.11), which of course would thus happen in a single day (as alluded in Isa. 52.6). And as we saw earlier, Jews may have been linking this dying ‘servant’ to the dying ‘Christ’ killed in Daniel 9 (in 11Q13), whose death is also said to correspond closely with a conclusive ‘end of sin’ in the world (Dan. 9.24-26), and both figures (in Daniel and 11Q13) were linked to an expected ‘atonement in a single day’ after a period of 490 years, whose starting point one needed only to discover in order to predict the end of the world (see Element 5).
These dots are so easily connected, and with such convincing force for anyone enamored of the thought process generating the Jewish pesherim as a literary genre, that it would be astonishing if no Jews had thought of this. Not ever, by anyone, in the whole of their fevered composition of pesherim? (See Element 8.) That seems quite improbable. Nevertheless, I am not here declaring Christianity was born from making this connection, only that it is certainly plausible to hypothesize it was.44 I will provide further evidence for that being the case in Element 40, where Christian and Jewish theology also coincide at exactly this point, but here I am concerned only with the existence of the scriptural coincidences, which definitely predated Christianity in public documents used as sacred scripture by all Jews, and thus by all would-be founders of Christianity.
As I mentioned, an ‘exoteric’ reading of Zechariah 3 and 6 would conclude the author originally meant the first high priest of the second temple, Jesus ben Jehozadak (Zech. 6.11; cf. Hag. 1.1), who somehow came into an audience with God, in a coronation ceremony (one would presume in heaven, as it is in audience with God and his angels and attended by Satan) granting him supreme supernatural power over the universe (Zech. 3.7). But such a scene hardly seems descriptive of any living person, and would more readily be ‘esoterically’ read as being about a celestial being named Jesus (as in fact we know it was, Philo of Alexandria having made exactly this inference: see Element 40), who was given by God supreme authority over the universe in defiance of Satan (Zech. 3.1-2). As it happens, the name Jehozadak means in Hebrew ‘Jehovah the Righteous’, so one could also read this as ‘Jesus, the son of Jehovah the Righteous’, and thereby conclude this is really ‘Jesus, the son of God’.
This is notable considering the evidence we have of a preexistent son of God named Jesus in pre-Christian Jewish theology, connected with this very passage (discussed in Element 40). The fact that in his coronation scene his dirty rags are replaced with magnificent raiment in heaven (Zech. 3.3-5) could also have been read as a resurrection metaphor, such a change of garments being a common metaphor for that at the time.45 But even without that assumption, if this Jesus had ever been connected in previous (but now lost) pesherim with the dying Christ figure in Isaiah and Daniel (by linking them all through Zech. 3.8-9), then we would have a man who dies and is then named Rising and said to ‘rise’ (just like Michael the Prince in Daniel) in order to be given all power and authority (which would imply a resurrection more than sufficiently to almost any Jew of the day) and who somehow conclusively atones for all sins in a single day.
The significance of this is that if such a connection had been made, the connector would have before him, in a simple pesher of Jewish scripture, a celestial being named Jesus Christ Rising, a high priest of God, in opposition to Satan, who is wrongly executed even though innocent, and dies to atone for all sins, is buried and subsequently ‘raised’, exalted to the highest station in heaven, appointed king with supreme heavenly power by God, and who will then build God’s house (the church). That sounds exactly like Christianity. And all from connecting just three passages in the OT that already have distinctive overlapping similarities. Such a coincidence cannot be ignored; it must be included in our background knowledge. Would Christians really have been that lucky, that all this connected so obviously? Or are we seeing here where the whole idea of the Christian gospel came from in the first place?
Element 7: (a) The pre-Christian book of Daniel was a key messianic text, laying out what would happen and when, partly inspiring much of the very messianic ferver of the age, which by the most obvious (but not originally intended) interpretation predicted the messiah’s arrival in the early first century, even (by some calculations) the very year of 30 ce. (b) This text was popularly known and widely influential, and was known and regarded as scripture by the early Christians.
This fact is already attested by the many copies and commentaries on Daniel recovered from Qumran,46 but it’s evident also in the fact that the Jewish War itself may have been partly a product of it. As at Qumran, the key inspiring text was the messianic timetable described in the book of Daniel (in Dan. 9.23-27). By various calculations this could be shown to predict, by the very Word of God, that the messiah would come sometime in the early first century ce. Several examples of these calculations survive in early Christian literature, the clearest appearing in Julius Africanus in the third century.47 The date there calculated is precisely 30 ce; hence it was expected on this calculation (which was simple and straightforward enough that anyone could easily have come up with the same result well before the rise of Christianity) that a messiah would arise and be killed in that year (as we saw Daniel had ‘predicted’ in 9.26: see Element 5), which is an obvious basis for setting the gospel story precisely then (I’ll revisit this point later on here and in Chapter 8), or else a basis for believing that, of all messianic claimants, ‘our’ Jesus Christ was the one for real.
For all of this to be coincidence is unlikely. Different calendars and calculations might have given slightly different years, but every straightforward calculation falls around the same period. And the Christian calculation was the most obvious, and therefore the most likely to have been arrived at before the fact. This kind of messianic math was very possibly the cause of the whole explosion of messianic claims and expectations in that very century (Element 4). Josephus even implies that this prophecy caused the Jewish War—certain Jewish factions being so convinced by it that they were certain God’s messiah would descend to defeat the Romans. Which didn’t happen, of course, resulting in their crushing defeat. But messianic fever remained so great it had thus led to a suicidal war. Arguably only a belief in a supernaturally backed messianic event could have mobilized armies among the Jews. Several other historians near to the event confirm it was indeed this belief that inspired that revolt.48
If Daniel was behind much or all of the first-century craze for messiahs, it could have inspired Christianity as well (with or without a historical Jesus), Christianity being just another messianic cult like all the others. And we can verify this at least as far as the Gospels. Mark quotes a passage from the Danielic timetable (Mk 13.14), and Matthew provides the attribution (Mt. 24.15). Thus the earliest texts that place Jesus’s death in Palestine around 30 ce were clearly aware of the very prophetic text placing a messiah’s appearance and death around 30 ce. And that’s a fact, whatever we decide to make of it. (Personally, I think if Jesus just ‘happened’ to die in 30 ce, then that would be a rather convenient coincidence; whereas if the year of the crucifixion was fudged or fabricated to match the prophecy, even for a historical death, then no lucky coincidence is required. It is therefore the more probable hypothesis.)
The irony in all of this is that Daniel 9 was an attempt to fix a failed prophecy in Jeremiah (Dan. 9.2, responding to Jer. 25.11-12), yet this ‘fix’ also failed, prompting later Jews to try and salvage this double failure by ‘reinterpreting’ Daniel this time and thus doing to Daniel what Daniel had unsuccessfully attempted to do to Jeremiah. Christianity was the most successful result. Of course, then the Christians had to spoil it by creating their own prophesy that the end of the world would come within the lifetimes of those hearing the good news. Which prophesy also failed.49 It would be comical if it wasn’t sad. But the cognitive dissonance caused by those earlier failures would explain the eventual success of a ‘reinterpretation’ that couldn’t be falsified: a messiah who triumphs in heaven, and reveals this fact from heaven, in secret, to a select few.
This is essentially Christianity in a nutshell (whether Jesus existed or not). The need to innovate an ironclad solution to the failure of God’s scripture (in Jeremiah, as patched up by Daniel) would certainly inspire both creativity to that end and its passionate acceptance—and with a ‘spiritual’ solution there could be no evidence against it (even in principle) and thus no more cognitive dissonance over it (see Element 28). The only thing left to cope with was the continuing failure of Christian prophets to get straight when the world would end, but history proves that has never been a difficulty. A heavenly victory simply made it easier. ‘Yes, the world didn’t end today as we thought, but at least we’re still saved’. That’s the mantra Christians have sustained the faith with for two thousand years.
But it all began with Jeremiah—and the book of Daniel. Experts agree Daniel was forged in the second century in part to ‘explain’ the death of the high priest Onias III in 171 bce, who was at the time believed to be the (or a) messiah (he is most likely the ‘Christ’ who is killed in Dan. 9.26), and to support the subsequent (and otherwise technically illegitimate) Maccabean regime by ‘predicting’ God’s defeat of their opponent, Antiochus IV, in 164 bce and then the coming end of the world (which didn’t happen—in fact, much of what Daniel predicts after Chapter 9 didn’t go to plan, providing a clue as to when it was written).50 This original meaning required a particular method of calculating years according to the timetable, using overlapping rather than sequential periods, the only way to get Jeremiah’s numbers to fit actual history up to Onias’s death (and thereby ‘predict’ this messiah would die in 171 bce). Obviously that was more awkward than simply counting sequentially. So subsequent reinterpreters, certain the ‘inspired’ Daniel could not have made a mistake, summed these years sequentially (the more obvious way), and chose different starting points (whatever could count as a ‘word concerning the restoration of Jerusalem’), which (depending on what calendar you use) gets various dates for the messiah’s death in the early first century ce.
The Christian religion could thus in a sense be explained as an attempt to explain away Daniel’s failed prediction of a divinely supported military victory for Israel over its Gentile oppressors (which continually didn’t happen), by imagining (unlike Daniel) a ‘spiritual’ kingdom instead of an actual one, and repeatedly postponing the actual one to an ever-receding future. Among the Dead Sea Scrolls, for example, in what’s called ‘The Son of God’ text (4Q246), we have a redaction of Daniel in which it is predicted that one day a great and righteous man will be born and be called the son of God and rule an eternal kingdom. Though here it was still imagined as a kingdom achieved by conquest, followed by an eternal reign of peace, it’s an easy thing to explain the failure of this to happen time and again by relocating that conquest into the spiritual realm (see Elements 23 through 28). And that’s exactly what the Christians did: they imagined a righteous man was born and was called the son of God and now rules an eternal kingdom—a kingdom that no one can see. And they imagined this happened exactly when Daniel appears to have predicted it would. And they imagined it followed the death of their Christ exactly as Daniel had said it would. And their own Gospels cite this passage in Daniel as confirmation. So the book of Daniel was clearly a seminal text in the development of Christianity, influencing the core of the gospel itself, including belief in the crucifixion and its prophetic importance. This is all the case whether Jesus existed or not, so this does not answer whether he did; it only entails he didn’t have to.
Element 8: (a) Many messianic sects among the Jews were searching the scriptures for secret messages from God about the coming messiah, in both the Hebrew Bible and the Septuagint (and beyond: see Element 9). The Christians were thus not engaging in novel activity when they did the same. (b) Since countless Jews were already doing this, and had been for a century or more, we must conclude the Jews who would become the first Christians had already been doing it long before they became Christians (since it would be extremely bizarre if they weren’t). Thus it is incorrect to assume Christians only started doing this after the fact; for we know they and their sectarian predecessors were already doing it before the fact.
Indeed this was a fad of the time, evident throughout the Dead Sea Scrolls and the Talmuds and Jewish literature elsewhere. The whole pesher genre is devoted to this activity.51 The Dead Sea pesher possibly linking the dying messiah of Daniel to the dying servant of Isaiah is an example (Element 5). Everyone was feverishly searching the scriptures to find secret messages about the messiah and God’s eventual plan for the Jews, and often finding these messages in the weirdest places. Indeed the Christians took it to a level of veritable lunacy (the book of Hermas, e.g., would peg anyone who wrote it today as all but insane), and the authors of the Dead Sea Scrolls seem not too far from it themselves.
Many doctrines originated from this search, each community’s search finding something different. Any pattern would be considered inspired—due to the routine fallacy of assuming a consistent pattern is too much a coincidence to be there by chance (when in fact many coincidentally consistent patterns will be there by chance, owing to the vast size and complexity of the scriptures and the inherent ambiguity and multivalent meaning of words). Hence countless different sectarian ‘discoveries’ were possible, each colored by the moral, political, theological, or other assumptions and expectations brought to the text. And it is because of this that countless different sects and interpretations of God’s plan arose, with Christianity among them.52 In fact, so many Jews were engaged in looking for these kinds of hidden meanings, for so long, that we can be nearly certain that all the most obvious patterns would inevitably have been discovered.
Element 9: What in the early first century were considered the inspired scriptures of God consisted of a larger network of texts than are now collected in the OT, including texts outside the canon and texts that no longer exist and also variants of texts that do exist (even canonical texts) but which often said different things then than extant versions now do. In other words, anyone trying to construct their picture of the messiah from hidden messages in the ‘Bible’ (per the previous element) would have been using texts and variants not in any current Bible today, and Christianity can be understood only in light of this fact.
Jewish authorities did not establish a canon until the second century ce, so no actual ‘Old Testament’ existed at the dawn of Christianity, just a sea of scriptures, from which different sects selected their own collections. The earliest Christians clearly held in their sacred collection books no longer in the Bible, including the Wisdom of Solomon and the Book of Enoch (which show their influence throughout the NT), and others. Codex Sinaiticus, for example, one of the earliest surviving Christian Bibles, includes in its OT ‘canon’ 2 Esdras, Tobit, Judith, 1 Maccabees, 4 Maccabees, Wisdom of Solomon, and Sirach (otherwise known as the ‘Book of the All-Virtuous Wisdom of Jesus ben Sira’). These and other texts influenced everything the earliest Christians said or believed about Jesus. Jude 14, for example, explicitly cites Enoch as scripture, and Jude 9 quotes another scripture now lost (which has been tentatively identified as the Revelation of Moses). Enoch was also a part of the scriptures collected at Qumran (e.g. 4Q204), along with many other books found in Codex Sinaiticus, and others known from nowhere else. Other texts they may have used include the Apocalypse of Moses, or any of the lost Danielic or Ezekiel literature we have pieces of from Qumran, where we have found fragments of many scriptures that have not survived anywhere else.53
Another important scripture of the period was the apocryphal Psalms of Solomon, which established many of the standard beliefs about the messiah, including his roles as king, judge, and shepherd, his designation as ‘Son of David’ (even though one would presume that that could not be meant literally, David having been dead for many centuries: although see Chapter 11, §9), as well as his assuming the title of Christ and Lord (‘Lord Messiah’).54 Many other connections between the Psalms of Solomon and Christianity are evident, including the messiah’s freedom from sin (17.36) and empowerment by the Holy Spirit (17.37). Though the Psalms describe this messiah in the manner of a military conqueror (e.g. 17.21-26), it is still somewhat circumspect, saying ‘he shall destroy the godless nations with the word of his mouth’ (17.24, 17.35-36) and that he will use no weapons or armies (17.33). It also says God will ‘raise him up for the house of Israel to educate him’ (17.42), which could easily inspire proto-Christian thinking: for ‘raise him up’ (anastēsai auton) is identical in wording to ‘resurrect him’, and can even be read as saying God will resurrect this messiah to educate Israel. I am not arguing here that Christians got this idea of a spiritual dying-and-rising messiah from this scripture, only that we have to take seriously the possibility that they in part did, because this text was widely regarded as scripture at the time, and Jews everywhere were searching their scriptures for hidden meanings just like this.
Since, like all Jews, proto-Christians would have been searching this scripture (and others) for secret messages about the messiah, anyone who interpreted this chapter in light of Dan. 9.26, for instance, could easily derive the core Christian gospel therefrom, yet again (see Elements 6 and 17). It’s certainly not improbable to see in the Psalms of Solomon a prediction of a metaphorically victorious messiah, who uses no armies or weapons but conquers solely through the power of his words (in other words, his teachings), especially for Jews who were convinced that scriptures like this were not to be taken at what they appeared to say, but as concealing their true meaning, as a great many Jews of that time thought (Element 8). And if you were already convinced the last Christ must die as Daniel predicted (Elements 5 and 7), a verse seeming to say he will be resurrected is available here as well.
There were also evidently several scriptures early Christians were using that we don’t have and don’t even know the titles of. Clement of Rome, for example, quotes as scripture texts we know nothing about, and yet which clearly influenced earliest Christianity.55 But not only did now-lost scriptures and non-canonical scriptures influence early Christianity, but so did canonical scriptures that said different things than the versions we now have. Early Christians even claimed the Jews had erased passages from the scriptures that predicted things about the Christ. In reality, the Christians probably just had textual variants and interpolated passages in their manuscripts—which can only have predated Christianity (and thus were Jewish in origin) unless they were forged by Christians to ‘create’ prophetic verification of their religion. For example, Paul quotes a now-lost variant reading of Isaiah in Rom. 9.33 (see Chapter 11, §8). Likewise, Irenaeus reports that in Jeremiah there was a passage saying, ‘and the Lord, the Holy One of Israel, remembered his dead, which aforetime fell asleep in the dust of the earth, and he went down unto them, to bring the tidings of his salvation, to deliver them’. No such passage exists in Jeremiah now, and it’s hard to think where it could have been. But Irenaeus is fully confident it was there.56 This and several other passages Christians insisted had been removed by the Jews from their copies of ‘the Bible’, but were clearly present in the copies of ‘the Bible’ the Christians were relying on. Earlier, Justin Martyr had documented a whole slew of such passages, now missing from extant Bibles but which he was sure existed in his.57 Origen later commented on this sort of thing being commonplace.58 We can even see examples in the first epistle of Clement (see Chapter 8, §5). How many other examples were there that we don’t have a surviving reference to?
Likewise, Christians often trusted the Septuagint over the Hebrew text of the Bible. The infamous case of the ‘virgin’ birth prediction is well known.59 But Irenaeus also says Ps. 119.120 says, ‘nail my flesh out of fear’, and therefore predicts the crucifixion, which is true only in the Greek; the Hebrew says, ‘my flesh trembles from fear of you’, which is certainly the original reading. The Greek translation Irenaeus used literally reads, ‘nail my flesh from fear of you, as I am afraid of your judgments’, which makes no sense really, yet differs from the perfectly sensible Hebrew by only a single word. Nevertheless, Christians trusted this erroneous variant, and based their religious beliefs thereon.60 Irenaeus likewise says his copy of the Psalms said, ‘spare my soul from the sword, fasten my flesh with nails, for the assemblies of the wicked have risen up against me’, which in fact is an entirely different verse than appears in either the Hebrew or the Greek that we now have. He was thus using a different version of the Bible than survives today in any form at all. And Irenaeus is not an aberration here. Exactly the same thing is said in the Epistle of Barnabas, which was once a part of some early Christian Bibles.61
We know these kinds of deviant manuscripts were all over the place even before Christianity began. Greek versions of the scriptures were found (and thus evidently used and studied) among the Dead Sea Scrolls in Palestine, so Greek-based interpretations could easily pre-date Christianity. Even a Hebrew copy of Isaiah at Qumran, for example, replaces the word ‘bruised’ with the word ‘pierced’ in both Isa. 53.5 and 53.10. That’s the very passage we previously discussed as predicting the messiah’s death when connected with Dan. 9.25-26, and here now we see this variant also linking Isaiah 53 with Psalms 22, a connection the Christians also made, as we see in Mark’s construction of the crucifixion narrative (see Chapter 10, §4). Thus it can’t always have been Christians doctoring texts to conform to the crucifixion—for here we have a variant text that could readily evoke an expected crucifixion for the atoning servant of Isaiah 53 long before there even were Christians.62
Thus Christians were not relying on the biblical texts we have. They had different versions to work from, as well as books now no longer in the Bible at all. Which means whenever a Christian text claims there was (or indeed even quotes) a scripture that we can’t find in the Bible (e.g. Jn 7.38; Lk. 24.46-47; Mt. 2.23; Mk 9.12; even 1 Cor. 2:9), we should presume they were looking at a textual variant we no longer have (and thus the scripture was there, and probably there before Christianity, at least in some of the manuscripts available to them), or were citing a book other than any now in the OT (such as any of those mentioned earlier, although there were also others we no longer even know about). Likewise, Christians didn’t always say they were citing or deriving an idea from scripture, yet we can identify where they got it from ourselves, which means there must also have been many more cases where they also derived a text or idea from a variant scripture now lost to us or no longer in the canon, without telling us that is what they were doing.63
Element 10: Christianity began as a Jewish messianic cult preaching a spiritually victorious messiah. This means that (a) sometime in the early first century at least one of the many diverse sects of Jews came to believe and preach that (b) a certain Jesus was an eschatological Christ, (c) despite his having been crucified and buried by the powers that be (whether temporal or supernatural), (d) because (or so they preached: 1 Cor. 15.3-8 and Gal. 1.11-12) he had afterward appeared to certain favored people and convinced them he was this Christ and (e) had to die in atonement for all sins but (f) had risen from the dead to sit at the right hand of God in order to begin the work (through the sect he was thus founding) of preparing for God’s kingdom until (g) the time when this Christ would descend from heaven to complete his mission of destroying God’s enemies, resurrecting the dead, and establishing an eternal paradise (e.g. Romans 8; 1 Cor. 10.11 and 15.23-26; 1 Thess. 4.14-17). (h) At this time Jesus was already believed to be a preexistent being (1 Cor. 8.6; 10.1-4; Phil. 2.6-8; and Rom. 8.3; see also Element 40), but (i) was not believed to be identical to God, but to be his appointed emissary and subordinate, not God himself but given God’s authority, being God’s ‘son’ in the same sense as angels and kings traditionally were (see my discussion of the resulting linguistic ambiguity in §3).
None of this should be controversial.64 Some scholars might challenge the notion that the earliest Jesus cult regarded the death of Jesus to be an atonement sacrifice, but the fact of the matter is our earliest Christian documents widely attest this was a standard, fundamental, and pervasive Christian belief, and affords no evidence of any prior version of Christianity (1 Cor. 15.3; Rom. 3.23-26; 5.6-11; 2 Cor. 5.18-19). This is particularly clear in Galatians 1–2, where Paul emphatically insists ‘preaching another gospel’ is enough to condemn anyone as cursed and shunned (Gal. 1.6-9), but that his gospel was in accord with that of the ‘pillars’ Peter, James and John (Gal. 2.6-10), whom he implies are the founders of Christianity (he certainly here treats them as the ultimate authorities whose blessing any Christian apostle required; and he again confirms their primacy in 1 Cor. 15.3-8, although the reliability of the text on this point has been questioned: see note in Chapter 11, §2). Since the ‘pillars’ and their ‘gospel’ were thus not condemned as ‘anathema’ by Paul, they cannot possibly have been preaching anything so radically different from him as a Jesus who hadn’t atoned for anyone’s sins (much less a Jesus who hadn’t been crucified!).
Any challenge to this conclusion cannot be a disagreement as to the evidence, but only in respect to theory, that is, one might propose the theory that there was a previous version of the religion upon which Paul innovated the atoning death, and then test that theory against the evidence. I just here predict it won’t test well. Hence I am rejecting it. The only dispute evident throughout Galatians 2 is over the matter of the observance of the specific strictures of the Jewish law, the doing away of which very clearly was an innovation of Paul (see Element 20). But that was only an interpretation of the gospel, not the gospel itself (e.g. this abolition of the Law is nowhere stated in Paul’s matching declaration of the gospel that was revealed to him in 1 Cor. 15.3-8 or anywhere else), therefore an agreement could be reached without either side declaring the other anathema (Gal. 2.6-10).
Some scholars might also challenge the assumption that apocalyptic hopes were innate to Christianity from the beginning. But this really can no longer be doubted. The Epistles are rife with no other view (again, see Romans 8; 1 Cor. 10.11; 15.23-26; 1 Thess. 4.14-17), and they long predate the Synoptic Gospels. The Synoptic Gospels are rife with no other view (as everyone agrees), and they long predate the Gospels of John and (almost certainly) Thomas, and only there do we first see the replacement of an actual apocalypse with a metaphorical one that had already transpired.65 Thus the idea of an immanent ‘invisible kingdom’ replacing the imminent physical kingdom that was previously expected to arrive (but disturbingly hadn’t) was a later development in Christianity and not a founding belief.66 Far more foundational was the belief that the resurrection of Jesus had been the firstfruits (and therefore a positive sign) of the general apocalyptic resurrection very soon to come (1 Cor. 15.20-24).67
And finally, some (though mostly fundamentalist Christians) might challenge the claim that at this stage Christians did not regard Jesus as identical to God.68 But this is undeniably clear. Jesus is the power of God and the wisdom of God, but not himself God (1 Cor. 1.24), only the image of God (literally, ‘God’s icon’, 2 Cor. 4.4; though compare 1 Cor. 11.7, where the same is said of ordinary men, but there only through their unity with Christ); he was made by God (1 Cor. 1.30). He sits at the right hand of God and pleads with God on our behalf (Rom. 8.34). All things were made by God, but through the agency of Christ (1 Cor. 8.4-6). Christ is given the form of a god, but refuses to seize that opportunity to make himself equal to God, but submits to incarnation and death instead, for which obedience God grants him supreme authority (Phil. 2.5-11). And Christ will in the end deliver the kingdom to God, who only gave Christ the authority to rule and wage war on God’s behalf; and in the end Christ will give that authority back to God (1 Cor. 15.24-28). Thus in our earliest sources Jesus was always distinguished as a different entity from God, and as his subordinate.69 Even in Colossians he is the image of God, not God himself; in fact, he is ‘the firstborn of all creation’ (and thus a created being), and ‘God dwelled within him’, in the same sense as was imagined for Jewish prophets, priests and kings (Col. 1.15-19). Thus in Rom. 1.4 (and all of Hebrews 1) Jesus is only appointed the ‘Son of God’. This was precisely how the phrase ‘Son of God’ and the concepts of divine ‘incarnation’ and ‘indwelling’ were then understood by the Jews.70 This was therefore not a radical idea but entirely in accord with popular Jewish theology. This would still make Jesus a god by my terminology (and in common pagan parlance), but not in the usual vocabulary of Jews (who would sooner call such a divine being an archangel or celestial ‘lord’).
6. Elements of Christian Religion
Element 11: The earliest definitely known form of Christianity was a Judeo-Hellenistic mystery religion. This is also beyond any reasonable doubt, yet frequently denied in the field of Jesus research, often with a suspiciously intense passion. So I shall here survey a case for it.71
To say Christianity was a mystery religion is not to say that Christianity is exactly like any other mystery religion, any more than any mystery religion was ‘exactly like’ any other. Often when scholars deny that Christianity was a mystery religion, they really mean it wasn’t just one of the already-existing mystery religions superficially overhauled with Jewish concepts. Christianity wasn’t ‘Osiris Cult 2.0’. Which is certainly true. But that’s all that anyone’s evidence can prove. If instead we define a mystery religion as any Hellenistic cult in which individual salvation was procured by a ritual initiation into a set of ‘mysteries’, the knowledge of which and participation in which were key to ensuring a blessed eternal life, then Christianity was demonstrably a mystery religion beyond any doubt.
If we then expand that definition to include a set of specific features held in common by all other mystery religions of the early Roman era, then Christianity becomes even more demonstrably a mystery religion, so much so, in fact, that it’s impossible to deny it was deliberately constructed as such. Even the earliest discernible form of Christianity emulates numerous cultic features and concepts that were so unique to the Hellenistic mystery cults that it is statistically beyond any reasonable possibility that they all found their way into Christianity by mere coincidence. They formed a coherent, logical and repeatedly replicated system of ideas in every other mystery cult. It would be irrational to conclude the same wasn’t so of Christianity. Christianity cannot be understood apart from this fact. And any theory of historicity that fails to account for it cannot be credible.72
That Christianity taught eternal salvation for the individual cannot be denied. That it taught that this salvation was procured by initiation rituals (such as undergoing baptism and partaking of the Eucharist) cannot be denied. And that these rituals involved an induction into a set of ‘mysteries’, the knowledge of which and participation in which were key to ensuring a blessed eternal life, is explicitly stated throughout the authentic epistles of Paul—and nearly everywhere else in the NT. In Paul’s letters essential Christian doctrines are routinely called mysteries.73 The NT evinces other common vocabulary of mystery cult, used with the same peculiar connotations, not just mystērion (divine secret), but teleios (mature [as higher ranking initiates]), nēpios (immature [as lower ranking initiates]), skēnē (body [as discardable and unneeded for salvation]), epoptēs (witness [to the mysteries]), etc.74
In fact, ‘in the Pauline epistles we have more than isolated terms and ideas of the type in question. In certain contexts, as, e.g., 1 Corinthians [2.1–3.2], we light upon groups of conceptions which have associations with the Mystery-Religions. This cannot be accidental.’75 This concept framework is found in other places as well (e.g. 2 Cor. 5; 1 Cor. 4.1; Heb. 5.11-14, etc.). This does not require Christianity to have used these concepts identically to any other mystery cult, any more than any other cult did. It only entails some influence and employment of mystery-cult themes, and that Christianity was constructed in a fashion similar to those cults, even while, like each of them, it remained distinct, with each borrowed element altered by receiving an appropriate Jewish twist.76 We should thus concur with Jaime Alvarez, who proposes what he calls a ‘commensality’ approach of ‘complex transfers’ among mystery cults, Christianity included, such that instead of Christianity being a direct reworking of a specific preceding mystery cult (which it is not), we should see it as the reworking of a Jewish cult from a ‘common trough of current ideas’, including those collectively shared among the mystery cults of its day, transforming them in the process.77 And yet even transformed, certain fundamental elements remain in common.
All mystery religions centered on a central savior deity (literally called the sōtēr, ‘the savior’, which is essentially the meaning of the word ‘Jesus’, as explained in Chapter 6, §3), always a son of god (or occasionally a daughter of god), who underwent some sort of suffering (enduring some sort of trial or ordeal) by which they procured salvation for all who participate in their cult (their deed of torment having given them dominion over death). These deaths or trials were literally called a ‘passion’ (patheōn, lit. ‘sufferings’), exactly as in Christianity.78 Sometimes this ‘passion’ was an actual death and resurrection (Osiris); sometimes it was some kind of terrible labor defeating the forces of death (Mithras), or variations thereof. All mystery religions had an initiation ritual in which the congregant symbolically reenacts what the god endured (like Christian baptism: Rom. 6.3-4; Col. 2.12), thus sharing in the salvation the god had achieved (Gal. 3.27; 1 Cor. 12.13), and all involve a ritual meal that unites initiated members in communion with one another and their god (1 Cor. 11.23-28). All of these features are fundamental to Christianity, yet equally fundamental to all the mystery cults that were extremely popular in the very era that Christianity arose.79 The coincidence of all of these features together lining up this way is simply too improbable to propose as just an accident.
Notably all the mystery religions were products of the same sort of cultural syncretism. The Eleusinian mysteries were a syncretism of Levantine and Hellenistic elements; the mysteries of Attis and Cybele were a syncretism of Phrygian and Hellenistic elements; the mysteries of Jupiter Dolichenus were a syncretism of Anatolian and Hellenistic elements; Mithraism was a syncretism of Persian and Hellenistic elements; the mysteries of Isis and Osiris were a syncretism of Egyptian and Hellenistic elements. Christianity is simply a continuation of the same trend: a syncretism of Jewish and Hellenistic elements. Each of these cults is unique and different from all the others in nearly every detail—but it’s the general features they all share in common that reflect the overall fad that produced them in the first place, the very features that made them popular and successful within Greco-Roman culture.
Unfortunately we know very much less about these other cults than Christianity, because Christians chose not to preserve any of their sacred literature—sometimes deliberately destroying it, as we might infer from the fate of books 2 and 3 of Hippolytus’s Refutation of All Heresies (in which, according to what he says at the end of book 1, he exposed all the secrets of the mystery religions, yet these chapters were mysteriously removed and remain lost to this day). But our ignorance is also due to the fact that much of what the mystery cults taught was kept secret, being so sacred that only initiates sworn to secrecy would be told the true content of the mysteries of each cult (the same was true of Christianity: see Element 13).80 But enough evidence survives to reconstruct all the common features I’ve mentioned, and more.
There is one notable exception, the Golden Ass of Apuleius (also known as the Metamorphoses), which is a kind of Acts for the Isis cult (recorded in the fashion of a novel, thus in a sense disguising its sacred nature), which medieval Christians preserved intact. This tells us many things about the religion, including its initiation ritual: the initiation, Apuleius tells us, resembles a ‘voluntary death’ (instar voluntariae mortis), after which one is ‘reborn’ (renatus). After you were baptized into the cult (literally, with an ablution of water), the day of initiation became a new ‘birthday’ and the priest who initiated you became your new father. As Apuleius describes it, ‘I approached the border of death, and once the threshold of Proserpina [Lady Death] was crossed, I was conveyed through all the elements, and came back’ to life (all of which he again calls a ‘rebirth’).81 Christianity’s initiation ritual also involved a baptism, and was conceptually identical: you symbolically underwent death and resurrection, and are thereby ‘reborn’ with a new ‘father’ (in this case, God—see Element 12—although, just like in the Isis cult, in earliest Christianity the one who initiated you could also be called your father: 1 Cor. 4.15).
Mithras cult also involved an initiatory baptism.82 As did the Eleusinian cult, which even practiced substitutionary baptism on behalf of the dead (to bring salvation to those who hadn’t yet been baptized in life), centuries before Christians adopted the same practice, as evident already in the earliest known churches (1 Cor. 15.29), which is yet another unlikely coincidence.83 In many if not all the mystery cults, these baptisms effected salvation in part by washing away sins, exactly the same function claimed of Christian baptism.84 Which is another unlikely coincidence (although predating Christianity, Judaism did not have this element until after contact with Hellenism; before that, only blood sacrifice could remove sin).
In Apuleius’s account of the Isis cult, initiation was also ‘consummated’ with a ‘sacred meal’ on ‘the third day’ of the completed rites, implying the meal fully united him to his savior god or goddess and his fellow initiates, the very thing accomplished by the Eucharist within Christianity. And just as for Christians, by undergoing these rites the Isis initiate procured eternal life for himself in the hereafter. In other words, personal salvation. There appears to have been a similar sacred meal securing eternal life in the mysteries of Mithras.85 Thus, for all these reasons, Christianity is certainly in essentials a Hellenistic mystery religion, differing from others only in its Jewish details and framework, just as Mithraism differs from all others in its Persian details and framework, and Isis–Osiris cult differs from all others in its Egyptian details and framework, and so on.
Christianity also conforms to four universal trends distinctive of the Hellenistic mystery religions, and is therefore unmistakably a product of these same cultural trends:
1. syncretism of a local or national system of religious ideas with distinctly Hellenistic ideas (and the ideas of other nations and localities whose diffusion was facilitated by Hellenism);
2. a monotheistic trend, with every mystery religion evolving from polytheism (many competing gods) to henotheism (one supreme god reigning over subordinate deities), marking a trajectory toward monotheism (only one god);
3. a shift to individualism, placing the religious focus on the eternal salvation of the individual rather than the welfare of the community as a whole;
4. and cosmopolitanism, with membership being open and spanning all environments, provinces, races, and social classes (and often genders).
That all four features were universal to all the known mystery religions has been abundantly demonstrated in current scholarship, as has the enormous popularity of these new religions, and the rise of these features and their popularity centuries before Christianity. Christianity fits exactly within this trend and in that respect looks exactly like every other mystery religion developed during this period—indeed, it is a relative latecomer. It is thus an expected phenomenon of its time and evinces an unmistakable transformation of the very different Jewish religion into something more palatably identical to popular pagan religious movements arising from every other ‘foreign’ culture under the Roman Empire.86 To understand this we must take a closer look at each element in turn.
(1) Syncretism is the creative merging of religious ideas, borrowing and adapting elements from several religions to create something new. This trend is evident in all the mystery religions,87 as well as Christianity. This trend indeed parallels the rise of eclecticism in science and philosophy (the merging of different philosophical ideas into a new superior whole, rather than dogmatically adhering to one school of thought), and is thus representative of the entire cultural matrix of the time (which, of course, never ceased: later Christians adopted pagan holidays, such as Christmas, and absorbed pagan gods, in both fact and concept, in the guise of a cult of saints, and a great deal else besides).88 We’ll see more evidence of how this syncretism produced Christianity as we go along. But in general, this so routinely occurred, it would be improbable for Christianity to not also have been a product of it (I answer the usual objections to this in Elements 30-38, but of course it must be noted that syncretists themselves never claim they are borrowing; they always portray what they borrowed as a natural development of their native cult—so hostility to borrowing would produce no barrier to actually doing it).
(2) Christianity’s monotheism was also not original. Indeed, it was entirely parallel to the henotheism already popularly promoted by the mystery cults.89 Within those cults is a clear trend toward a focus on one supreme god and the demotion of other gods to the status of either minions (becoming the equivalent of angels and demons) or ‘aspects’ of the one God, thus folding numerous gods into one, each being thought a different guise of the same god. This trend is already evident in Herodotus, and thus began even before the Hellenistic period. Christian rhetoric hardly conceals the fact that it is identically henotheistic, with not just the one God (to whom was later assimilated and originally subordinated the additional gods of the Lord Christ and the Holy Spirit), but many other subordinate gods, including a ‘god of this world’ (i.e., Satan: 2 Cor. 4.4) and a panoply of angels (divine ‘messengers’) and demons (literally, daimones or daimonia, ‘divinities’) possessed of all the same roles, attributes, and powers of pagan gods (see my definitions in §3). That they were not called gods is merely semantics, a rather transparent attempt to deploy doublespeak to conceal what was really a syncretism of Jewish monotheism and pagan polytheism, producing a system of theology that was conceptually identical to pagan henotheism, differing only in the superficial use of words—which difference was itself a product of that syncretism, it being the Jewish contribution; the multiplication of divinities being the pagan one.90
This had already been occurring within Judaism before the rise of Christianity, which merely continued the process to its logical conclusion.91 Thus when Paul says,
We know an idol is nothing in the cosmos, and that there is no God except the one, for although there are ones called gods, either in heaven or on earth (as there are indeed many gods and many lords), yet for us there is the one God, the Father (from whom all things come, and we come to him) and the one Lord, Jesus Christ (through whom all things come, and we come through him) (1 Cor. 8.4-6).
Here we have a plain declaration of henotheism: yes, there are many gods, but we worship only two of them, and the second of them we only worship as a subordinate of the other (and thus call that subordinate divinity not ‘God’ himself but by one of that God’s titles, Lord). Spoken like a true henotheist. The only thing unique about it is its restrictions on worship (and a corresponding use of titles)—which derives from Judaism. The rest is pagan.
(3) The third trend was the rise of religious individualism.92 Under the Hellenistic mystery cults, religion became a personal individual choice to join or not to join (in contrast with old-style paganism in which a public cult was simply maintained regardless of whether anyone participated or believed); and the motivation to participate became an individual reward (personal salvation) rather than a communal reward (such as successful crops and, thereby, the survival of the community). Thus the mystery religions co-opted what had once been agricultural deities (whose dying and rising or descent and ascent originally corresponded to the seasonal fertility of the earth) and reinterpreted their narratives as metaphors for personal salvation (each individual literally sharing in the demigod’s dying and rising or descent and ascent, with eternal life as the end product, rather than continued agricultural fertility in the here and now). So the fact that Christianity also turned what was originally a communal aim (the resurrection and salvation of Israel as a whole) into an individualistic one (the resurrection and salvation of individual Christians, hence of only those who individually chose to join the faith—and indeed creating a cultic model for this in the individual resurrection of Jesus) is entirely parallel with what the mystery religions were doing, and thus again fully reflective of the same cultural trend.
(4) Finally, cosmopolitanism was part of the same trend. Each mystery religion explicitly created a new group identity transcending all traditional borders and distinctions. Members of the cult became universal brothers and sisters regardless of their actual family ties or geographical, national, or social origins. Mystery cults were thus no longer restricted to a single city, state, or race, or even social status, but spread everywhere and accepted everyone (whether slave or free, rich or poor, citizen or foreigner; in most cases even male or female), thereby uniting all classes, races, and peoples in a new common humanity.93 So when Paul writes that ‘for in one spirit were we all baptized into one body, whether Jews or Greeks, whether bond or free’ and thus we are all brothers (1 Cor. 12.12-13; cf. also Gal. 3.26-29; Rom. 12.4-5; and 1 Cor. 10.17; 12.12-25) he is echoing an ideology that had already been popularized by the Hellenistic mystery religions. Indeed he is here pulling Christianity even more into the orbit of this trend, by doing away with the requirement of initiates to first become Jews through circumcision and other rites (Rom. 10.4-9; Philippians 3; Galatians 2, 5, 6).
This reflected a parallel trend in the rise of associations, guilds, burial clubs and fraternities that also allowed people to explore new group identities.94 This included the development of ‘fictive kinship language’, in which members of a religious cult or fraternity would call one another ‘brother’ and ‘sister’ (and sometimes elders of the group ‘fathers’ and ‘mothers’), exactly as Christians did.95 This was a common practice in mystery cults, too, so again to see it in earliest Christianity is more evidence of it being part of the same trend. In all these cults and fraternities, key to maintaining this fictive kinship was the sharing of sacred meals dedicated to their patron god (in which bread, wine and fish were the most common components).96 Indeed, we know these groups set up rules to keep them reverent, and from degenerating into disrespectful partying or other bad behavior, exactly as Paul seeks to accomplish for the Christian equivalent (in 1 Cor. 11.20-34).97 Likewise in the mystery cults, sharing in the Lord’s meal or baptism or other ritual often united members in a common family by adoption as the sons of their supreme God, thereby making them immortal demigods in the afterlife, like their Savior Lord,98 which is essentially the view Christians held of their own salvation, as they gained in every respect the glorious, immortal, invincible bodies otherwise only gods enjoyed (1 Cor. 15.35-54; 2 Corinthians 5), and similarly achieved this through adoption as the sons of their supreme God (see next element).
It is therefore undeniable that Christianity was a Judeo-Hellenistic mystery religion, exactly conforming to the trends in religious development that befell nearly every other national culture within the Roman Empire, from the Egyptians to the Persians. Christianity was simply the result of this trend finally befalling the Jews. There may well have been precedents for this already, if Josephus is to be believed in his report that the Essene sect of the Jews conducted itself like a mystery religion, complete with four levels of initiation, including a baptism at the first of them, a communal meal, and swearing to keep the secret of their mysteries even under pain of death (and, of course, a belief in their personal salvation through resurrection).99 There is also evidence of such mysteries within other varieties of pre-Christian Judaism, which were kept secret from the public.100 We just know too little about any of these precedents to know how much they may have led to or influenced Christianity.
Element 12: From as early as we can ascertain, Christians believed they became ‘brothers’ of the Lord Jesus Christ through baptism (Rom. 6.3-10), which symbolized their death to the world and rebirth as the ‘adopted sons of God’, hence they became the brothers of the Lord, the son of God.101 Thus Jesus was only ‘the firstborn among many brethren’ (Rom. 8.29).
Element 13: Like all mystery cults, Christianity had secret doctrines that initiates were sworn never to reveal, and that would be talked about and written about publicly only in symbols, myths and allegories to disguise their true meaning (see Element 14).102
Clement of Alexandria, though writing in the early third century, explains:
Now it is not wished that all things should be exposed indiscriminately to all and sundry, nor should the benefits of wisdom be communicated to those who have not even in a dream been purified in soul (for it is not allowed to hand to every chance comer what has been procured with such laborious efforts); nor are the mysteries of the Word to be expounded to the profane.103 . . . Those who instituted the mysteries, being philosophers, buried their doctrines in myths, so as not to be obvious to all. Did they not then, by veiling human opinions, prevent the ignorant from handling them? And was it not more beneficial for the holy and blessed contemplation of realities, that they be concealed?104 . . . So these [secrets] we shall find indicated by symbols under the veil of allegory.105
This feature of all the mystery religions of antiquity is well known,106 but here Clement is saying this was a good practice, even a necessary practice, and that Christianity likewise adheres to it. Earlier Clement had outright said there is a secret understanding of the gospel that he is forbidden to tell his readers.107 But here he goes on to explain:
For the prophet says, ‘Who shall understand the Lord’s parable but the wise and understanding, and he that loves his Lord?’ It is but for few to comprehend these things. For, they say, it is not out of envy that the Lord passed on in a certain Gospel, ‘My mystery is for me, and for the sons of my house’.108
Clement further explains that the Epistles confirm this same division, of some teachings reserved only for insiders; and then even within the church there was another special set of knowledge and teachings reserved only for ‘mature’ believers (teleioi, ‘the perfected’), who were distinguished from lower-ranking initiates called ‘children’ (nēpioi, ‘babes’, the newly baptized being newly born). These were well-recognized code words in the mystery cults, which meant the same thing there as they clearly do for Clement here: ‘babes’ were Christians not yet inducted into the higher mysteries, while the ‘mature’ had been, and thus knew teachings that other Christians did not. But Clement also indicates in the above quotes that there were also teachings that ‘babes’ were privy to that non-Christians (the ‘profane’) were not to be told.
Obviously the only way any of this could have been maintained is if initiates at each level were sworn to secrecy, and as we know this was the case in all other mystery cults, and Christianity was likewise a mystery cult (see Element 12), we can be certain this was the case there, too. Thus, when Clement quotes Rom. 16.25-26, which says ‘the mystery’ of Christianity was a secret hidden within scripture but now revealed and taught ‘to all nations for the obedience of faith’, Clement says this means ‘that is, to those from “all nations” who are believers’, and not, in fact, indiscriminately to everyone. Clement then adds, ‘But even only to a few of them [meaning, Christian believers] is shown what those things are which are contained in the mystery’.109 Clement says this was rightly so, as Plato himself had said, when discussing God in a letter (sent on a tablet), ‘We must speak in enigmas, so that, should this tablet come by any mischance on its leaves either by sea or land, he who reads may remain ignorant’.110
Clement then says:
Akin to this is what the holy apostle Paul says, preserving the prophetic and truly ancient secret (from which the teachings that were good were derived by the Greeks): ‘But we do speak wisdom among the mature [teleioi]—not the wisdom of this world, or of the princes of this world, who will be done away with, but we speak the wisdom of God, hidden in a mystery’ [1 Cor. 2.6-7]. Then proceeding, he thus inculcates the caution against the divulging of his words to the multitude in the following terms: ‘But I, brethren, could not speak to you as spiritual men, but as carnal men, as babes [nēpioi] in Christ. I have fed you with milk, not with solid food: for you could not receive it; even now you can’t receive it. For you are still carnal men’ [1 Cor. 3.1-3]. If, then, ‘the milk’ is said by the apostle to belong to the babes, and ‘solid food’ to be the food of the mature, then ‘milk’ will be understood to be catechetical instruction—the first food, as it were, of the soul—and ‘solid food’ is beholding the highest mysteries.111
That last phrase, ‘beholding the highest mysteries’, is in Greek epoptikē theōria, terminology very specific to mystery cult. This is corroborated by others. Origen explains there were different ranks of initiation, with secrets in the church withheld until each rank was achieved, and the lowest rank were the babes, fed only milk.112
It’s evident that their reading of Paul is correct. Paul very clearly does say that there is some teaching he can’t impart to his Corinthian readers because they are not of sufficient rank in the church, and he very clearly uses the particular terminology of mystery cult, distinguishing initiates (newborn babes) from the teleioi, those who presumably have ‘completed’ all the mysteries. He says the truth (the ‘wisdom’ that is not of men or angels) that the teleioi are taught is a secret and ‘hidden in a mystery’, and thus he explains he can’t tell them what it is. One has to have a more mature spiritual understanding first (1 Corinthians 2, throughout which the ‘us’ and ‘we’ he is referring to must be the apostles and teleioi, not the whole congregation), because without that the truth will seem ridiculous to them (mōria) and they won’t be able to understand it (1 Cor. 2.14–3.3). That is how he says the advanced teachings would seem even to baptized initiates, just as the introductory teachings seem ridiculous to outsiders but can still be understood by the babes in Christ (1 Cor. 1.17-31; 3.18-19).
The mysteries the beginners are taught, Paul says, are ‘nothing other than Jesus Christ and him crucified’ (1 Cor. 2.2), the most basic gospel (outlined in 1 Cor. 15.3-5). But there is also a special ‘wisdom’, he says, that was taught to advanced members (the teleioi), which Paul sees as the root of the problem he is addressing at Corinth: because those he is speaking to have not yet been initiated into the highest mysteries, they are splitting into factions (e.g. some declaring themselves for Paul, some for Apollos: 1 Cor. 3.3-4), not being aware of that ‘higher’ teaching that (Paul is assuming) would sort them out and resolve their dispute. Indeed, Paul implies that Apollos imparted to them some new mysteries that weren’t among those taught them by Paul, and Paul explains Apollos was only building on what Paul taught (1 Cor. 3.5-24), suggesting that Paul is saying their different teachings don’t really contradict each other, but rather that Apollos was imparting a second tier of deeper understanding (the mystery cults generally had more than two levels of mysteries to enter; so Christianity may have, too: see below). Hence, he says, ‘this is how one should regard us [i.e., the apostles], as servants of Christ and stewards of the mysteries of God’ (1 Cor. 4.1). Paul elsewhere mentions there being many mysteries (which together constituted complete ‘knowledge’) and implies only the most advanced knew them all (1 Cor. 13.2). Thus, Paul assumes throughout 1 Corinthians 8 that Christians with certain secret knowledge can partake of pagan-sacrificed meat but that this might mislead Christians not yet privy to that knowledge, and therefore higher-ranking Christians should not encourage this by setting a bad example (thus he develops the compromise in 1 Corinthians 10), all of which entails there were levels of teaching kept hidden from lower ranks of Christians.113
We see something similar in the Dead Sea Scrolls, one of which mentions secrets held by insiders of differing rank, using the same distinctions between ‘babes’ and ‘adults’ and ‘milk’ versus ‘meat’.114 All of this is confirmed for Christianity in the book of Hebrews, which also speaks of ‘milk’ and ‘solid food’ and the distinction between those in the church who are not ready to receive the latter, who again are called ‘babes’, and those who are able to receive it, because of their more advanced spiritual training, who are again called the ‘mature’ (Heb. 5.11–6.3). It likewise speaks of more basic principles of Christ (the ‘first principles’), which are enumerated as ‘repentance from dead works; faith toward God; the doctrine of baptisms; and of laying on of hands; and of resurrection of the dead; and of eternal judgment’. This is evidently the litany of what would be imparted by the ‘initial’ mysteries, or possibly several ranks of mysteries (since there is more to this list than Paul said one’s first initiation began with), and this is all distinguished from the final mysteries, by which one is ‘perfected’, which this author implies is contained in what follows (in Hebrews 6 through 13).
It’s worth noting that these hints of there being more than just two levels of initiation (first becoming newborn babes, then becoming perfected) accords with other mystery cults, which typically had three or four levels. In the second century, the letters of Ignatius also suggest there were multiple levels, when he says he can’t tell the Trallians some of the Christian mysteries because they are still ‘babes’ and thus not able to receive the secrets he is hinting at (which from context seem to be something about the nature of Satan, his role in attacking the church, and its connection with esoteric knowledge about the heavenly realms and the names of various angels and celestial powers), but that there are still other teachings even he has not received yet (which he knows will involve more knowledge of the structure of heaven and some sort of detailed angelology).115 That entails at least three levels of initiation were known to him and his fellow congregants. This may have been the case in Paul’s time as well.
Clement himself describes four levels of initiation in the church of his own day, consisting of ‘faith’ (pistis), ‘knowledge’ (gnōsis), ‘love’ (agapē) and ‘inheritance’ (klēronomia).116 One ascends through these stages to achieve immortality:
Which takes place whenever one is held up by the Lord through faith, then through knowledge, then through love, and then ascends along with him to where the God and watcher of our faith and love resides. Whence at last it is that knowledge is passed down to those fit and selected for it, because immense preparation and previous training is necessary in order to hear what is said, and to live a life of restraint, and to advance intelligently to the fullness of righteousness that is according to the law. It leads us to the endless and perfect end, teaching us beforehand the future life that we shall lead, according to God, and with gods. . . .
After which redemption, the reward and the honors are assigned to those who have become perfect [lit. ‘to those who have become teleioi’], when they will be done with purification, and ceased from all service (though it be holy service, and among saints). Then they become pure in heart, next to the Lord, where they await their return to eternal contemplation. Then they are called by the appellation of ‘gods’, being destined to sit on thrones with the other gods that have been first put in their places by the Savior.117
Clement’s previous designation of that final rank as the ‘inheritance’, and then here describing it as reaching the status of ‘god’, placed ‘next to the Lord’, destined to sit on a throne in heaven and eternally contemplate reality, might be an important clue to what it meant to be a teleios, a Christian admitted to the highest mysteries: full inheritance as God’s son, something more than by mere adoption, but complete equivalence to God’s firstborn. This could be the underlying idea when Paul says those in the church of his own rank ‘have the mind of Christ’ and thus can properly judge all things because they have full knowledge of all the mysteries (1 Cor. 2.16). Paul elsewhere hints at a secret doctrine in 2 Cor. 12.3, where he says a man he knows (most scholars believe he is speaking of himself) experienced a spiritual ascent ‘into the third heaven’ where he heard teachings he was forbidden to tell (thus again evincing a secret mystery teaching), a notion of ascent that accords with Clement’s description of the highest mysteries in Christianity.118
Whether either of those last points is correct or not, Paul clearly references secret doctrines kept from the public, plus more secret doctrines kept even from most Christians and reserved instead for those who were ‘mature’. Clement fully confirms this.119 As does Origen, Ignatius and Hebrews. This evidence is only supported further by the more general point that this was a standard feature of all mystery cults, and Christianity clearly was one (as shown in Element 11), so we should expect it shared this feature as well, especially as even pre-Christian Judaism had similar traditions of secret doctrines.120
Element 14: Mystery cults spoke of their beliefs in public through myths and allegory, which symbolized a more secret doctrine that was usually rooted in a more esoteric astral or metaphysical theology. Therefore, as itself a mystery religion with secret doctrines, Christianity would have done the same.
The most explicit discussion of this fact can be found in Plutarch’s book on the myths and teachings of the mystery cult of Isis and Osiris, which he wrote and dedicated to a priestess of that cult, Clea.121 Plutarch says the highest aim of any religion is to learn the truth behind its stories and rituals, the truth about the gods. And part of that consisted in realizing that the stories and narratives of the gods were only allegories for higher truths:
Clea, whenever you hear the mythical stories told by the Egyptians about their gods—of their wanderings, dismemberments, and many experiences like these—you must remember what I said earlier and not think that any of these things is being said to have actually happened like that or to have actually come to pass.122
He then goes on to summarize what is essentially the ‘gospel’ of Isis and Osiris, a typical mythic narrative of events transpiring on earth leading to Osiris’s death and resurrection.123 He then closes by repeating the point that Clea knows better than to really believe these stories, that ‘in fact, you yourself detest’ those who take them literally, and that she (like all true believers) sees them as ‘but window dressing’ that points us to something else more profound.124
Plutarch then goes on to survey what this underlying truth might actually be. He first brings up the theory of Euhemerus that all such tales are the mythification of past kings into current gods, but then he rejects this as impious and absurd.125 Instead, ‘better’, he says, is the theory that these earthly tales are of the ‘sufferings’ (pathēmata) not of gods or men, but of ‘great divinities’ (daimonōn megalōn, ‘great demons’ in Christian vernacular), divine beings with incarnate bodies capable of suffering and corruption. This, he says, was just as in other mystery cults (he alludes definitely to those of Dionysus and Demeter, meaning the Bacchic and Eleusinian mysteries, of which Clea was also a participant), where there are also ‘mythical stories’ told of the wanderings and sufferings of those gods, but ‘all is concealed behind mystic sacraments and initiations, not spoken or shown to the multitude’, thereby preserving the truth. Plutarch says the stories of Isis and Osiris ‘have the same explanation’.126 Hence it’s important to note that Paul also speaks of ‘the sufferings’ (pathēmata) of Christ, just as Plutarch says ‘the sufferings’ of other savior gods were spoken of in other mystery cults.127 As Plutarch explains, the true story is that Isis and Osiris are celestial gods engaged in a war in outer space between good and evil demons.128 The tales that relate their adventures on earth are just an allegory for this higher reality, which is actually going on in heaven (see Element 37).
Plutarch also explores another explanation, in which a god’s narrative myth is reduced to purely naturalistic and mystical allegories, and thus not about actual beings at all—but he indicates this is not the view he shares.129 He prefers the demonological theory, and accepts the other more thoroughgoing allegorization as only a supplemental explanation at best, concluding that ‘individually these theorists are wrong, but collectively they are right’ because all the things they describe are a part of the gods in question, not identical to those gods.130 He says these demigods control all the things their myths are said to allegorize; in fact, those who think the gods simply are these natural forces and mystical truths he denounces as atheists or idolators.131 Thus, Plutarch continually returns to and defends the demonological theory (in which cosmic good and evil beings, and their struggles and battles, lie behind it all) as being ‘the wisest’ view (just as Paul calls the secret teachings of Christianity the real wisdom, a wisdom not of this world, in 1 Corinthians 2).132 Plutarch cannot, of course, come out and tell us what the initiates to the Isiac mysteries are actually told. If he knew he would have been sworn to secrecy, and in any event would not offend Clea by exposing them to the public. But we can read between the lines: he would of course prefer of all explanations the one actually in accord with what the highest ranking initiates like Clea were taught. Thus we can infer it accorded most closely with his demonological theory. And as he says all other mystery religions have ‘similar explanations’, we can infer this was the common trend among them all.
It was common in fact to see all sacred literature (even revered poetry about the gods) as allegorical, not meant literally, such that one had to ‘lift the veil’ through interpretation to reveal the true meaning of a text, much as Paul says Christians must approach the OT (2 Cor. 3.12–4.6). Though Paul could imagine actual historical events being arranged to convey the allegory (1 Cor. 10.1-11) it’s obvious (as with Plutarch) that this would not always be a necessary understanding, even among Christians. For instance, Paul clearly does not regard the historicity of the tale of Sarah and Hagar to be relevant to his allegorical understanding of it, which he assumes his Christian congregations will readily accept (Gal. 4.22-31: see Chapter 11, §9). And anyone who welcomed the reading of sacred stories as allegory would welcome the writing of sacred stories as allegory. Obviously, since Paul believed the OT was so written and endorsed as such by God.
The same had already occurred among the pagans. Homer, for example, came to be increasingly read (even from as early as the time of Plato) as allegorically representing deeper cosmic truths through his superficial narratives of the gods, and as such Homer was treated as divinely inspired scripture.133 The Jews had already caught the same bug and were treating their scriptures the same way before Christianity arrived on the scene. And as Paul attests, Christians adopted the same practice. All simply embraced the same way of reading divine secrets out of sacred texts. The Jewish theologian Philo, for example, a contemporary of Paul, interprets the tale of Lot’s wife turning into a pillar of salt as an allegory for spurning a teacher’s instruction and locking one’s gaze instead on what one knew before.134 Thus such a story did not have to be historical to be ‘true’.
Not all myths and interpretations had merit. Philo could simultaneously denounce ‘cleverly devised fables’ while himself interpreting a biblical text as symbolic allegory and calling that the ‘real truth’. It depended, he argues, on whether one saw correctly, being in the right state of mind as one read: ‘as many as are able to contemplate the facts related’ in the stories of the Bible while they are ‘in their incorporeal and unclothed state, living rather in the soul than in the body’, will see that the true meaning lies in the allegory, not ‘what are contained in the plain words of the scriptures’.135 Philo thus says the tales of Eve and the Serpent ‘are not mere fabulous inventions, in which poets and sophists delight, but are rather types shadowing forth some allegorical truth, according to some mystical explanation’, and thus the story is symbolic.136 He regards Abraham’s father, Terah, as nonhistorical, merely an allegory, in contrast to Socrates, ‘who really existed’, and he likewise deems Sarah and Hagar as not real people but just allegorical symbols (just as Paul apparently did).137 Accordingly, Philo composed entire books about how to read the scriptures allegorically, and frequently relies on this procedure for understanding what the scriptures ‘really’ meant.138
If Philo respects reading sacred stories that way, he would have to respect composing them that way. Indeed, as historical events never in fact work out so neatly as an allegory requires, even if someone believed an allegorical story ‘had’ to also be superficially true (though it is clear Paul and Philo didn’t), an allegorical tale would still have to be invented and then passed off as superficially true. And as Plutarch explained for the mystery religions, this same thing would also be done to conceal the true meaning from the public. He describes the result of this as the multitude ‘superstitiously’ believing the stories are true, while initiates like Clea and himself knew better. For instance:
There is a doctrine which modern priests hint at to satisfy their conscience, but only in veiled terms and with caution: namely that the god Osiris rules and reigns over the dead, being none other than he whom the Greeks call Hades or Pluto. The truth of this statement is misunderstood and confuses the masses, who suppose that the sacred and the holy one, who is in truth Osiris, lives in the earth and under the earth, where are concealed the bodies of those who appear to have reached their end. He is actually very far removed from the earth [i.e., in outer space], being undefiled, unspotted, and uncorrupted by any being which is subject to decay and death.139
In fact, Plutarch believes, the souls of the dead ascend into outer space, where Osiris will preside over them as their heavenly king.140 This much Plutarch can reveal. The more sacred details he omits.
What the priests were doing by speaking this way was not deemed lying. For instance, Philo says Moses (whom Philo, like many Jews, believed wrote the Torah) tells no fable when he says ‘there were giants on the earth in those days’ (Gen. 6.4), but meant only allegorically that there were men of heavenly wisdom. Philo then says Moses would never tell a fable, because he only tells the truth, so, just like Plutarch, anyone who takes that statement about giants literally Philo compares to idolaters and men deceived.141 Thus, for Philo ‘the truth’ is the allegorical meaning of the text, not its literal meaning. We have to appreciate the significance of this. For us, even as Philo explains it, ‘Moses’ told a lie, plainly saying what is not true, that giants once walked the earth. But for Philo, as long as this statement has a higher symbolic meaning that is true, Moses isn’t lying. Those who don’t have the holy spirit of wisdom and understanding will only think he’s lying—or believe the literal meaning and thus believe what is false. Take note of this. Because people who think this way will both read and write books differently than we expect.142
The gospel story found in Mark, for example, could have begun as a set of mythic models for common Christian rituals and realities such as baptism and the Eucharist and facing persecution and martyrdom and performing miracles of healing, exorcism and prophecy. If that were so (and we’ll see how likely it is in Chapter 10), then we would have to conclude it also establishes a model for initiation into the secret teachings of the Christian mysteries (in Mk 4.11-12):
And [Jesus Christ] said unto [his closest followers], ‘Unto you is given the mystery of the kingdom of God: but to outsiders, everything is given in parables, so that seeing they may see, but not know; and hearing they may hear, but not comprehend; lest they should turn and be forgiven.’
Within the narrative Jesus is speaking of his parables (paraphrasing, or quoting a lost variant of, Isa. 6.9-10). But insiders might have been taught that the narrative itself is constructed the same way, and thus the notion that Jesus is speaking only of his parables is what outsiders are meant to think. Indeed, that the Gospel actually tells the secrets behind his parables suggests the real secrets lie elsewhere in the text, as otherwise they were here being revealed, which defeated the purpose of concealing them in the first place. We’ll see evidence of all this in Chapter 10. But here I mean only to establish its plausibility.
In his early-third-century rebuttal to the pagan critic Celsus (who wrote in the late second century), the Christian teacher Origen says an allegorical understanding of sacred writings is common to pagans, Jews and Christians, and that in fact Christians frequently understand the scriptures allegorically, including their own Gospels. ‘The historical parts’ of the Bible, Origen declares, ‘were written with an allegorical purpose, being most skillfully adapted not only for the multitude of the simpler believers, but also for the few who are willing or even able to investigate matters intelligently’. Indeed, he says, ‘what other inference can be drawn than that they were composed so as to be understood allegorically in their chief signification?’143 Those who approach the text literally, he says, have ‘a veil of ignorance’ upon them and thus ‘read but do not understand the figurative meaning’, whereas this veil ‘is taken away by the gift of God’ from those who have achieved sufficient philosophical perfection.144 Origen thus echoes what is said by Paul in 2 Corinthians 3, that readers of the Bible have a veil over their hearts which prevents them from understanding its true meaning—which, Paul makes clear, is the allegorical meaning. Origen even says that the Jewish and Christian narratives are better because they have been designed to be more morally edifying than the licentious fables of the pagans. Thus ‘our narratives keep expressly in view the multitude of simpler believers’, just as Plato had commanded be done, as Origen says, by purging all immoral tales from the poets and crafting only acceptable myths in their place (a leading theme of Plato’s Republic).
Origen is clear in meaning that the Gospels were likewise allegorically constructed and not to be taken literally as Celsus was doing.145 Origen cannot mean all the stories were ‘also’ literally true, as Celsus was arguing that they are in that case absurd, and Origen is responding by saying they are not absurd because they have a sublime allegorical meaning. But that only cancels their absurdity if they are not also literally true. At most, some of them may be true, while for the others their literal meaning only had use in edifying the ‘simpler’ believers in the way Plato had meant: false tales told in order to trick the masses into doing the right thing. Origen cites Plato’s very argument to that effect in his own defense, so he clearly meant the Bible (the NT included) served the same role. Elsewhere he is explicit: when it comes to the actual meaning of what the Gospels say, ‘mature’ believers are taught one thing, but ‘simpler’ believers are taught another, and in result, he says, many passages in the Gospels are literally false and only allegorically true; as Origen put it, ‘the spiritual truth was often preserved, as one might say, in a material falsehood’.146 And indeed, from extensive analyses of his writings, Joseph Trigg and Gunnar Hällström have each found that Origen did indeed believe it was better for the ‘simpleton’ to believe literally in what the Bible says even when that literal meaning isn’t true.147
This reasoning is most explicitly endorsed by Eusebius (in the early fourth century), who argues that it was necessary to lie like this for the cause of Christianity, and that the Bible thus contained many such lies—Eusebius even claims Plato got this edifying idea from the Bible. In fact, Eusebius’s entire treatise on God’s Preparation for the Gospel argues that every good idea the Greeks had actually came from Moses. And among those ‘good ideas’ Eusebius includes the following, under the heading ‘that it is necessary sometimes to use falsehood as a medicine for those who need’ it:
[As was said by the Athenian in Plato’s Laws] ‘And even the lawmaker who is of little use. . .if he dared lie to young men for a good reason, then can’t he lie? For falsehood is something even more useful than [the truth], and sometimes even more able to bring it about that everyone willingly keeps to all justice.’ [Then is said by Clinias] ‘Truth is beautiful, stranger, and steadfast. But to persuade people of it is not easy.’ You would find many things of this sort being used even in the Hebrew scriptures, such as concerning God being jealous or falling asleep or getting angry or being subject to some other human passions, for the benefit of those who need such an approach.148
To understand what Eusebius means, it is important to know how the Platonic dialogue he quotes continues:
Athenian: Be it so; yet it proved easy to persuade men of the Sidonian fairy-tale, incredible though it was, and of numberless others.
Clinias: What tales?
Athenian: The tale of the teeth that were sown, and how armed men sprang out of them. Here, indeed, the lawgiver has a notable example of how one can, if he tries, persuade the souls of the young of anything, so that the only question he has to consider in his inventing is what would do most good to the State, if it were believed; and then he must devise all possible means to ensure that the whole of the community constantly, so long as they live, use exactly the same language, so far as possible, about these matters, alike in their songs, their tales, and their discourses. If you, however, think otherwise, I have no objection to your arguing in the opposite sense.
Clinias: Neither of us, I think, could possibly argue against your view.149
Plato had already had the Athenian argue that justice is the only real road to happiness, and therefore by this argument people can be persuaded to be good. But he then addresses the possibility that the truth will not suffice, or that justice is not in fact the only real road to happiness, by arguing that lying is acceptable, and in fact even more effective in bringing about what is desired—that the people will be good—and thus teachers should employ lies for the benefit of the community.
The added significance here is the distinction being made between the ‘young’ as the targets of this manipulation: here we have the conceptual parallel to the ‘babes’ in Christ who need ‘milk’ because they are not yet ready to receive the real food (the true teaching) of the Christian religion (see Element 13). This is the very point Plato makes, saying that one thing is to be told to ‘the mature’ of understanding, and another thing told to ‘children’ (including adolescents, but metaphorically he means anyone philosophically immature), and from the latter the real truth will be kept, such that, he says, only after an initiation into the appropriate mysteries can they receive it.150 The second-century pagan orator Maximus of Tyre attests the same concept, even evoking the ‘milk’ metaphor.151 Eusebius agrees, as did Origen. This same attitude could thus have been ingrained within the church from its very inception.
As we saw before (in Element 13), in the early third century Clement of Alexandria also referred approvingly to the letters of Plato in which he makes the same argument, that the common people aren’t prepared to understand the truth and thus must be told a superficial lie to conceal it from them, and that it would be concealed within riddles and myths only symbolizing or pointing to the truth.152 Centuries later Augustine would condemn this widely held principle (that ‘it is expedient to deceive the people in matters of religion’, a view he suggests was also endorsed by the Roman scholar Varro in the early first century bce), yet at the same time still defends allegorical readings of the Bible when the literal meaning clearly could not be true (as when, e.g., it contradicted established science, a specific problem Augustine was apologetically addressing).153 Today we call that hypocrisy. At any rate, even Augustine, for all his protests, only confirms that the view was entrenched and widely embraced—even by himself.
Origen gives us the most candid discussion of this doctrine within the church: ‘Each person understands the Scriptures according to his capacity. One takes the sense from them more superficially, as if from the surface of a spring. Another draws up more deeply as from a well.’154 Though Origen thinks literal interpretations can be ‘helpful’ for edifying the ‘simple’ believer, they are not the actual truth, which can sometimes even be exactly the opposite. Sometimes Paul himself, Origen says, ‘wanted to conceal the forbidden meaning of a passage as something not appropriate for simple folk or for the common hearing of those who are led only by faith to what is better’, and yet, ‘so we would not mishear his words, he was then compelled’ to give clues to the real meaning of what he said, so that we would know ‘there was something forbidden and secret in that passage’. As for example, when Paul says, ‘Behold, I tell you a mystery’ about the nature of the resurrection, Origen says, ‘this is his way of introducing things deeper and more secret which are appropriately kept hidden from the multitude’. Origen concludes, ‘as is even written in Tobit, “It is good to keep the king’s mystery a secret”, but respectable and fitting “to honorably reveal the works of God” to the multitude with what is conveniently true’.155 Thus, there is a gospel for the simpleton (the ‘babes’ in Christ) and a gospel for ‘grown ups’, and Origen explains that the latter is concealed from the ‘simpleton’ because it might turn him away from the faith and thus away from salvation, while only a few people of sufficient maturity are really fit to understand the truth.156 Clement of Alexandria makes the same argument, using Paul’s own language of ‘carnal’ vs. ‘spiritual’ understanding of the Gospel text.157
It is in this context that we might better understand Paul’s claim that the gospel preached in public appeared to be ‘foolishness’ to outsiders, a ‘stumbling block’ to their understanding (1 Cor. 1.18-25; see Chapter 12, §4), but was not such to those who understood its secret meaning—the gospel not preached in public, but only to insiders (1 Cor. 2.4–3.3). This was quite the same in other mystery cults: when in his own mythic narrative Dionysus speaks in riddles and is called foolish, he responds, ‘One will seem to be foolish if he speaks wisely to an ignorant man’.158 Paul is in effect saying the same thing. So, too Origen. Thus it is plausible that, like other mystery cults, Christianity also came to be packaged with a set of earthly tales of its savior that were not meant to be taken literally, except by outsiders—and insiders of insufficient rank, who were variously called even by their own leaders ‘babes’ or ‘simpletons’.
Element 15: Christianity began as a charismatic cult in which many of its leaders and members displayed evidence of schizotypal personalities. They naturally and regularly hallucinated (seeing visions and hearing voices), often believed their dreams were divine communications, achieved trance states, practiced glossolalia, and were (or so we’re told) highly susceptible to psychosomatic illnesses (like ‘possession’ and hysterical blindness, muteness and paralysis).159 These phenomena have been extensively documented in modern charismatic cults within numerous religious traditions, and their underlying sociology, anthropology and psychology are reasonably well understood (in addition to what follows, see also Element 29).
For example, we know the first Christians regularly practiced glossolalia. Acts 2 mythologizes this phenomenon, depicting the first Christians ‘speaking in tongues’ in the middle of Jerusalem as if this actually meant miraculously speaking foreign languages fluently that they were never taught, when in fact we know ‘speaking in tongues’ actually meant (as it does now) babbling in random syllables, which no one could really understand except special interpreters who were ‘inspired’ by the holy spirit to miraculously understand and translate for their congregation. We know this because Paul tells us so (in 1 Corinthians 14; in fact the phenomenon is addressed throughout 1 Corinthians 12–14). Thus Acts has taken this real phenomenon and exaggerated it into a legendary power. But we know from Paul it operated differently. And in fact, the phenomenon Paul describes is known across the world, in countless cultures and religious traditions, and has been extensively studied.160 When we see in antiquity a phenomenon we’ve documented scientifically as commonly occurring in various cultures, it’s far more likely to be the same phenomenon than something entirely new yet coincidentally identical. We must therefore conclude the first Christians had some social and anthropological similarities to other cults that practice glossolalia.
Acts represents this as a recurring practice in the church: Acts 10.46; 19.6 (confirmed in Mk 16.17); and in 1 Cor. 14.18, Paul himself says he spoke in tongues more than anyone, and throughout that chapter makes clear it was so commonly happening to others in his churches that he had to set up rules to govern it. And as for glossolalia, so for the other phenomena Paul reports as regularly practiced by the first Christians. The most important of which for our purposes was hallucination (visual and auditory). Humans are actually biologically predisposed to hallucinate. The neurophysiology of hallucination is built-in and thus must have evolved for some useful function (or as a side-effect of something else that did). Studies of shamanism and the cultural role of prophets and holy men have found evidence that hallucinators were often given positions of religious authority across the world, possibly even as far back as prehistoric times.161 The propensity to hallucinate is molded by cultural context (people hallucinate frequently in cultures that promote and accept it, but suppress their capacity to hallucinate in cultures that denigrate and reject it), but also exists on a biological spectrum, from almost no capacity to a crippling capacity—and everything in between.162
Schizophrenia results when your biological propensity to hallucinate is ramped up to such an extreme that it interferes with your ability to function. This is how most mental disorders originate. For example, a natural and necessary brain function that prompts us to remember whether we have completed a necessary task (and to clean and organize things, and to build mental lists of what we have to do or have already done, and so on), when overactive leads to a disability called OCD (obsessive-compulsive disorder). Depression is likewise an extreme and hasty activation of otherwise normal emotions. Thus many functions appear in populations along a spectrum. In the case of behaviors such as organizing, cleaning, double-checking, some people have weak motivators (people who routinely forget things and don’t care about being disorganized); most have normal motivators of varying degree (from carefree to fastidious), and some have strong motivators (and those people we say have OCD). Likewise with hallucination: some people have no capacity for it, some have a normal capacity for it in varying degrees (further modulated by their culture), and some have an overriding capacity for it (and become disabled by schizophrenia). Those in the middle are called ‘normals’ or ‘neurotypicals’.
Normals can hallucinate when exposed to triggers. The most common of which is sleep paralysis (where normals hallucinate at the threshold between being asleep and awake); but the most familiar are pharmaceuticals (many drugs induce hallucination, including several that were not only available in antiquity but known in antiquity), while the most culturally transmitted are trance behaviors.163 Extreme fatigue, heat, illness, fasting, grief and sleep or sensory deprivation (‘incubation’) can all induce hallucination in normals. And by the time of Christianity, cultural practices had long developed to intentionally trigger hallucination, including fasting and sensory or sleep deprivation, but more typically rhythmic prayer or chanting or the use of music or dance to induce an ecstatic state (Paul alludes to singing and prayer as likely trance-inducing behaviors in his congregations in 1 Cor. 14.12-15; see also Acts 16.25; Eph. 5.19; and Col. 3.16; which might suggest also dance, as in other cultures whirling or spinning are known triggers). Fasting (i.e., starving) is also attested within the church.164 But with increasing experience, a normal can hallucinate more easily, with minimal use of triggers, depending on their biological propensity.165 Such trance-inducing behaviors had already become a standard feature of Jewish religion by the time Christianity began.166
In fact, normals with a high propensity for hallucination have been identified as schizotypal, meaning they hallucinate nearly as easily as schizophrenics do but are not so prone to it as to be disabled. A schizotypal is ‘a relatively well-adjusted person who is functional despite, and in some cases even because of, his or her anomalous perceptual experiences’.167 Hallucination in schizotypals in fact has been shown to reduce their anxiety and thus has a positive personal function. In modern cultures a prevalent hostile attitude toward hallucinatory behavior still often drives schizotypals to become loners (because they are characterized as weirdos or insane and there is no recognized place for them), but in cultures that embrace hallucinators we see the opposite. For example, where we find cults that socially integrate schizotypals or even elevate them to positions of leadership, we find that schizotypals begin to congregate and socialize.168 In fact, culture determines how easily and frequently even normals will hallucinate, as well as how accepted and revered schizotypals will be.169 Modern ‘first world’ cultures are actually profoundly atypical among world cultures in stigmatizing and suppressing hallucinatory tendencies.170 As scientific observers have concluded, ‘the folk theory of visions and voices adopted by a culture may be important in determining whether a hallucination is viewed as veridical or as evidence of insanity’, which in turn greatly affects the commonality and acceptance of hallucination within a population.171
Accordingly, in antiquity, where schizotypals would routinely be regarded as prophets and holy men (and not seen as insane, as they are in modern cultures), we can expect schizotypals will actually gravitate into religious cults that socially integrate them or even grant them influence and status. The availability of niches of strong social support for schizotypals would explain why in antiquity there were few reported cases of psychosis (and why hallucination was not regarded as a major index of insanity except when wholly crippling or conjoined with fever), and why miracles and visions (not just Christian and Jewish, but pagan as well) were so frequently reported and widely believed to be genuine. Obviously schizotypals would prefer the company of people who take them seriously. As a result, they will tend to be found in religious movements that did not originate within the governing elite (where Greek ideals of scientific rationalism largely prevailed). In fact, we should expect the leaders and originators of revelatory movements such as Christianity to have commonly been schizotypal.172 After all, where else would we find them?
And yet even non-schizotypals can become regular trance hallucinators within cults and cultures that encourage and develop their capacities in this regard. Even in hostile cultures (like our own), normals find themselves hallucinating with remarkable frequency, particularly within the context of religious assumptions and expectations (Christians hallucinate Christ; Buddhists hallucinate Buddha), and psychological priming (UFO enthusiasts hallucinate encounters with aliens; the bereaved hallucinate encounters with the recently deceased).173 In cultures that encouraged, rewarded and facilitated this phenomenon, normals would be even more prone to hallucinate, and their hallucinations would even more closely conform to priming, anchoring, suggestion and cultural framing.174 I have elsewhere discussed the anthropology of prophets and how their deepest, most reverent plans or desires will manifest in their visions, as will solutions to cognitive dissonance. In fact, there I also discuss how the esteem in which hallucinators were held could easily inspire motivated leaders to pretend to be schizotypal.175 This is ironic, as in our culture we would expect people to pretend not to be schizotypal, as being such is stigmatized rather than esteemed. But this only illustrates how very different ancient culture was from our own, a fact we must take into account when explaining the origins of Christianity. At any rate, this anthropological fact entails the first apostles may have only pretended to have visions and spirit communications, although we lack the kind of data we would need to distinguish pretense from reality in their case.176
Among the ways that social pressures and constructs can mold collective hallucination and limit hallucinatory content, social hierarchy and hazard is a major factor relevant to cults like Christianity.177 If acceptance in a group requires shared experience and affirmation of shared beliefs and perceptions, people will be inclined to hallucinate what the group expects (or even claim to have done so, when in fact they didn’t).178 Thus ‘mass hallucination’ occurs in various cults not in the sense that everyone objectively hallucinates exactly the same thing, but in the sense that everyone subjectively hallucinates what they believe is the same thing. And that can occur when a whole congregation simultaneously engages trance-inducing triggers and a common experience is sought—perhaps at the behest of a charismatic leader anchoring everyone to the same experience through the power of suggestion. They don’t check every detail, because if they report the same things in rough outline, then the differences (if any are even reported) will be overlooked (as a result of our innate tendency toward verification bias) or even adopted by others through memory contamination, such that experiences are remembered as even more similar the more they are discussed. This contamination can occur even during the process of hallucination, as what one member, especially an anchoring leader, says then influences others to have the same experience. These effects will manifest when hallucinating subjects are pressured or socialized to conform to the group (or desire to so conform) and when what one ‘experiences’ in trance states is regarded as a major test of such belonging, as was the case in earliest Christianity.179
This role of social pressure can also set constraints based on social hierarchy. In modern Shaker cults, for example, if in your visions and hallucinations of heavenly beings you claim Jesus Christ appeared to you, this is understood as claiming apostolic election—you are claiming God is choosing you for leadership status within the church. If the existing leadership hierarchy or even members of the congregation do not agree with this appointment, whether out of disapproval or envy (or simple practicality: not everyone can be in charge), they would accuse the person of lying or having been misled by a false or deceiving spirit (a tactic we know the earliest Christians employed).180 If enough members and leaders backed this play, the person would either have to recant, be exorcised or expelled.
The mere knowledge that this can happen (plus the understanding of the hardships and responsibilities that attend even successfully becoming an apostle) thus suppresses hallucinations of Jesus. Members will consistently hallucinate other beings instead (or only ever report having done so), simply to avoid conflict or denunciation (or to avoid a missionary or leadership role altogether). We should expect this same social phenomenon in the original church, which is why only apostles ‘saw the Lord’, as that is what it was to be an apostle: to be one whom the Lord chose to reveal himself (1 Cor. 9.1; 15.5-8; Gal. 1.11-12; note how Gal. 1.8 indicates that revelations from lesser divinities couldn’t make one an apostle). This also explains why their number was limited. The Lord might still communicate to lower ranking members through intermediaries (angels and benevolent spirits), but you dare not claim to have ‘seen the Lord’ unless you were ready to fight (and were likely to win) the ensuing socio-political battle for acceptance as an apostle (a status Paul had to labor greatly to achieve for himself, as revealed in Galatians 1–2).
All of this provides considerable background support to what several scholars have already argued: that the origin of Christianity can be attributed to hallucinations (actual or pretended) of the risen Jesus. The prior probability of this conclusion is already extremely high, given the background evidence just surveyed; and the consequent probabilities strongly favor it as well, given the evidence we can find in the NT.181 Christian fundamentalists are really the only ones who do not accept this as basically an established fact by now. But it is important to acknowledge the broader point as well, that Christian leaders, and many congregants, were either schizotypal or normal trance-induced hallucinators (or pretended to be), and they routinely engaged in hearing voices and seeing visions from heaven (or pretended to), and moreover regarded anything their subconscious mind hit upon during an ecstatic state as an inspired communication through the holy spirit.182
There are many reasons not to trust Acts as a faithful record of much that went on in the early church (as I’ll show in Chapters 7 and 9), but it may contain hints and reflections of historical reality, as in the case of speaking in tongues: a real phenomenon widely practiced in the church, but in Acts so mythologized that at best only the skeletal core of the story can be trusted, not any of the details. Just as in this case, we also have confirmation in Paul that Christian leaders and congregants regularly hallucinated visions and voices; so when we find similar reports in Acts we can expect this reflects, and thus confirms, the same underlying reality, such that some of these reports might derive from the skeletal core of a true story, and even those that don’t (but are instead wholly fabricated to suit the author’s purpose) still likely reflect a phenomenon in general that was familiar to the author and his Christian readers.
Thus, in Acts 2, we see the entire church hallucinating floating tongues of fire and then babbling in tongues in a mass ecstatic trance. In Acts 7, in the middle of the Sanhedrin court, Stephen hallucinates Jesus floating up in the sky, but no one else there sees it. In Acts 9, Paul hallucinates a booming voice and a beaming light from heaven (and suffers hysterical blindness as a result); and Ananias hallucinates an entire conversation with God. In Acts 10, Cornelius hallucinates a conversation with an angel, and Peter falls into a trance and hallucinates an entire cosmic dinner scene in the sky. In Acts 16, Paul hallucinates a revelation of a man who tells him where to travel (this story probably drawing in one way or another on Paul’s own mention of receiving such a revelation in Gal. 2.2). In Acts 27, Paul hallucinates a conversation with an angel. Many Christians receive spirit communications (‘prophesy’), as indicated in Acts 19.6 and 21.9-10—and Acts 2.17, which quotes Joel 2.28-31 as being fulfilled in the church: ‘I will pour out my Spirit upon all flesh, and your sons and your daughters shall prophesy, and your young men shall see visions, and your old men shall dream dreams’.
Paul confirms this general picture first-hand. In Gal. 1.11-12, Paul says he learned the gospel only from a hallucinated encounter with Jesus (a ‘revelation’) whom he experienced ‘within’ himself (Gal. 1.16). He confirms this in Rom. 16.25-26, where Paul says, ‘My gospel and the preaching of Jesus Christ is according to a revelation’.183 The other apostles received their information from revelations as well. ‘Unto us’, Paul says (meaning the apostles), ‘God revealed [the secrets of the gospel] through the Spirit’ (1 Cor. 2.10). And in 1 Cor. 15.1-8 Paul says, ‘the gospel I preached’ (which in Galatians and Romans he confirms came only by revelation) is the same gospel Peter and the others preached (this is the whole gist of Galatians 1 and 2: see discussion in Chapter 11), who also experienced special isolated visions of the Christ just like Paul’s, which again was the qualifying requirement to be an apostle (1 Cor. 9.1: ‘Am I not an apostle? Have I not seen Jesus our Lord?’). In Gal. 2.2, Paul mentions having another revelation that gave him instructions on where he should go and what he should do, as if there were nothing remarkable about this, indicating he had revelations often, and his congregants accepted this as normal.
Likewise, in Rom. 12.6, Paul says Christians in all congregations ‘have gifts differing according to the grace that was given to us; if it be prophecy, let us prophesy according to the proportion of our faith’ (and Paul indicates that these prophets were communicating with spirits, which were under the prophet’s control: 1 Cor. 14.19-32). Thus, in 1 Cor. 11.4-5, Paul sets rules for ‘every man praying or prophesying’ in the churches and ‘every woman praying or prophesying’, and in 1 Corinthians 14, Paul sets rules to prevent a problem arising in the church of so many people describing their hallucinations and spirit communications and speaking in tongues that they were talking over one another (on hallucinations in particular: 1 Cor. 14.26, 30).
In 1 Cor. 12.10, Paul elaborates on the gifts the holy spirit had given members of the church, and they include ‘to some, prophecy; to others, the discerning of spirits; to another the power of speaking in tongues; and to another the interpretation of those tongues’. In 1 Cor. 12.28, Paul ranks the members of the church in order of authority: ‘God has set some in the church, first apostles, secondly prophets, thirdly teachers, then those with powers [he most likely means exorcists], then charismatic healers, then aids, administrators, and speakers in tongues’, indicating a whole gamut of behaviors in the church that make original Christianity even more similar to modern cults engaged in the same (see also Eph. 1.17; 3.2-5; 4.11; and Hebrews 2). The ability to ‘discern spirits’ meant an intuitive (they would say ‘inspired’) judgment of whether a spirit communicating with a member is of God or the Devil, which further confirms the frequency of auditory hallucinations (and the readiness with which ‘intuition’ was interpreted as divinely inspired). We see this in 1 Thess. 5.20, where Paul says they should not shun prophesying in the church but test the spirits that communicate with them (see also 1 Jn 4.1–5.13, e.g., ‘do not believe every spirit that communicates with you’).184
In 2 Corinthians 12, Paul says he and others have many glorious ‘visions and revelations of the Lord’, and among these he includes hallucinated trips to heaven where the hallucinator hears and sees strange things, much like the entire book of Revelation, which is a veritable acid trip, an extended hallucination of the bizarrest kind, an example of the kind of thing going on all the time in the early churches (even despite the fact that that particular example is probably wholly fabricated). Paul then goes on to relate in that same chapter a whole two-way conversation he had with God, demonstrating that he not only heard voices but conversed with them; he also says he experiences an ‘abundance of revelations’ (2 Cor. 12.7). And in 1 Cor. 14.6, Paul says ‘what use am I to you, unless I speak to you by way of a revelation, or knowledge [gnōsis, meaning spiritual knowledge], or prophesying, or teaching?’ which entails hallucination was both respected and expected of him; it was also desired and sought after in the church among all the congregants (1 Cor. 14.1, ‘earnestly desire these spiritual gifts’, and 1 Cor. 14.12, ‘you are eager for them’).
Similarly, the fact that Christians regarded as inspired scripture such books as Daniel, which depict authoritative information coming from God through both visions and dreams, entails that Christians believed authoritative information came from God through visions and dreams (otherwise they would not deem such books as honest or reliable, much less scripture). They could therefore see their own visions and dreams as communications from God, too. Thus, even if books such as Revelation are fabricated, as symbolic discourses on the times, they still represent themselves as genuine hallucinatory experiences. As Rev. 1.1-2 says, the whole book describes:
the revelation of Jesus Christ, which God provided to show to his servants what must soon take place, and he made it known by sending his angel to his servant John, who bore witness to the word of God and to the testimony of Jesus Christ, even to all that he saw.
Which means even as a fabrication this book still demonstrates the esteem with which even the wildest hallucinatory experiences were held, which were believed so fervently to be genuine experiences that an author could gain authority for what he was writing by claiming to have hallucinated it. This is a radically different cultural context than we live in now.
As we’ll see in the next chapter (Element 29), earliest Christianity can be characterized as a revitalization movement. It is thus notable that ‘trance behavior’, including the regular mission-oriented hallucination among leaders and members, ‘looms large in the descriptive data of most of the revitalization movements known from the historical and the ethnographic record’, which movements also frequently practice glossolalia, prophesy, ‘faith healing’, possession and exorcism.185 Earliest Christianity thus perfectly aligns with known anthropological models, and can only be understood in that context.
Element 16: The earliest Christians claimed they knew at least some (if not all) facts and teachings of Jesus from revelation and scripture (rather than from witnesses), and they regarded these as more reliable sources than word-of-mouth (only many generations later did Christian views on this point noticeably change). As Paul says in Rom. 16.25-26:
My gospel and the preaching of Jesus Christ [is] according to the revelation of the mystery which was kept secret for long ages, but now is made visible through the prophetic scriptures and is made known to all nations, according to the command of the eternal God, for the obedience of faith.186
And in Galatians 1 he swears up and down, repeatedly, that he did not learn the gospel from oral tradition, but revelation alone, thus illustrating the order of values: he and his congregations respected revelations far more than human traditions (see Chapter 11, §§2 and 6).187
That some teachings and sayings of the Lord came by revelation, not from a living Jesus, has been noted before.188 The entire book of Revelation establishes this happened: not only in that book do new teachings come from a (supposedly) hallucinated Jesus, but this imaginary Jesus even dictates entire letters (Rev. 1.17–3.22). Paul’s belief that Jesus preached that we can abandon the Torah law and still be saved likewise came to him by revelation (as Galatians 1–2 establishes: see Elements 19 and 20). Paul even credits his knowledge of the inauguration of the Eucharist meal (what Jesus said and did on that occasion) as coming to him directly ‘from the Lord’, which means the content of 1 Cor. 11.23-27 was learned in a vision (see Chapter 11, §7). Otherwise he would cite his actual authority (whoever it was who told him of this), and not ‘the Lord’, since otherwise it’s obvious the words to follow come from the Lord, so that would not have to be stated unless to indicate that that’s where Paul learned of them (as he says: ‘I received this from the Lord’, not someone else). Paul likewise says in Rom. 16.25-26 that Jesus’ kērygma, the ‘message he preached’, came by revelation. In Rom. 8.2, Paul says ‘Jesus Christ will reveal these things to you, that I speak truly. He is the mouth altogether free from falsehood, by which the Father has truly spoken’, which confirms that people often received communications from Jesus via revelation (even if indirectly: i.e., through intuited feelings attributed to the holy spirit, or visions or prophetic messages communicated through angels or subordinate spirits), and no one thought this was unusual or inferior to any other source. To the contrary, Paul’s argument in Galatians 1 entails Christians had the opposite view: that information derived by revelation was more authoritative and trustworthy than any human tradition (again, see Chapter 11, §§2 and 6).
Thus, Paul frequently rests on the authority of things Jesus said, and yet in 2 Cor. 13.3 he says ‘you desire proof that Christ is speaking in me’ (per Gal. 1.16) which entails he received at least some of these teachings of Jesus through revelation—and some among his congregations dared question if he really had or if they were really coming from Jesus, rather than a false spirit. Confirming this is the fact that in 1 Cor. 14.37, Paul says his rules of order for the commotion in the church (of a mass of people talking over and interrupting one another announcing revelations, prophesying, speaking in tongues, and interpreting them: see Element 15) are ‘a command of the Lord’ (in contrast to occasions where he says he has no command of the Lord to cite: e.g. 1 Cor. 7.25). But it is very improbable that a living Jesus would have foreseen the complex discipline problem going on in Paul’s churches, so as to have pronounced rules for it (long before the problem ever existed or even could have existed), and it is clear no one at Corinth had heard of these rules before; because they were newly created to deal with the occasion—yet, Paul says, they should obey them, because ‘the Lord commands it’. Paul was therefore still receiving teachings from the celestial Jesus.
And of course anything Jesus taught after his ‘resurrection’ (and indeed the very fact of his resurrection) came to the earliest Christians by revelation. This is confirmed by 1 Cor. 15.1-8, where the ‘gospel’ that Paul ‘received’ and ‘preached’ came by revelation, not a transmitted human tradition, and that the risen Jesus only ‘appeared’ in visions to everyone just as to himself. The first point is confirmed by identical wording: ‘I would have you know, brethren, that the gospel I preached . . . I did not receive it from a man, nor was I taught it, but it came through a revelation of Jesus Christ’ (Gal. 1.11-12), which corresponds to, ‘I would have you know, brethren, that the gospel I preached . . . I delivered to you in the first place what I also received’ (1 Cor. 15.1, 3). No other conclusion is possible: the facts following this declaration are the very facts he claims to have learned only by revelation (even if on different occasions), and those facts are ‘that, according to the scriptures, Christ died for our sins, and that he was buried, and that, according to the scriptures, he rose again on the third day, and that he appeared’ to various apostles at various times (1 Cor. 15.4-8). I’ll discuss this further in Chapter 11 (§§2 and 4).
Paul always assumes there was no difference between the Lord’s appearance to him and the Lord’s appearances to others (Paul makes no distinction in 1 Cor. 9.1, where ‘seeing the Lord’ makes you an apostle, with no special status being imagined for those who saw the Lord in any way other than he did), and he never has to make any apology for it being otherwise (he simply assumes everyone accepts that his authority is equal to any other apostle’s: see Chapter 11, §2). And this conforms to natural probability (i.e., it is vastly more likely that these appearances were hallucinated, in reality or pretense, than that anyone actually rose from the dead). Above all, the sequence of appearances in 1 Cor. 15.5-8 entails singular, isolated events that lasted only briefly. Clearly Jesus was not hanging around during it all. He appeared only momentarily, to one or another apostle or group, and then others had to await another event to see him. This is explicit when Paul says Jesus appeared ‘at the same time’ only once to a large number of brethren, but not on any other of the occasions listed. This fits hallucinatory encounters, not a leader alive again rallying his followers.
All of the above confirms that some Christians could claim to know some teachings by and things about Jesus by revelation. But second to this, some facts about and teachings and sayings from the Lord were known by finding them ‘hidden’ in scripture. Again, Paul said that ‘my gospel and the preaching of Jesus Christ’ does not just come from revelations but is also ‘now made visible through the prophetic scriptures’ (Rom. 16.25-26). Accordingly, Paul says we must resort to the scriptures to ‘teach us’ things about Jesus (Rom. 15.3-4), and that we should not ‘go beyond’ the scriptures in our claims about Jesus (1 Cor. 4.6). In Rom. 1.1-6, Paul says ‘the gospel’ of Jesus was written ‘beforehand through the prophets in the holy scriptures’. And thus, of course, it is outright stated in Jn 20.9 that ‘they knew not the scripture, that he must rise from the dead’ and in Lk. 24.25-27 and 24.44-47, where Jesus declares that ‘everything written about me in the law of Moses and the prophets and the psalms must be fulfilled’ such that when you understand the scriptures properly you will see ‘it is written that the Christ should suffer and on the third day rise from the dead, and that repentance and forgiveness of sins should be preached in his name to all nations’ (essentially what Paul himself means in Gal. 3.1).
Such statements suggest that when Paul says in 1 Cor. 15.3-4 that ‘according to the scriptures’ Jesus died for our sins, was buried and rose on the third day, he might not mean these things happened in accordance with prophecy, but that in fact the scriptures are where we learn of them. The same exact phrase ‘according to x’ is how sources were cited in antiquity (e.g. ‘according to Herodotus, the Greeks defeated the Persians’). Thus Paul appears to be saying what Jesus is made to say in Luke, that these facts are learned about Jesus from the scriptures, and that extracting that information from the scriptures requires proper divine inspiration (Lk. 24.45). Thus Rom. 16.25-26 could be saying that a hallucinated Jesus taught Paul (and other apostles) exactly what the risen Jesus teaches them in Luke 24: that certain facts about him can be found in the scriptures, and how to find them.
I do not claim to have proved that point here, but only to have established its plausibility, from all the remaining evidence (likewise in the next element). Fully confirming that plausibility is the fact that pre-Christian Jews were already doing this. They, too, were finding ‘hidden messages’ in the scriptures and thereby learning ‘facts’ about their present reality and God’s plans and deeds.189 The entire pesher genre was devoted to that very thing (see Element 8; and for an example, Element 5). If Jews were already doing this in droves before Christianity, and then Christians suddenly appeared preaching that they, too, had found ‘secret messages’ in the Bible, we must conclude they may well have been getting their information from the Bible, in the very same way other Jews were. In other words, we cannot declare this to be too improbable to propose. Because there is sufficient background evidence to lend it credence. Likewise claiming revelation as a source of information. That is clear from the book of Revelation, for example, but again from Jewish precedent, where revelation was a routine source of information about earthly and heavenly beings and events and God’s plan for them. Like the Ascension of Isaiah discussed in Chapter 3 (§1), and the book of Daniel, and the Enochic literature (which the earliest Christians regarded as scripture).
The precedent is thus well established. A living, earthly Jesus was simply not the only available source for receiving sayings and teachings from and about him.
Element 17: The fundamental features of the gospel story of Jesus can be read out of the Jewish scriptures. The influence of the OT on the NT has been much written on,190 but here I mean to say that this fact, in conjunction with the evidence of previous elements (e.g. the pre-Christian pesher literature, Christian claims to have found hidden information in the scriptures, etc.), makes it plausible to ask whether the gospel was actually discovered and learned from the scriptures, rather than the scriptures being consulted after the fact as a merely defensive reinforcement for key claims Christians were making supposedly on other grounds. For this point it’s enough to illustrate how easy it would have been to do this, even beyond what was already shown in Element 6.191
As I’ve already noted, the Wisdom of Solomon declares that the wicked will ‘condemn to a shameful death’ the holiest man of God (which in the first century would entail a crucifixion, in contrast to an honorable death like decapitation), because they are ‘blinded by their wickedness’ and ‘do not know the secret purposes of God’ (Wis. 2.20-22; compare 1 Cor. 2.7-9); this righteous man they kill will be the ‘son of god’ (Wis. 2.18), who criticizes the current religious order and promotes strange teachings (Wis. 2.12-16); those who kill him will scorn and reject him, and mock him during his torture and execution, saying surely God will come to rescue him (which, to an interpreter looking for hidden connections, links this text with the same man in Ps. 22.7-8, which Psalm is heavily drawn upon to construct the crucifixion scene in Mark 15: see Chapter 10, §4); and this righteous man will be killed but then restored to life and exalted by God to stand again and judge those who killed him (Wisdom 5).
Earlier I demonstrated the links some Jews had likely made between the ‘messiah’ killed in Daniel 9 and the ‘righteous servant’ killed in Isaiah 52–53 (Element 5). The ‘righteous man and son of God’ killed in Wisdom of Solomon (who is, like the innocent righteous man killed in Isaiah, scorned and rejected of men, executed, and then exalted by God) could easily have been linked to the same network of passages and thus believed to have been prophetical of the same messiah, which then (as just noted above) ties into that network also Psalm 22, which gives us the three-day cycle: first Psalm 22, execution and mockery (v. 16 even implying crucifixion specifically, especially in variants known at Qumran); then Psalm 23, burial and sojourn among the dead (the funeral psalm); and then Psalm 24, ascension and exaltation ‘on the first day of the week’, where the very same unusual phrasing found in Mk 16.1 is found in Ps. 24.1 in the lxx (thus Mark is clearly quoting, and therefore alluding to, that Psalm), which altogether gives us the entire gospel spelled out by Paul in 1 Cor. 15.3-4.192
Tying all of this in to Isaiah is what gives us the strongest evidence of this: the particular, and peculiar, concept of this messiah dying ‘for our sins’ (which notion is only reinforced by linking this to Dan. 9.24, which would then imply the same thing). The relevant material in Isaiah describes an itinerant preacher whose beautiful feet walk the land ‘bringing the gospel’ and ‘announcing salvation’ (Isa. 52.7). This preacher God ‘will reveal’ to all nations, but possibly only through an elect few (52.10, using apokalypsei, the term for revelation; that he is revealed only to an elect few, and then reported to others, is implied in 53.1; just as Clement appears to have thought of Jesus: see Chapter 8, §5). This preacher is ‘God’s servant’ (‘God’s child’ in the Septuagint) who will ‘deal wisely and be exalted and raised up very high’ (52.13) even though he will be ‘despised, and rejected of men, a man of sorrows, and acquainted with grief’ (53.3). In fact, ‘he has borne our griefs and carried our sorrows’ (in the Septuagint ‘he bears our sins and suffers for us’) and though we thought he was being punished by God (53.4), in fact ‘he was wounded for our sins, he was bruised for our iniquities’ or even pierced for our iniquities in some pre-Christian manuscripts (see note in Element 9). Indeed, ‘with his stripes we are healed’ (53.5) because ‘the Lord gave him up for our sins’ (53.6; the word is paradidōmi in the Septuagint, identical to the word often translated as ‘he was betrayed’ in 1 Cor. 11.23, even though referring to exactly the same event, his being delivered up to die for our sins; and likewise this is the same word used for that event throughout the Gospels: see Chapter 11, §7). Explicitly, he is killed even though innocent, and killed specifically ‘because of the sins’ of God’s people (53.8-9), for God ‘shall make his life an offering for sin’ (53.10) because he ‘bears their sins’ (53.11). And this servant will then be exalted by God and his days prolonged (and also in reward he shall be shown the light of understanding, receive an inheritance, and divide all spoils with the mighty) ‘because he poured out his life unto death, and was numbered with the transgressors, yet bore the sin of many, and made intercession for the transgressors’ (53.11-12) That a later second temple Jew would readily take to mean he would be resurrected (as the only obvious way you can die yet be rewarded for this death with a prolonging of your days, and receiving wisdom and inheritance and spoils, is to be made alive again). All just from Isaiah 52–53. Connecting this to the nearly identical figure described in the Wisdom of Solomon would only make this all the more obvious, likewise the figures in Psalms 22 and Daniel 9 and 12 (as well as Zechariah 3 and 6).
All of this is not itself a proof that Christians did find every key element of their gospel by scouring scripture for secret messages, producing their gospel like a pesher (with assistance from ‘revelations’ and ecstatic ‘inspiration’). But the evidence above is sufficient to establish that they could have. The usual claim, of course, is that Christians sought out Isaiah 53 after the fact (and all scholars agree it was a key text employed by Christians as a prophecy of their Christ), and not as inspiration (i.e., finding the passage first, and then concocting a savior to match). But we don’t really know it was the one and not the other (see Element 16). Prior to any specific evidence either way, the one is as likely as the other. The ease with which we can produce the Christian gospel solely by constructing a messianic pesher out of the OT scriptures (and other scriptures the Christians used) is therefore something we must include in our background knowledge.
Element 18: Jesus Christ was regarded as having fulfilled (and thereby replacing) by his death the two greatest annual sacrifices in the Jewish religion, Passover and Yom Kippur (see Element 10), and thereby had replaced the temple as a relevant religious institution (see Element 28).
Passover celebrated the Jews’ rescue from death, which began their exodus from Egypt to the Promised Land (Exodus 12). The angel of death ‘passed over’ their houses, sparing their lives, on account of the blood of the sacrificed lamb (or goat: 12.5) smeared across their door frame (sides and crossbeam), whose flesh they also ate in communal household meals (12.7-13, 22-23). The Passover sacrifice was killed and eaten ‘in the night’ (12.6, 8), just as the Eucharist was (1 Cor. 11.23-26), and many commentators have noted the similarities between them (see Chapter 11, §7). Yom Kippur cleansed the whole congregation of Israel of all its sins for one year, and so this sacrifice had to be repeated every year to maintain its salutary effect (Lev. 16), and in between various lesser sacrifices had to be performed for specific sins committed since the last general atonement. That atonement sacrifice, procuring a general forgiveness of sins, was called the Day of Atonement (Lev. 23.27). Two goats were chosen and lots were cast (Lev. 16.7-10), choosing one to ‘carry the sins’ of Israel and be driven into the wilderness (16.8-10, 21-22), while the other was killed and its blood sprinkled on the altar to atone for Israel’s sins (16.15-16, 30-34).
Paul declared that ‘Christ is our Passover sacrifice’ (1 Cor. 5.7) and therefore God will ‘pass over’ our sins (Rom. 3.25; see also evidence in Element 43), while at the same time preaching that Christ was the definitive atonement sacrifice (and therefore the definitive Yom Kippur).193 Hebrews 9 lays this out in detail (see Chapter 11, §5). Although Paul is not its author and its date is disputed (see Chapter 7, §3), nevertheless, Paul clearly taught this, too, frequently saying Jesus’ death atoned for all sins once and for all (1 Cor. 15.3; Gal. 1.4; 3.13; 2 Cor. 5.18-19; Rom. 3.24-26; 5.6-11), which was the function of the Yom Kippur sacrifice (except that that had to be repeated every year, whereas Christ’s was final, for reasons explained in Hebrews). Thus the earliest gospel combined the two major Jewish rituals of salvation: from death (as the angel ‘passed over’ the households protected by the lamb’s blood) and from all other wages of sin (the annual cleansing of Israel’s sins by the ritual of the goats at Yom Kippur), thereby connecting atonement with salvation and eternal life. (Further reason why the death of Jesus was connected with Passover and not just Yom Kippur is provided in Element 43, which shall more directly survey the Jewish background.)
Per Element 10, the earliest known Christian ‘gospel’ preached that Jesus’ death had atoned for all sins and procured salvation for all adherents. Christians therefore had no need for the Jewish temple or any of its rituals, which existed for the purpose of maintaining a conduit to God and cleansing Jews of their sins (e.g. Lev. 4 and 16). Christians now had their own conduit to God (Jesus Christ ‘in us’) and were permanently cleansed of all sins (by Jesus’ death) and therefore had no need of priests to act as intermediary. Accordingly, as the Epistles make clear, priests had no more role to play in Christian worship, communion with God, or salvation.
Therefore, a distinguishing element of the earliest Christian sect of Judaism was that Christians themselves are now the temples of god (Gal. 6.14-17) and thus God dwells in them (1 Cor. 3.16; 6.19; 2 Cor. 6.16). Likewise Eph. 2.19-22 and 3.16-19 and 1 Peter 2 (e.g. ‘like living stones be yourselves built into a spiritual house, to be a holy priesthood, to offer spiritual sacrifices acceptable to God through Jesus Christ’, 1 Pet. 2.5). In the words of the earlier redaction of the letter of Ignatius to the Ephesians (15.3), ‘Let us do all things as those who have Him dwelling in us, that we may be His temples, and He may be in us as our God, which indeed He is, and will manifest Himself before our faces’. And as Clement of Alexandria would later put it, ‘This is in reality righteousness: not to desire other things, but to wholly be the consecrated temple of the Lord.’194 Indeed, the Eucharist meal would have brought God into oneself by actually consuming (symbolically) the body of his appointed Lord, in whom God’s spirit resided (just compare 1 Cor. 11.23-27 with 10.16-22).
Because God now dwelled in each person, then he did not dwell only in the holy of holies as mainstream Judaism held. And if all one’s sins were thereby cleansed, there was no need of further rituals or sacrifices. There was therefore no need of priests or the temple. Replacing not just Yom Kippur but also Passover, the two great temple sacrificial rituals, was essential to accomplish that end (see Element 43), and had the obvious connotation of not just procuring forgiveness of sins (the role of Yom Kippur) but procuring salvation from death (the role of Passover). Which two facts completed the Christian system of salvation.
7. Elements of Christian Development
Element 19: The apostle Paul is the earliest known Christian writer, yet he did not know a living Jesus but was converted by revelation some time after Jesus is said to have died, and did not begin writing anything we know of until many years after his conversion (Galatians, e.g., was written about seventeen years after: 1.18; 2.1).
Element 20: (a) The earliest known Christians proselytized Gentiles but required them to convert to Judaism. (b) Paul is the first known Christian to discard that requirement (having received a special revelation instructing him to), and he had to fight the earliest known leaders of the cult for acceptance of that radical idea. (c) But some books in the NT are from the sect that did not adopt this innovation but remained thoroughly Jewish (most obviously Matthew, the letters of John and James, and Revelation).
Most scholars concede this. The primary evidence is Galatians 1–2, and supporting that is the fact that in his extended defense of this novelty in Romans, Paul is unable to cite the authority of a historical Jesus even once (see, e.g., Rom. 14.14).195 This entails that if Jesus lived, then he never taught anything other than a Jewish religion for Jews, and countenanced admitting only those Gentiles who first became Jews through circumcision and adherence to Torah law (such as Jewish dietary requirements and Sabbath observance, although possibly all rituals pertaining to the temple had been replaced by the cult paid to Christ: e.g. see 1 Jn 2.3-4 vs. 5.16), as such a procedure for converting Gentiles was already in accordance with Torah law (Exod. 12.48).
Element 21: (a) Paul and other NT authors attest that there were many rival Christian sects and factions teaching different gospels throughout the first century. In fact, evidence of such divisions and disagreements date as far back as extant records go. Yet we know very little about these other versions of Christianity (and in some cases nothing at all). And (b) of these only a few amalgamated sects survived the process of competition to remain in the Middle Ages, and those sects controlled nearly all choices as to what texts to preserve into the present, and which texts to ignore or abandon; and for the former, they also had complete custody of those texts for over a thousand years of hand-copying and editing.196
Of course Paul mentions factions sometimes advocating one apostle’s teaching over another, and argues Christians should accommodate them all and not make divisions. Paul names himself, Apollos and Cephas [Peter] (1 Cor. 1.12; 3.4-22), although supposedly Paul and Apollos regarded themselves as teaching roughly the same thing (1 Cor. 4.6; 16.12), and Paul and Peter came to a somewhat uneasy détente, with Peter accepting Paul’s innovative Torah-free gospel and Paul accepting Peter’s continuing adherence to a Torah-observant gospel (Galatians 2). But Paul also frequently refers to gospels of Jesus Christ so alien to his own that they must be declared anathema and shunned (Gal. 1.6-10; 2 Cor. 11.4-15; Rom. 16.17-18) and many other NT texts likewise allude to various early Christian sects being condemned (but almost never described).197
We therefore cannot simply assume surviving texts report what was normative for the original or earliest sects of Christianity. There is a great deal we just don’t know, and we have to factor that ignorance into our reasoning, as many scholars have pointed out.198 The epistles written during the first generation of Christians (from the 30s to the 60s ce) reveal a highly fragmented church already from the earliest recorded time, rife with fabricated new gospels and teachings effectively beyond the control of any central authority. And if this much divergence had already occurred in Paul’s generation, the amount of divergence in later generations would have been even greater. There is no guarantee that all the beliefs originally touted by Paul, for example, would even be those to survive the ensuing competition among rival factions. We already know (per Element 20) that the teachings of the original apostles did not survive that competition (Jewish Christianity stagnated and died out, and we have almost no texts from it). And we know the teachings of even ‘orthodox’ Christianity in the second century deviated considerably from the simpler faith taught by Paul (for whom there was no trinity, e.g., nor was Jesus identical to God; and a great deal else besides). And yet the ‘orthodox’ Christianity of that century was no more likely to be closer to original Christianity than any of the countless other sects its adherents deemed ‘heretical’, and we can easily see how incredibly diverse and bizarre they were.199 (See my definitions in §3.)
Thus, if Christian sectarian divergence was already considerable in the early first century, and very considerable in the following century, we must assume it was somewhere in between in the late first century, which entails there must have been quite a lot of practically unknown divergence and development in that period, far more even than indicated in the letters of Paul for the generation preceding it.
Element 22: (a) We have no credible or explicit record of what happened within the Christian movement between 64 and 95 ce (or possibly even as late as 110 ce). And (b) unlike almost any other cult we might consider for comparison, we know the leadership of the Christian church had been catastrophically decimated by the beginning of that period.
Given that Acts is not a paragon of reliability (see Chapter 9) one might doubt whether we even have a reliable record of what went on before 64 (the ‘authentic’ letters of Paul [see Chapter 7, §3] would then be all we really had, and they all date generally to a single late decade, that of the 50s). Likewise, the evidence of ecclesial events for the whole three or four decades after 95 is not what one would characterize as robust, either. Indeed, the fact that 1 Clement was written in 95 is really a traditional date and not actually secured by any trustworthy evidence; in fact, I am fairly certain it was written in the 60s (see Chapter 7, §6, and Chapter 8, §5). But even if we set all that aside and look on what we have with as rosy a view as we can stomach, then we can still say that nothing we have says anything about what happened between 64 (the year of the Neronian persecutions as reported in Tacitus and Suetonius) and 95 (the year that 1 Clement was ‘traditionally’ written). This is effectively a dark age in the early church, a thirty-year black box in which we can’t reconstruct what happened. In fact we can barely reconstruct what happened in the ten years either side of that, which makes for fifty years (half a century) of largely untracked development within the movement. Back then, that was an average human lifetime.
Even texts that may have been written in that thirty-year zone (like perhaps some of the Gospels) do not discuss any developments or events in that period. The only record of events in the church that has any chance of being other than fictional comes centuries later (since wildly implausible hagiographies and legends in the interim are hardly credible: see, e.g., discussion in Chapter 8 of Papias and Hegesippus, §§7 and 8). And that is only the succession of bishops recorded in Eusebius, which is devoid of any historical information but the names and offices. Such succession lists are typically untrustworthy anyway, as gaps in succession lists (such as for philosophical schools) were always intolerable and thus would be filled by fabrication if necessary, and Eusebius exhibits a reliance on unreliable sources for his list (e.g. Hegesippus), which only confirms our suspicions.200
In contrast, in the sources we have before Eusebius tried to smooth things over, we see much less certainty about what happened. For example, the inconsistent lists of apostles scattered across the four Gospels demonstrates that ‘by the time the gospels were composed, which disciples belonged to the twelve was no longer known’, and thus fundamental facts about the cult’s own history and leadership had been lost already in the course of the first century.201 This was surely the one detail that should have been easily and consistently remembered for generations, unless some major disruption in the cult’s traditions had occurred. Instead, already by the second half of the first century the leadership council of ‘the twelve’ (if such there was) no longer existed and left no identifiable heirs, and no one could even remember who all was on it, or even what had happened to them. Indeed, for most of them there are no historical accounts at all, beyond very late and obviously fabricated legends, and for the rest, the accounts we have (such as in Acts) either assume or establish their early deaths, or don’t seem aware of what happened to them at all (see Chapters 8 and 9).
By contrast, we have a lot of scattered information about the people, events and schisms within Christianity in the middle and later decades of the second century—but near total silence for the thirty to fifty years of the latter first to early second century. Acts presents us with a ‘history’ of the church movement from its origins in the 30s to around 60 or 62 ce (although still omitting a great deal; e.g. it says almost nothing about Egyptian or North African Christianity, or Christianity east of the Empire, or even Christianity in Italy and points west; it tells us little about the rival factions of Christianity, such as that of Apollos; etc.). But oddly nothing else like this was ever again produced for over two centuries—unless, of course, Acts is as bogus as the many apocryphal ‘Acts’ generated in the second century (see Element 44; and Chapter 7, §5), and if that’s the case, then we don’t really even have the history of the church to the year 62. Because apart from Acts we have only the letters of Paul, all produced during the end of that same period (the last authentic letter of Paul is unlikely to date much later than where Acts ends).
The only thing we next hear is that the Neronian persecution wiped out Christianity at Rome, possibly after Rome burned in 64 ce.202 Although no Christian ever recorded any information about this event; it is known (even to medieval Christian writers) only through Tacitus, which suggests either the story is a fiction or that the event produced a rather complete destruction of all Christian witnesses at Rome.203 And then the Jewish War between 66 and 70 ce wiped out Christianity at Jerusalem, home of the original church (Gal. 1.18; 2.1).204 Again, no Christian record of what happened to any Christians or their churches in Judea during this event was ever made (at least none known to us), suggesting again a rather thorough eradication. A decade or two before that (most likely around 47 ce), a famine had also ravaged the Middle East, the main proving grounds of Christian evangelism at the time, which would also have considerably reduced the normal life expectancy of the church membership, especially its leaders, insofar as leadership always tended to be elderly.205 Though it’s possible some of the leadership escaped all these events, we actually have no evidence any did. From 60 to 95 all (authentic) letter writing within the church ceases for the whole thirty years (a chilling sign), and no one writing after that period (Clement of Rome? See Chapter 8, §5) indicates that anyone survived those events. Certainly neither Peter nor Paul nor any other apostle from their time is known to have survived beyond the year 70.
There are some claims to be found that the disciple John survived into the second century, but Eusebius reveals this to be mistaken, as that John was often being confused with a different and later John.206 The odds are already hundreds or even thousands to one against anyone having lived from the early 30s ce into the reign of Trajan (c. 100 ce), as was being claimed of John (and that only in unreliable sources many generations later). In fact, life expectancy in the ancient world was already short, even in times of plenty, much less when a massive war, persecution and famine are added to further cull numbers.207
Even in the best of times, no more than one in three people made it to 55 or above. Yet if anyone started in the apostolate at, for example, age 15 in the year 30, they would be 55 in the year 70. And it is far more likely the first apostles were in their 20s or 30s, not teenagers, which would make them around 65 or 75 in the year 70. Teenagers would have incredible difficulty earning the respect or deference of those in their 20s or 30s, much less of elder folk, and therefore would be ineffective as evangelists. So it is very unlikely the first apostles were of teen age. Indeed, such a thing would be so remarkable it could not have failed to have been remarked upon in the sources we have. Yet only one in five teenagers would reach age 65, and barely one in twenty would make it to age 75—and that’s without wars, famines and persecutions reducing their survival rate. Factor those in, and we can expect none of the original ‘twelve’ (if 1 Cor. 15.5 is to be trusted) will have made it much beyond the year 75 (to which age the chances of a 25 year-old surviving are one in eight in normal conditions). Combine these prior expectations with the lack of any reliable evidence of anyone so surviving, and the silence of evidence against it (such as the complete absence of letters or writings from, to, or about these or any other leaders composed in that period), and we must conclude that in all probability all the original leaders were by then dead.
The significance of all this is that in that period (from 64 to 95 ce) we have no clear idea who was in charge or which churches they controlled or what schisms developed or what disputes arose or how they were resolved, or even whether they were resolved. We cannot know if the secret oral knowledge known to Paul and reserved for ‘mature’ members of the church was accurately or devotedly passed on—or if it was, to whom, or in what ways it was altered. And we cannot identify anyone who was in a position to prevent the development of novel interpretations and beliefs—even when Peter and Paul were still alive, the Epistles reveal their inability to prevent such schismatic developments (Element 21), so control of dogma must have been even less efficacious when no clear authority remained. And with no clear authority in control for thirty years—an entire generation—there is no limit to what can happen to an institution and its teachings, especially one built (at least in substantial part) on myths and secrets, two things that are the easiest to change (hence see Chapter 6, §7).
1. Luke converts this glorious appearance tale into a hidden god narrative (a reversal that befits how Christianity was also inverting the message of Romulus: promising, at least in the meantime, a hidden spiritual kingdom rather than a visible earthly one: 2 Cor. 4.18; Rom. 14.17), but otherwise the details are essentially the same (in fact, the similarities are even more numerous than proposed here, as I’ll show in Chapter 10, §6; and in Element 47). See also Richard Carrier, ‘The Spiritual Body of Christ and the Legend of the Empty Tomb’, in Empty Tomb (ed. Price and Lowder), pp. 105-232 (180-84, 191).
2. Mark also happens to be one of the recited names of those who fled the vanishing of Romulus—as is a cognate of Luke (‘they shout out many local names, like Marcus, Lucius, and Gaius’, Plutarch, Romulus 29.2). These were very common names, however; and Lukas was a contraction of Lucanus, not Lucius (though the names are related). So the fact that Mark and Luke are the two Gospels that most conspicuously emulate the story of Romulus is perhaps just a coincidence.
3. This tale is widely attested as pre-Christian: in Romulus 27-28, Plutarch, though writing c. 80–120 ce, is certainly recording a long-established Roman tale and custom, and his sources are unmistakably pre-Christian: Cicero, Laws 1.3, Republic 2.10; Livy, From the Founding of the City 1.16.2-8 (1.3–1.16 relating the whole story of Romulus); Ovid, Fasti 2.491-512 and Metamorphoses 14.805-51; and Dionysius of Halicarnassus, Roman Antiquities 2.63.3 (1.71–2.65 relating the whole story of Romulus); see also a later reference: Cassius Dio, Roman History 56.46.2. The story’s antiquity was acknowledged even by Christians: Tertullian, Apology 21.
4. Most certainly Osiris, Zalmoxis, Dionysus, Inanna, and others: see Carrier, Not the Impossible Faith, pp. 17-19, 85-113 (more will be said on this point here and in following chapters: Elements 14, 31, and 46-48).
5. We also have to take into account how much we don’t know about antiquity (because assuming we know everything is itself a fallacy that undermines many theories and estimates); see Carrier, Proving History, pp. 129-34, and Carrier, ‘Spiritual Body’, in Empty Tomb (ed. Price and Lowder), pp. 180-82.
6. For more on the terminology of celestial beings see Elements 11, 36 and 37.
7. Matthew Novenson, Christ among the Messiahs: Christ Language in Paul and Messiah Language in Ancient Judaism (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2012).
8. This and what follows have already been thoroughly demonstrated in Gunnar Samuelsson, Crucifixion in Antiquity: An Inquiry into the Background of the New Testament Terminology of Crucifixion (Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2011).
9. See Richard Carrier, ‘The Burial of Jesus in Light of Jewish Law’, in Empty Tomb (ed. Price and Lowder), pp. 369-92 (esp. pp. 375-79); with D.J. Halperin, ‘Crucifixion, the Nahum Pesher and the Rabbinic Penalty of Crucifixion’, Journal of Jewish Studies 32 (1981), pp. 32-46; and J.A. Fitzmyer, ‘Crucifixion in Ancient Palestine, Qumran Literature, and the New Testament’, Catholic Biblical Quarterly 40 (1978), pp. 493-513.
10. Carrier, ‘Spiritual Body’, in Empty Tomb (ed. Price and Lowder), esp. pp. 107-13, 126, 137-38.
11. Carrier, Not the Impossible Faith, pp. 85-127.
12. For my editorial on this subject see Richard Carrier, ‘B.C.A.D.C.E.B.C.E’, Richard Carrier Blogs (January 16, 2012), at http://freethoughtblogs.com/carrier/archives/166.
13. In every case, the argument I develop for each element could be reproduced in formal Bayesian terms, but to keep things simple I present them in colloquial terms. As background knowledge, the procedure for each would be to assign a neutral prior probability (which for each simple binary true/false statement is 0.5) and then ask how probable the total body of human knowledge is on h (that the claim is true) and how probable it is on ¬h (that the claim is false), especially the evidence specifically enumerated here (the evidence most directly determinative of h or ¬h), and then stating the posterior probability that results, which in some cases is ‘maybe’ (meaning: more than merely possible, but still not certain) and in others is ‘certainly’ (meaning: not absolutely certain, but certain to a very high probability), or some degree in between. I have carefully worded my claims in each element to reflect this.
14. For a summary of the evidence and sources collectively establishing this element see Carrier, ‘Spiritual Body’, in Empty Tomb (ed. Price and Lowder), pp. 107-13, with support in James Charlesworth and Petr Pokorný (eds.), Jesus Research: An International Perspective (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans, 2009), pp. 58-59. Indeed, there, primarily only Palestinian sects are considered; when considering Judaism of the Diaspora, Jewish sects and views diverge even more: see Erich Gruen, Diaspora: Jews amidst Greeks and Romans (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2002); and Erich Gruen, Heritage and Hellenism: The Reinvention of Jewish Tradition (Berkeley, CA: University of California Press, 1998); J. Andrew Overman and Robert MacLennan (eds.), Diaspora Jews and Judaism (Atlanta, GA: Scholars Press, 1992); with Margaret Williams, The Jews among the Greeks and Romans: A Diasporan Sourcebook (Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1998). But even in Palestine, diversity and Hellenization was a common reality: see Morton Smith, ‘Palestinian Judaism in the First Century’, in Israel: Its Role in Civilization (ed. Moshe Davis; New York: Seminary Israel Institute of the Jewish Theological Seminary of America, 1956), pp. 67-81; Alan Segal, ‘Jesus and First-Century Judaism’, in Jesus at 2000 (ed. Marcus Borg; Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 1997), pp. 55-72; and James Charlesworth et al. (eds.), Qumran-Messianism: Studies on the Messianic Expectations in the Dead Sea Scrolls (Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 1998), pp. 25-27.
15. Stanley Porter (ed.), The Messiah in the Old and New Testaments (Grand Rapids, MI: William B. Eerdmans, 2007); Markus Bockmuehl and James Carleton Paget (eds.), Redemption and Resistance: The Messianic Hopes of Jews and Christians in Antiquity (New York: T. & T. Clark, 2007); Magnus Zetterholm (ed.), The Messiah in Early Judaism and Christianity (Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2007); Charlesworth et al. (eds.), Qumran-Messianism; Craig Evans and Peter Flint (eds.), Eschatology, Messianism, and the Dead Sea Scrolls (Grand Rapids, MI: William B. Eerdmans, 1997); James Charlesworth (ed.), The Messiah: Developments in Earliest Judaism and Christianity (Minneapolis, MN: Fortress Press, 1992); Jacob Neusner, Messiah in Context: Israel’s History and Destiny in Formative Judaism (Philadelphia, PA: Fortress Press, 1984); and Jacob Neusner et al. (eds.), Judaisms and their Messiahs at the Turn of the Christian Era (New York: Cambridge University Press, 1987). See also C.A. Evans, ‘Messianism’, in Dictionary of New Testament Background (ed. Craig Evans and Stanley Porter; Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press, 2000), pp. 698-707.
16. On this being the case see Richard Carrier, ‘Christianity’s Success Was Not Incredible’, in The End of Christianity (ed. John Loftus; Amherst, NY: Prometheus Books, 2011), pp. 53-74, 372-75, along with Carrier, Not the Impossible Faith.
17. See M. Black, ‘The Messianism of the Parables of Enoch: Their Date and Contribution to Christological Origins’, in The Messiah (ed. Charlesworth), pp. 145-68; J.C. VanderKam, ‘Righteous One, Messiah, Chosen One, and Son of Man in 1 Enoch 37–71’, in The Messiah (ed. Charlesworth), pp. 169-91; and in Neusner et al., Judaisms and their Messiahs. In the NT Jesus is of course ‘the Messiah’ (Christ), but is also called ‘the Chosen One’ (Mt. 12.18; Lk. 9.35; 23.35), ‘the Righteous One’ (Lk. 23.47; Acts 3.14; 7.52; 22.14; 1 Jn 2.1; Rev. 16.5) and ‘The Son of Man’ (countless instances, e.g., Mt. 12.30; Mk 14.41; Lk. 22.48; Acts 7.56; Jn 1.51; etc.), among a great many other epithets, both familiar and strange.
18. See John Collins, ‘The Expectation of the End in the Dead Sea Scrolls’, in Eschatology (ed. Evans and Flint), pp. 74-90 (esp. 76-79, 83).
19. See Lawrence Schiffman and James VanderKam (eds.), Encyclopedia of the Dead Sea Scrolls (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000), I, pp. 166-70.
20. Philo, On Rewards and Punishments 79-172 (esp. § 95).
21. See Mk 9.9-13; 8.27-28; 6.14-16; Mt. 17.10-13; 16.13-14; Lk. 9.18-19; 9.7-9.
22. See D. Mendels, ‘Pseudo-Philo’s Biblical Antiquities, the ‘Fourth Philosophy’, and the Political Messianism of the First Century ce’, in The Messiah (ed. Charlesworth), pp. 261-75 (quote from Rhoads: p. 261 n. 4); which is thoroughly supported by Craig Evans, ‘Josephus on John the Baptist and Other Jewish Prophets of Deliverance’, in The Historical Jesus in Context (ed. Amy-Jill Levine, Dale Allison, Jr and John Dominic Crossan; Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2006), pp. 55-63, which contains all the relevant references in Josephus.
23. Which may have been a key to Christianity’s success: by avoiding mass territorial action (and focusing instead on spiritual combat), they avoided armed conflict and thus survived, by gaining more converts over a wider area than were lost to sporadic persecutions. See Carrier, Not the Impossible Faith, pp. 219-45, with pp. 147-60, 259-96. This may even have been a lesson learned from observing the fate of other movements. But natural selection alone would determine it: agitative cults would be wiped out, leaving more pacifist cults to dominate the market (then it became simply a competition among products for sale). A non-existent messiah (whose lordship and victory were known only spiritually and thus never a worldly militaristic threat) would thus have an enormous competitive advantage at these earliest stages (see Elements 23-28).
24. Evans, ‘Josephus on John the Baptist’, whose analysis is corroborated by Rebecca Gray, Prophetic Figures in Late Second Temple Jewish Palestine: The Evidence from Josephus (New York: Oxford University Press, 1993). See Exod. 17.1-7; Num. 20.1-13; and Ps. 95.7b-11, a passage that Evans notes is cited and commented on in the NT as well (in Heb. 3.7–4.13). The temptation narrative in the Gospels bears the same connection (see Chapter 10, §4).
25. We should at least consider the possibility that all these stories are fiction (the fact that all emulate Joshua but each, conveniently, in a different way could suggest literary or parabolic fabrication), but if so, this story-cluster can have only two origins: the Jewish public (i.e., oral lore picked up by Josephus) or Josephus himself (or some other Jewish author he is using as a source, most likely in this case Justus of Tiberias, or some lost Jewish apocryphon). In the one case we still have confirmation of the same messianic fad (in this case creating popular tales and rumors of messiahs), and in the other case we have an improbability (that a single Jewish author invented a messianic fever with remarkable coincidence precisely when the messianic cult of Christianity arose and messianic cults were composing the texts stashed at Qumran, yet this same author doesn’t position Christianity among them or mention the cults of Qumran, and is even too coy to identify the fad he thus invented as messianic). The most probable fabrication hypothesis is that Josephus (or Justus of Tiberias?) took actual rebel movements and mapped onto them this ‘new Joshua’ motif himself, yet that would mean the idea of inventing miracle-working, popular-movement-style ‘Jesus Christs’ readily occurred to him. The improbability of this coinciding (in time and concept) with an ‘actual’ Jesus Christ (which the author completely fails to connect with them by the same motifs) would then argue in favor of our Jesus Christ being as fabricated as these. But note also how most of them also die at the hands of the Romans. If they were historical, then these figures might have even been trying to get themselves killed, so as to fulfill the prophecy of Dan. 9.26 and thereby usher in the end of the world as promised in Daniel 12. God had promised that the Jews would rule the universe (Zech. 14), but their sins kept forestalling his promise (Jer. 29; Dan. 9), which would also create a motive for would-be messiahs to perform atonement acts, which could include substitutionary self-sacrifice (see Element 43), out of increasing desperation (Elements 23-26). Christianity almost becomes predictable in this context.
26. See Stephen Haar, Simon Magus: The First Gnostic? (New York: Walter de Gruyter, 2003), pp. 11-15; challenging this Simon’s historicity is Gerd Lüdemann, Untersuchungen zur simonianischen Gnosis (Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 1975).
27. R.A. Horsley, ‘“Messianic” Figures and Movements in First-Century Palestine’, in The Messiah (ed. Charlesworth), pp. 276-95 (282). Horsley still insists these are not messianic movements, but that assertion depends on an implausibly specific definition of ‘messiah’ (or an excessively irrational denial of obvious inferences): see my discussion of definitions (§3). Similarly in Sean Freyne, ‘The Herodian Period’, in Redemption and Resistance (ed. Bockmuehl and Paget), pp. 29-43: like Horsley, Freyne is only skeptical in respect to an over-restrictive definition of ‘messiah’; whereas given my definition, his evidence completely confirms my conclusion. The same can be said of Martin Goodman, ‘Messianism and Politics in the Land of Israel, 66-135 c.e.’, in Redemption and Resistance (ed. Bockmuehl and Paget), pp. 149-57.
28. If Jesus did exist, his followers may have repackaged the dead Jesus into a spiritual one consciously or not—that is, by merely claiming to have been visited by his risen spirit or by their subconscious minds constructing that experience for them (see Element 15).
29. Richard Carrier, ‘Did Any Pre-Christian Jews Expect a Dying-and-Rising Messiah?’ [in review]; see also Carrier, Not the Impossible Faith, pp. 34-49 (with a correction: p. 34 arguably misreads Isa. 49.7 [cf. p. 49 n. 30]; as had already been suggested on p. 37). Essentially the same conclusion is argued by rabbinical scholar Daniel Boyarin, The Jewish Gospels: The Story of the Jewish Christ (New York: New Press, 2012), pp. 129-56.
30. b. Sanhedrin 98b and 93b.
31. b. Sukkah 52a-b.
32. We might have evidence of a strand of that prior tradition in the early-first-century Targum of Jonathan ben Uzziel on Isaiah 53 (a kind of paraphrastic commentary in Aramaic; Jonathan ben Uzziel was traditionally a student of Hillel, who died c. 10 ce, and a contemporary of Shammai, who died c. 30 ce), which explicitly identifies the suffering servant there as the Christ—but otherwise transforms the narrative to suppress or downplay the element of his dying. But anyone who read this Targum, and then the original Hebrew (or Greek), could put two and two together: ‘this servant is the messiah’ plus ‘this servant dies and is buried and then exalted’ = ‘the messiah dies and is buried and then exalted’, the very doctrine we see in the Talmud, which just happens to be the same doctrine adopted by Christians. This Targum was multiply tampered with over the years, however (see Bruce Chilton, The Glory of Israel: The Theology and Provenience of the Isaiah Targum [Sheffield: JSOT Press, 1982], e.g., p. 94), so nothing conclusive can be decided by it (even though, again, it is unlikely Jews would change the Targum to make Isaiah 53 messianic after Christianity started using Isaiah 53 to support their cause), although Jintae Kim makes a case for the reading being early in ‘Targum Isaiah 53 and the New Testament Concept of Atonement’, Journal of Greco-Roman Christianity and Judaism 5 (2008), pp. 81-98.
33. See translation in John Reeves, Trajectories in Near Eastern Apocalyptic: A Postrabbinic Jewish Apocalypse Reader (Atlanta, GA: Society of Biblical Literature, 2005), pp. 40-66, where the Messiah ben Joseph appears (p. 57), is killed (pp. 59-60), then resurrected (pp. 60-61) by the Messiah ben David, after which the apocalypse follows. The narrative in this text was adapted to contemporary political circumstances of the later Middle Ages, but it is clear from the Talmud that the outline of it long predated that period, and thus long predates this redaction of it.
34. The Dead Sea Scrolls also speak of two messiahs, one ‘Messiah of Aaron’, who would be the ‘true high priest’, and a ‘Messiah of Israel’, who would be a kingly warlord figure. See Evans and Flint (eds.), Eschatology, pp. 5-6; and Peter Flint, ‘Jesus and the Dead Sea Scrolls’, in Historical Jesus in Context (ed. Levine, Allison and Crossan), pp. 110-31; and Florentino García Martínez and Eibert J.C. Tigchelaar (eds.), Qumranica minora, Vol. II (Boston: Brill, 2007), pp. 13-32. But it’s debated whether these are actually two messiahs, or what kind of messiahs they are: see L.D. Hurst, ‘Did Qumran Expect Two Messiahs?’, Bulletin for Biblical Research 9 (1999), pp. 157-80 (although note that his conclusion is reversed when we adopt my definition of messiah rather than his). It’s also debated whether one of the Qumran fragments says one of these messiahs ‘will be pierced’ and killed, or whether he will pierce and kill someone else, and I consider that question presently unresolvable (the manuscript is too damaged to tell). See Helmut Koester, ‘The Historical Jesus and the Historical Situation of the Quest: An Epilogue’, in Studying the Historical Jesus: Evaluation of the State of Current Research (ed. Bruce Chilton and Craig Evans; Leiden: Brill, 1994), pp. 535-45; and Craig Evans, ‘The Recently Published Dead Sea Scrolls and the Historical Jesus’, in Studying the Historical Jesus (ed. Chilton and Evans), pp. 547-65 (553-54); and the debate between Hershel Shanks, ‘The “Pierced Messiah” Text—An Interpretation Evaporates’, Biblical Archaeology Review 18 (July/August 1992), pp. 80-82; and James Tabor, ‘4Q285: A Pierced or Piercing Messiah?—The Verdict Is Still Out’, Biblical Archaeology Review 18 (November/December 1992), pp. 58-59; as well as the discussion and scholarship cited in Martin Abegg, ‘Messianic Hope and 4Q285: A Reassessment’, Journal of Biblical Literature 113 (Spring 1994), pp. 81-91.
35. Jarvis Williams, Maccabean Martyr Traditions in Paul’s Theology of Atonement: Did Martyr Theology Shape Paul’s Conception of Jesus’s Death? (Eugene, OR: Wipf & Stock, 2010), pp. 53-63, 72-84.
36. 11Q13 = 11QMelch ii.18-20. For the scroll’s text, translation and notes, see Alex Jassen, Mediating the Divine: Prophecy and Revelation in the Dead Sea Scrolls and Second Temple Judaism (Leiden: Brill, 2007), pp. 90-95; John Sietze Bergsma, The Jubilee from Leviticus to Qumran: A History of Interpretation (Leiden: Brill, 2007), pp. 277-91, with Géza Vermès, The Complete Dead Sea Scrolls in English (New York: Penguin Press, 7th edn, 2011), pp. 532-33; and Christian Metzenthin, Jesaja-Auslegung in Qumran (Zurich: TVZ, 2010), pp. 314-23; see also Abegg, ‘Messianic Hope and 4Q285’, pp. 89-90; and Lara Guglielmo, ‘11Q13, Malchî Sedek, Co-Reference, and Restoration of 2 18’, Henoch 33 (2011), pp. 61-72, with a somewhat weak rebuttal by Darrell Bock, ‘Is That All There Is? A Response to Lara Guglielmo’s 11Q13, Malchî Sedek, Co-Reference, and Restoration of 2 18’, Henoch 33 (2011), pp. 73-76.
37. In Carrier, ‘Did Any Pre-Christian Jews Expect a Dying-and-Rising Messiah?’
38. For this and the following points see the discussion of the pre-Christian interpretation of Isaiah 53 in Martin Hengel, ‘The Effective History of Isaiah 53 in the Pre-Christian Period’, in The Suffering Servant: Isaiah 53 in Jewish and Christian Sources (ed. Bernd Janowski and Peter Stuhlmacher; Grand Rapids, MI: William B. Eerdmans, 2004), pp. 75-146; see pp. 103-105 on the divergent text of 1QIsaa, where the suffering servant figure of Isaiah 52–53 is ‘pierced’ rather than ‘bruised’ in Isa. 53.10 and correspondingly in Isa. 53.5 he is ‘pierced through for our transgressions’ rather than merely ‘wounded’ for them; likewise in that same scroll, Isa. 52.14 has God declare of him that he shall have ‘anointed his appearance beyond that of any man, and his form beyond that of the sons of man’, which Hengel considers allusive to the anointing of high priests in Lev. 21.10 and 16.32, which would make this figure a messiah in the broadest sense—therefore anyone who saw this figure’s atoning death as eschatological would also regard him as a messiah in the narrower sense that I have defined (in §3).
39. As explained in Daniel 12; Michael is not there called a messiah, but plays the role of what many Jews expected of the final messiah. Both Michael and Melchizedek were regarded as God’s celestial high priest in Jewish writings generally, thus they would have commonly been equated: Joseph Fitzmyer, ‘Further Light on Melchizedek from Qumran Cave 11’, in Essays on the Semitic Background of the New Testament (London: Geoffrey Chapman, 1971), pp. 245-67 (254-55). This would further link these figures to the pre-Christian Jewish theology of God’s Logos and celestial firstborn son, also named Jesus (Element 40).
40. On the facts and logic of this point, and other scholars making it, see Carrier, Proving History, pp. 129-34 (with pp. 117-19).
41. See discussion of this example in Carrier, Proving History, pp. 273-75.
42. That this eliminates the strength of any argument from silence, see previous note.
43. God’s house is, of course, God’s temple, which is what Christians sometimes called their church (each member was God’s temple, but also collectively they were each a part of a single body and thus collectively God’s temple): 1 Cor. 3.16-17; 6.16-20; 10.17; 12.12-27; 2 Cor. 6.16; Rom. 12.4-5. See Element 18.
44. That Zechariah 3 was a seminal scripture in the founding of Christianity has been argued before: see Daniel Stökl ben Ezra, The Impact of Yom Kippur on Early Christianity: The Day of Atonement from Second Temple Judaism to the Fifth Century (Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2003), pp. 194-97.
45. See Carrier, ‘Spiritual Body’, in Empty Tomb (ed. Price and Lowder), pp. 114-15, 132-47, 157, 212 (n. 166). The heavenly ascent narrative known to Ignatius, Irenaeus and Justin Martyr (see Chapter 8, §6) may have alluded to this passage in Zechariah, if this is what is intended by mentioning the lowly state of Jesus’ attire when he enters God’s heavenly court in Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 36.
46. On the numerous copies of Daniel among the Dead Sea Scrolls, including fragments of commentaries on it, see Peter Flint, ‘The Daniel Tradition at Qumran’, in Eschatology (ed. Evans and Flint), pp. 41-60, and F.F. Bruce, ‘The Book of Daniel and the Qumran Community’, in Neotestamentica et semitica: Studies in Honour of Matthew Black (ed. E. Earle Ellis and Max Wilcox; Edinburgh: T. & T. Clark, 1969), pp. 221-35.
47. Julius Africanus, in his lost History of the World, which excerpt survives in the collection of George Syncellus, Excerpts of Chronography 18.2. Other examples of this kind of calculation survive in Tertullian, Answer to the Jews 8, and Clement of Alexandria, Miscellanies 1.21.(125-26).
48. Josephus, Jewish War 6.312-16; verified in Suetonius, Life of Vespasian 4.5, and Tacitus, Histories 5.13.2. Josephus’s discussion does not here identify Daniel by title but he does elsewhere (in Josephus, Jewish Antiquities 10.276), and here he clearly intends no other text given his description (of two rulers who would come, and the presence of an actual timetable, two features not found together in any other passage of the Bible). Josephus himself correctly interprets the Danielic prophecy to have been regarding the Maccabees (Josephus, Jewish Antiquities 12.321-22), yet also acknowledges (in 10.276) that it was about the Roman sack of Jerusalem, imagining the prophecy as having been twice fulfilled.
49. And this cycle of predicting the end, followed by failure, then revising of the prediction, has continued ever since. See John Loftus, ‘At Best Jesus Was a Failed Apocalyptic Prophet’, in Christian Delusion (ed. Loftus), pp. 316-43. That Christians taught that Jesus had predicted the imminent end is undeniable: Heb. 1.10–2.5; 10.36-37; 1 Cor. 1.28; 6.13; 7.29-31; 1 Thess. 4.15; 2 Pet. 3.5-13; 1 Jn 2.15-18; and of course Mark 13 and Matthew 24. On the continuing cycle of failure after that, see Bernard McGinn et al., The Continuum History of Apocalypticism (New York: Continuum, 2003); and Jonathan Kirsch, A History of the End of the World (San Francisco, CA: Harper, 2006).
50. A good discussion of all of this is provided for Daniel 9 in André Lacocque, The Book of Daniel (Atlanta, GA: John Knox Press, 1979); but any professional commentary on Daniel 9 will make the same point, for example John Collins, Daniel: A Commentary (Minneapolis, MN: Fortress Press, 1993).
51. On the genre of the pesherim and how they constructed hidden meanings from past scriptures, see Shani Tzoref, ‘Qumran Pesharim and the Pentateuch: Explicit Citation, Overt Typologies, and Implicit Interpretive Traditions’, Dead Sea Discoveries 16 (2009), pp. 190-220 (with scholarship cited therein); and Bruce Chilton, ‘Commenting on the Old Testament (with Particular Reference to the Pesharim, Philo and the Mekilta’, in It Is Written—Scripture Citing Scripture: Essays in Honour of Barnabas Lindars, SSF (ed. Barnabas Lindars, D.A. Carson and H.G.M. Williamson; New York: Cambridge University Press, 1988), pp. 122-40. The practice is praised in Philo, On the Contemplative Life 3.28-29.
52. In addition to the evidence already surveyed (such as for the use of Daniel), see also Alison Salvesen, ‘Messianism in Ancient Bible Translations in Greek and Latin’, in Redemption and Resistance (ed. Bockmuehl and Paget), pp. 245-61; Joachim Schaper, Eschatology in the Greek Psalter (Tübingen: J.C.B. Mohr [Paul Siebeck], 1995), esp. pp. 93-94, 101-107; and the other works cited in previous notes on ancient messianism. For Christian examples, see Craig Evans and James Sanders (eds.), Early Christian Interpretation of the Scriptures of Israel: Investigations and Proposals (Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press, 1997); G.K. Beale and D.A. Carson (eds.), Commentary on the New Testament Use of the Old Testament (Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Academic, 2007); the latter also discusses other Jewish interpretations of the same messianic passages (thus confirming Christianity’s creative use of the Bible to this end was part of a wider trend and not itself novel).
53. For example, 4Q385-391 contain lost writings of Ezekiel and Jeremiah; fragments of lost writings of Daniel are discussed in Bruce, ‘Book of Daniel and the Qumran Community’, pp. 223-25.
54. See discussion in Joseph L. Trafton, ‘The Psalms of Solomon’, in Historical Jesus in Context (ed. Levine, Allison and Crossan), pp. 256-65.
55. See Chapter 8 (§5). There may have been many texts like that: see, e.g., Matthias Henze (ed.), Hazon Gabriel: New Readings of the Gabriel Revelation (Atlanta, GA: Society of Biblical Literature, 2011).
56. Irenaeus, Demonstration of the Apostolic Preaching 78.
57. Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 71-73.
58. Origen, Letter to Africanus 2-9.
59. See Tim Callahan, Bible Prophecy: Failure or Fulfillment? (Altadena, CA: Millennium Press, 1997), pp. 115-16; and Raymond Brown, The Birth of the Messiah: A Commentary on the Infancy Narratives in the Gospels of Matthew and Luke (Garden City, NY: Doubleday, 1993), §5 B3.
60. Irenaeus, Demonstration of the Apostolic Preaching 79.
61. Epistle of Barnabas 5. This is in the Codex Sinaiticus, one of the oldest Bibles in the world (transcribed in the early fourth century ce), and the epistle itself was probably written in the early second century ce and thus half a century at least before the time of Irenaeus (see note in Chapter 8, §6).
62. Again, the Qumran version of Isaiah (1QIsaa) says ‘he was wounded for our transgressions, he was pierced for our iniquities . . . it pleased Jehovah to pierce him . . . to make his life an offering for sin’ (which in effect means the same thing in English as ‘he was nailed up for our iniquities . . . it pleased Jehovah to nail him him up’). For examples of other variant readings of otherwise-known scriptures found at Qumran, see John Collins and Craig Evans (eds.), Christian Beginnings and the Dead Sea Scrolls (Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Academic, 2006), p. 10.
63. On this and many other of the points made here see Magne Sæbø (ed.), Hebrew Bible, Old Testament: The History of its Interpretation. Volume I: From the Beginnings to the Middle Ages (until 1300). Part 1: Antiquity (Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 1996), esp. Oskar Skarsaune, ‘The Question of Old Testament Canon and Text in the Early Greek Church’, pp. 443-50, which documents many more examples.
64. This is all undeniably explicit in later texts such as Heb. 1.1-4 and Col. 1.12-20 (and elsewhere, e.g., Heb. 2.10, which echoes 1 Cor. 8.6), but I shall proceed to demonstrate these claims are already in the earliest letters of Paul and even pre-Pauline creeds. On the related ‘high Christology’ debate see Andrew Chester, ‘High Christology—Whence, When and Why?’, Early Christianity 2 (2011), pp. 22-50; his results corroborate mine, and are further supported by the evidence I adduce for Elements 36 and 40-42. See also Jonathan Knight, Disciples of the Beloved One: The Christology, Social Setting and Theological Context of the Ascension of Isaiah (Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press, 1996), pp. 135-39 and 296-303.
65. ‘The kingdom of the Father is already spread upon the earth and men do not see it’, Gos. Thom. 113, which is compatible with the Synoptic idea of a spiritual kingdom soon to be followed by a physical one (brought on clouds of glory) but still conspicuous for lacking any such notion here; the Gospel of John is full of similar sentiments (which likewise erases from the story all the mentions of a coming apocalypse, as are found throughout the Synoptic Gospels and the Epistles).
66. This is well enough argued in Bart Ehrman, Jesus: Apocalyptic Prophet of the New Millennium (New York: Oxford University Press, 1999). That the Gospel of Thomas is far more certainly a late text (of the early to mid-second century), see the thorough discussions of Nicholas Perrin, Thomas and Tatian: The Relationship between the Gospel of Thomas and the Diatessaron (Leiden: Brill, 2002); and Klyne R. Snodgrass, ‘The Gospel of Thomas: A Secondary Gospel’, in The Historical Jesus: Critical Concepts in Religious Studies, Vol. IV: Lives of Jesus and Jesus outside the Bible (ed. Craig Evans; New York: Routledge, 2004); and now Mark Goodacre, Thomas and the Gospels: The Case for Thomas’s Familiarity with the Synoptics (Grand Rapids, MI: William B. Eerdmans, 2012). I find attempts to argue the contrary too weak to rest any conclusion on; and they still cannot reliably date Gos. Thom. even if correct.
67. See Carrier, ‘Why the Resurrection Is Unbelievable’, in Christian Delusion (ed. Loftus), pp. 291-315 (306).
68. Some scholars challenge the converse claim, that Jesus was thought from the start to be a preexistent being of any sort. Chester, ‘High Christology’, demonstrates the implausibility of the claim that Christianity began without a notion of Jesus being a preexistent being. There is simply no evidence to support that conjecture, and all the evidence we do have indicates otherwise (e.g. 1 Cor. 8.6 and Phil. 2.5-11, which are corroborated by the implications of Rom. 8.3).
69. Rom. 1.7-8; 2.6; 5.1, 11; 6.11, 23; 7.25; 8.39; 10.9; 15.6, 30; 16.27, etc.; 1 Cor. 1.3-4; 6.11; 15.57, etc.; 2 Cor. 1.2-3; 11.31; 13.14, etc.; Gal. 1.1; 1.3, etc.; Phil. 1.2, 11; 3.3, 14; 4.19, etc.; 1 Thess. 1.1; 3.11-13; 4.14; 5.9, etc.; and so on. In contrast to all this evidence, Rom. 9.5 is often cited as saying Jesus was identical to God (it would then be the only passage in Paul that ever says this), but many early Christians punctuated the text differently, and accordingly modern translations disagree on the meaning, some holding that it was meant to distinguish a spontaneous praise of God with a statement about Jesus coming in the flesh. See A.W. Wainwright, ‘The Confession “Jesus is God” in the New Testament’, Scottish Journal of Theology 10 (1957), pp. 278-82; W.L. Lorimer, ‘Romans IX. 3-5’, New Testament Studies 13 (1967), pp. 385-86; and Bruce Metzger, ‘The Punctuation of Rom. 9:5’, in Christ and the Spirit in the New Testament (ed. B. Lindars and S. Smalley; Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1973), pp. 95-112. From the other passages in Paul it is clear he did not believe Jesus was ‘the’ God over all, so at most he can only have meant here ‘a’ god (a subordinate god, in the henotheistic sense: see Element 11; notably, in accord with this, the passage does not say Christ is necessarily ho theos, ‘the God’, but just theos, ‘[a] god’). But I think it’s far more likely (on the evidence of the whole Pauline corpus) that the text has become corrupted. In Rom. 1.25 Paul says something almost identical, that the Creator is ‘blessed forever. Amen’ (eulogētos eis tous aiōnas amēn, word-for-word identical to the conclusion of Rom. 9.5), and in 2 Cor. 11.31 Paul says God is the ‘father’ of Christ and therefore ‘the one who is blessed forever’ (ho ōn eulogētos eis tous aiōnas), which is very similar to the phrase in Rom. 9.5; likewise in 2 Cor. 1.3 Paul says God is ‘blessed’ because he is the father of Christ, not because he is the Christ. It is far more likely that Rom. 9.5 originally repeated this sentiment than that it said something radically new that outright contradicts it. I would thus expect that the phrase ho patēr originally appeared before the ho ōn in Rom. 9.5, which would create an apt parallel with the preceding ‘whose are the fathers’ in the same line, in which case Paul wrote ‘my brethren are the Israelites . . . whose are the fathers [i.e., the patriarchs] and out of whom is Christ in the flesh, whose father is the blessed God over all. Amen’. Indeed, Christ’s divine paternity is otherwise conspicuous for its absence in this sentence, which (in light of the other identical ‘blessing’ passages in Paul) strongly indicates that it was originally present here. For additional bibliographies on this problem see Douglas Moo, The Epistle to the Romans (Grand Rapids, MI: William B. Eerdmans, 1996), pp. 565-68, and Robert Jewett, Romans: A Commentary (Minneapolis, MN: Fortress Press, 2007), pp. 566-69 (although neither Moo nor Jewett consider the reconstruction of the text I just proposed, nor the evidence I advanced for it).
70. See my discussion in Carrier, Not the Impossible Faith, pp. 247-57; and Carrier, Proving History, pp. 145-49; and more extensively, Adela Yarbro Collins and John Collins (eds.), King and Messiah as Son of God: Divine, Human, and Angelic Messianic Figures in Biblical and Related Literature (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans, 2008); and Charles Gieschen, Angelomorphic Christology: Antecedents and Early Evidence (Boston: Brill, 1998). See also Craig Evans, ‘The Recently Published Dead Sea Scrolls and the Historical Jesus’, in Studying the Historical Jesus: Evaluations of the State of Current Research (ed. Bruce Chilton and Craig Evans; Leiden: Brill, 1994), pp. 563-65; and Margaret Barker, The Great High Priest: The Temple Roots of Christian Liturgy (New York: T. & T. Clark, 2003), pp. 60-62, 210-12. On pagan equivalents (from which one can see Jesus was assigned all the royal titles associated with Greco-Roman kings and emperors), see Erwin Goodenough, ‘The Political Philosophy of Hellenistic Kingship’, Yale Classical Studies 1 (1928), pp. 55-102.
71. See also Marvin Meyer (ed.), The Ancient Mysteries: A Sourcebook of Sacred Texts (Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1987), pp. 225-27 (with bibliography pro and con) and pp. 252-54; with Jaime Alvarez, Romanising Oriental Gods: Myth, Salvation and Ethics in the Cults of Cybele, Isis and Mithras (Leiden: Brill, 2008), pp. 396-97, 420-21, etc.
72. The oft-cited article to the contrary by Bruce Metzger, ‘Considerations of the Methodology in the Study of the Mystery Religions and Early Christianity’, Harvard Theological Review 48 (January 1955), pp. 1-20, is so profoundly inept in its analysis that it must be rejected. The argument ‘it was different from x, therefore it wasn’t influenced by x’ (which describes more than half the arguments Metzger deploys) is fallacious to the point of ridiculous: this, as well as nearly every other argument Metzger constructs, would rule out every mystery religion as being a mystery religion (e.g. the argument, on p. 11, that certain terms are not found in Paul’s letters: that is true of most mystery religions, by Metzger’s own admission, pp. 6-7), which of course is so absurd a conclusion as to refute his entire case. His remaining arguments (e.g. that Jews never syncretized their religion with surrounding religions) are simply false, or irrelevant to explaining the origins of Christianity (like the fact that Christianity underwent even more syncretism in later centuries). The same mistakes uniformly plague the analysis of Devon Wiens, ‘Mystery Concepts in Primitive Christianity and in its Environment’, Aufstieg und Niedergang der römischen Welt II.23.2 (New York: W. de Guyter, 1980), pp. 1248-84.
73. Collectively in the plural in 1 Cor. 4.1 and 13.2 (and 14.2); individually in the singular in Rom. 11.25-26; 16.25-26; 1 Cor. 2.7; 15.51 (and 1 Cor. 2.1 in some mss.; replaced with the more contextually inappropriate martyrion in others). Pseudo-Paulines use the same terminology: Eph. 1.9; 3.3-4, 9; 5.32; 6.19; Col. 1.26, 27; 2.2; 4.3; 2 Thess. 2.5-10 (cf., e.g., Rev. 17.5-7); 1 Tim. 3.9, 16.
74. See Rom. 16.25-26; 1 Cor. 2-3; 2 Cor. 5; Eph. 3.1-10; Col. 1.26-28; 2 Pet. 1.16; Mk 4.11-12; etc.
75. Harry Angus Alexander Kennedy, St. Paul and the Mystery-Religions (London: Hodder & Stoughton, 1913), p. 121 (on mystery religion vocabulary: pp. 115-98). Despite being out of date, Kennedy’s study remains correct in many respects, as verified and reinforced in Hugo Rahner, Greek Myths and Christian Mystery (New York: Harper & Row, 1963), and by the scholarship cited in coming notes. I should also note that Samuel Angus, The Mystery-Religions and Christianity: A Study in the Religious Background of Early Christianity (London: J. Murray, 1925) is also obsolete, but still contains a lot of useful data, and like Kennedy, some of his arguments have been confirmed and are now mainstream (though others have been refuted and are now regarded as quaint). By contrast, though often cited, Joscelyn Godwin, Mystery Religions in the Ancient World (New York: Harper & Row, 1981) is only to be used with caution, being occasionally under-sourced or overstating the facts. Far better references are to follow.
76. Alvarez, Romanising Oriental Gods, pp. 396-97.
77. Alvarez, Romanising Oriental Gods, pp. 420-21.
78. For Christianity: Heb. 2.10; 9.26; Phil. 3.10; 2 Cor. 1.5; Mk 8.31; etc. For other mystery cults see, e.g., Herodotus, Histories 2.171.1 (on the mysteries of Osiris); Plutarch, On Isis and Osiris (= Moralia) 17.357f, 20.358f (on Osiris and others); Euripides, Bacchae 492, 500, 786, 801, 1377 (on the Bacchic mysteries).
79. Kennedy, St. Paul and the Mystery-Religions, pp. 229-55 (baptism as a universal ritual in the mystery cults), pp. 256-79 (sacred meals). Recent scholarship confirms the basic picture. On the Bacchic and Eleusinian mysteries: Radcliffe Edmonds III, Myths of the Underworld Journey: Plato, Aristophanes, and the ‘Orphic’ Gold Tablets (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2004); Martin Nilsson, The Dionysiac Mysteries of the Hellenistic and Roman Age (Lund: Gleerup, 1957); M.L. West, The Orphic Poems (New York: Oxford University Press, 1983), pp. 1-38; for some practices and terminology: Richard Seaford, ‘Dionysiac Drama and the Dionysiac Mysteries’, The Classical Quarterly 31 (1981), pp. 252-75. On the Mithraic mysteries: Manfred Clauss, The Roman Cult of Mithras: The God and his Mysteries (New York: Routledge, 2000), cf. esp. pp. 14-15 (with 174 n. 30) and 108-13 on the features it shares with other mystery cults (including the ritual of symbolically emulating the god’s labors to achieve personal salvation in the hereafter, and the ritual of sharing a sacred meal with other initiates); see also Marvin Meyer, ‘The Mithras Liturgy’, in The Historical Jesus in Context (ed. Levine, Allison and Crossan), pp. 179-92; Gary Lease, ‘Mithraism and Christianity: Borrowings and Transformations’, Aufstieg und Niedergang der römischen Welt II.23.2 (New York: W. de Gruyter, 1980), pp. 1306-32 (1309 for the generic features Christianity shares with all mystery cults; the specific influence of Mithraism on early Christianity is unlikely, however—they instead arose around the same time, in a parallel phenomenon of creating mystery cults from major ethnic cults, Persian in the one case, Jewish in the other—they are therefore separate instances of the same phenomenon); Roger Beck, Beck on Mithraism (Burlington, VT: Ashgate, 2004); and Roger Beck, The Religion of the Mithras Cult in the Roman Empire: Mysteries of the Unconquered Sun (New York: Oxford University Press, 2006), the latter works correcting or superseding David Ulansey’s The Origins of the Mithraic Mysteries (New York: Oxford University Press, 1989); see also Richard Gordon, Image and Value in the Graeco-Roman World: Studies in Mithraism and Religious Art (Brookfield, VT: Ashgate, 1996). On Isis–Osiris cult: Malcolm Drew Donalson, The Cult of Isis in the Roman Empire: Isis Invicta (Lewiston, NY: E. Mellen Press, 2003); Sarolta Takacs, Isis and Sarapis in the Roman World (Leiden: Brill, 1995); Reinhold Merkelbach, Isis Regina, Zeus Sarapis: Die griechisch-ägyptische Religion nach den Quellen dargestellt (Stuttgart: B.G. Teubner, 1995); Sharon Kelly Heyob, The Cult of Isis among Women in the Graeco-Roman World (Leiden: Brill, 1975); and Robert Wild, Water in the Cultic Worship of Isis and Sarapis (Leiden: Brill, 1981). On the Samothracian mysteries: Susan Guettel Cole, Theoi Megaloi: The Cult of the Great Gods at Samothrace (Leiden: Brill, 1984), which surveys evidence of baptisms (31-33), passion plays (48), ritual meals (36-37) and a duo of resurrected gods (1-7). On the mysteries of Attis and Cybele: Lynn Roller, In Search of God the Mother: The Cult of Anatolian Cybele (Berkeley, CA: University of California Press, 1999); Giulia Sfameni Gasparro, Soteriology and Mystic Aspects in the Cult of Cybele and Attis (Leiden: Brill, 1985); and Maria Grazia Lancellotti, Attis, between Myth and History: King, Priest, and God (Leiden: Brill, 2002). Note that all of the above literature confirms moral teachings were linked to every mystery cult (a fact still often denied). The Thracian deity Zalmoxis was also anciently believed to have died and risen from the dead, procuring salvation for all who share in his cult (including a ritual eating and drinking), as attested by Herodotus in the fifth century bce, which also suggests an early mystery cult: cf. Herodotus, Histories 4.94-96; Plato, Charmides 156d; and discussion and sources in Carrier, Not the Impossible Faith, pp. 86, 100-105; and Mircea Eliade, Zalmoxis the Vanishing God: Comparative Studies in the Religions and Folklore of Dacia and Eastern Europe (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1972). On the Sumerian dying-and-rising gods Innana and Tammuz (Astarte and Adonis) and others like them see Element 31. There were probably many other mystery cults that we know nothing or next to nothing about: see Origen, Against Celsus 6.22 and Michael Cosmopoulos (ed.), Greek Mysteries: The Archaeology and Ritual of Ancient Greek Secret Cults (New York: Routledge, 2003).
80. That there nevertheless were ‘gospels’ in other mystery cults recounting their myths and teachings is certain, as they are referred to in extant texts: for example, for Isis–Osiris cult, Apuleius, Metamorphoses 11.22-23 (cf. 11.28-30) mentions such sacred writings, as does Plutarch, On Isis and Osiris (= Moralia) 80.383e (there called hiera grammata, ‘sacred writings’) also 5.351f, 352b; the Egyptian Manetho had allegedly written that cult’s Holy Bible (Hiera biblos) sometime before the end of the third century bce (notably the very time the Hebrew ‘Holy Bible’ was supposedly being translated into Greek); cf. J. Gwyn Griffiths, Plutarch’s De Iside et Osiride (Cardiff: University of Wales Press, 1970), p. 80. The Dionysiac mysteries also appear to have had a set of gospels no longer extant: Nilsson, The Dionysiac Mysteries, pp. 116-18, 133; West, Orphic Poems, pp. 25-29. Similarly, recovered paraphernalia of the Mithras cult include the equivalent of ‘graphic novels’ (painted or carved in stone) recounting the narrative of the Mithras gospel. No text survives to tell us what stories the scenes illustrate, but there clearly must have been such a text. The tauroctony or ‘bull-slaying’ is only the most climactic scene, abundantly represented, but there was a whole sequence of ‘story cells’, including a miraculous nativity, Mithras dragging the bull to a cave, life springing from its blood, Mithras eating of its flesh, his ascension or exaltation, and various scenes featuring Mithras and the Supreme God (probably Sol Invictus, ‘The Invincible Sun’).
81. Apuleius, Metamorphoses 11.21-25; 11.16.
82. Tertullian, On Baptism 5. Per Beskow, in ‘Tertullian on Mithras’, in Studies in Mithraism: Papers Associated with the Mithraic Panel Organized on the Occasion of the XVIth Congress of the International Association for the History of Religions, Rome 1990 (ed. John Hinnells; Rome: L’Erma di Bretschneider, 1994), pp. 51-60, argues that the Mithraic ‘baptism’ was only an anointing of the forehead, but that is not a relevant difference. How a baptism was performed would naturally be highly variable from cult to cult (just as it is from sect to sect in Christianity today).
83. See Hans Conzelmann, 1 Corinthians: A Commentary on the First Epistle to the Corinthians (Philadelphia, PA: Fortress Press, 1975), pp. 275-76; with Plato, Republic 364e-365a. For evidence that Bacchic and Attis cults also regarded their baptisms as ‘rebirthing’ ceremonies, see Peter Kingsley, Ancient Philosophy, Mystery, and Magic: Empedocles and Pythagorean Tradition (New York: Oxford University Press, 1995), p. 264-69; that a Dionysian (i.e., Bacchic) ritual washed away sins (inherited over many generations): Kingsley, Ancient Philosophy, p. 261 n. 37 (cf. Plato, Phaedrus 244d-245a and 265b), the ritual in question most likely the baptism (per the evidence in Conzelmann). That baptism was conceived as part of a ‘rebirthing’ ceremony in Mithras cult as well: Hans Dieter Betz, The ‘Mithras Liturgy’: Text, Translation, and Commentary (Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2003), p. 51 (lines 505-11).
84. That Jesus through one’s baptism awarded liberation from sins (Rom. 6.20-23; Col. 1.13-14) just like Bacchus does in his mystery cult (see previous note), and apparently as baptisms do in the mystery cults generally, see Tertullian, Prescription against Heretics 40 and On Baptism 4-5. In the Osiris cult (as evinced in the Book of the Dead and elsewhere), it was your sins that weighed your soul down in the afterlife, dooming you to a bad outcome (your soul, in the form of your heart, being weighed on a scale against a feather: if your soul is heavier, it is devoured by a monster; lighter, you move on to eternal life); so the fact that baptismal rebirth into communion with Osiris freed you from this outcome entails that this cult, too, held some equivalent concept of washing away or forgiving sins through baptism. See W.B. Ober, ‘Weighing the Heart against the Feather of Truth’, Bulletin of the New York Academy of Medicine 55 (July–August 1979), pp. 636-51.
85. Justin, Apology 1.66; Tertullian, Prescription against Heretics 40.
86. See Petra Pakkanen, Interpreting Early Hellenistic Religion: A Study Based on the Mystery Cult of Demeter and the Cult of Isis (Helsinki: Suomen Ateenan-Instituutin Saatio, 1996); in which see esp. pp. 65-83 for a survey of various pagan mystery religions and their identifiable features. See also Marvin Meyer (ed.), The Ancient Mysteries: A Sourcebook of Sacred Texts (Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1987); and Alvarez, Romanising Oriental Gods.
87. See Pakkanen, Interpreting Early Hellenistic Religion, pp. 85-100, 129-35.
88. On eclecticism in science and philosophy: Richard Carrier, ‘Christianity Was Not Responsible for Modern Science’, in Christian Delusion (ed. Loftus), pp. 396-419 (405-406; with p. 416 n. 26). On Christmas (both its date and rituals) being originally pagan: Francis James and Miriam Hill (eds.), Joy to the World: Two Thousand Years of Christmas (Portland, OR: Four Courts, 2000). On the cult of saints being a syncretization (not a direct adoption) of pagan polytheism: Peter Brown, Cult of the Saints: Its Rise and Function in Latin Christianity (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1981), with James Howard-Johnston and Paul Antony Hayward (eds.), The Cult of Saints in Late Antiquity and the Middle Ages: Essays on the Contribution of Peter Brown (New York: Oxford University Press, 1999); and that there remained also a definite Jewish background to this process of syncretism in creating the Christian cult of saints: William Horbury, ‘The Cult of Christ and the Cult of the Saints’, New Testament Studies 44 (1998), pp. 444-69.
89. See Pakkanen, Interpreting Early Hellenistic Religion, pp. 100-109, 136; Hendrik Simon Versnel, Ter Unus: Isis, Dionysos, Hermes: Three Studies in Henotheism (Leiden: Brill, 1990); and for subsequent development of this trend: Polymnia Athanassiadi and Michael Frede (eds.), Pagan Monotheism in Late Antiquity (New York: Oxford University Press, 1999).
90. See Larry Hurtado, ‘Monotheism, Principal Angels, and Christology’, in The Oxford Handbook of the Dead Sea Scrolls (ed. Timothy Lim and John Collins; Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2010), pp. 546-64; and the scholarship on Judeo-Christian ‘principalities and powers’ (see Element 37).
91. See, e.g., Margaret Barker, The Great Angel: A Study of Israel’s Second God (Louisville, KY: Westminster/John Knox Press, 1992); Larry Hurtado, One God, One Lord: Early Christian Devotion and Ancient Jewish Monotheism (Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1988); and Alan Segal, Two Powers in Heaven: Early Rabbinic Reports about Christianity and Gnosticism (Leiden: Brill, 1977).
92. Pakkanen, Interpreting Early Hellenistic Religion, pp. 109-21, 130, 136-37.
93. Pakkanen, Interpreting Early Hellenistic Religion, pp. 121-28, 130, 137.
94. Pakkanen, Interpreting Early Hellenistic Religion, pp. 48-49, 52-54.
95. John Kloppenborg, ‘Associations in the Ancient World’, in Historical Jesus in Context (ed. Levine, Allison and Crossan), pp. 323-38 (esp. 329). That Christians called one another ‘brothers’ is evident throughout the Epistles (e.g. 1 Cor. 7.12; 15.6, 31; see Element 12). Paul considers himself the ‘father’ of those he converted (1 Cor. 4.15; cf. also Phlm. 10), just as was the practice in Isis cult.
96. See J. Gwyn Griffiths, The Isis-Book: Metamorphoses, Book XI (Leiden: Brill, 1975), pp. 318-19; and following note.
97. Evidence of the same rule-making for other cult’s sacred meals: Kloppenborg, ‘Associations’, pp. 335-36.
98. Edmonds, Myths of the Underworld Journey, pp. 82-108, 198-201. See also Jean-Pierre Vernant, ‘Mortals and Immortals: The Body of the Divine’, Mortals and Immortals: Collected Essays (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1991), pp. 27-49.
99. Josephus, Jewish War 2.137-42 and 2.150-53.
100. Explicitly stated in the Qumran text ‘Hymns of the Just’, esp. in 1.1; 3.5; 3.8-12; 4.1; 11.34-36; 13.8-12, 28; 14.21; 15.1-2; 16.22; 18.3; 19.15; 20.9; 21.1-2; 22.13-14; see Robert M. Price, The Pre-Nicene New Testament: Fifty-Four Formative Texts (Salt Lake City, UT: Signature Books, 2006), pp. 887-928. See also James Scott, ‘Throne-Chariot Mysticism in Qumran and in Paul’, in Eschatology, Messianism, and the Dead Sea Scrolls (ed. Craig Evans and Peter Flint: Grand Rapids, MI: William B. Eerdmans, 1997), pp. 101-19 (esp. 105-106); and Margaret Barker, The Great High Priest: The Temple Roots of Christian Liturgy (New York: T. & T. Clark, 2003), pp. 1-33 and On Earth as It Is in Heaven: Temple Symbolism in the New Testament (New York: T. & T. Clark, 1995), pp. 59-60.
101. There are numerous passages that confirm this: Rom. 8.15-29; 9.26; Gal. 3.26-29; 4.4-7; and Heb. 2.10-18; Eph. 1.5; 1 Jn 5.1-4 (and likewise 1 Jn 2.28–3.10; 4.8; 5.18-20); with Rom. 6.3-10; Col. 2.12. See also Irenaeus, Demonstration of the Apostolic Preaching 3 and 8; with Carrier, ‘Spiritual Body’, in Empty Tomb (ed. Price and Lowder), pp. 142-47. The notion could easily be derived from Ps. Sol. 17.27.
102. See Guy Stroumsa, Hidden Wisdom: Esoteric Traditions and the Roots of Christian Mysticism (Leiden: Brill, 1996).
103. Clement of Alexandria, Miscellanies 5.9 (§57.2-3).
104. Clement of Alexandria, Miscellanies 5.9 (§58.4-5).
105. Clement of Alexandria, Miscellanies 5.9 (§58.6).
106. As Philo of Alexandria put it, as quoted in John of Damascus, Parallels 533c, ‘It is not lawful to speak of the sacred mysteries to the uninitiated’. See Thomas Harrison, Divinity and History: The Religion of Herodotus (New York: Clarendon Press, 2000), pp. 182-89, especially with regard, e.g., to Herodotus, Histories 2.170-71; Euripides, Bacchae 20-54, 470-74; and Plutarch, The Obsolescence of Oracles 14.417b-c; and On Isis and Osiris 9.354c–11.355d; 58.374e; 78.382e-f. See also Clauss, Roman Cult of Mithras, p. 14.
107. Clement of Alexandria, Miscellanies 1.12.
108. Clement of Alexandria, Miscellanies 5.10 (§63.6-7).
109. Clement of Alexandria, Miscellanies 5.10 (§64.6).
110. Clement of Alexandria, Miscellanies 5.10 (§65.1-2).
111. Clement of Alexandria, Miscellanies 5.10 (§65.4–66.2); but all of 5.4-11 illustrates the point.
112. Origen, Against Celsus 3.51-61. See also Hippolytus, Apostolic Tradition 15-21, who describes the process of ascending from outsider to insider (first initiation), then from babe to mature (second initiation) as typically taking years to complete (and his manual does not even cover the teaching of the mature, nor ascending into the priesthood for that matter, which would by then have been yet another stage).
113. Note that Paul also at one point uses a technical term from the mystery cults that meant induction into the mysteries: mueō, whose principal meaning was ‘initiate into the mysteries’, which Paul uses in Phil. 4.12, but metaphorically, and in too ambiguous a way to be certain if his metaphor was to Christian mysteries or pagan mysteries (the former, I think, is more likely, but unprovable from this datum alone).
114. Qumran ‘Hymns of the Just’ 4 (with 13.8-12, 28; 16.22; ‘babes’ and ‘adults’ and ‘milk’ and ‘meat’ distinction in 14.21 and 21.1-2). See Price, Pre-Nicene, pp. 887-928.
115. Ignatius, Epistle to the Trallians 5.
116. Clement of Alexandria, Miscellanies 7.10 (§55.7–56.1). See Robin Lane Fox, Pagans and Christians (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1987), pp. 316-17, 733 (n. 11).
117. Clement of Alexandria, Miscellanies 7.10 (§56.1-7); the whole of 7.10 describes these levels and the knowledge requisite to ascend each. It need not be assumed that Clement is saying that lower ranking church members were not saved, since Clement and every other Christian, from Paul onward, declares that baptism (into ‘faith’) was sufficient; rather, those inducted but not yet fully ascended would still get eternal life, because they could ascend the remaining ranks in heaven (e.g. Origen, On the First Principles 2.11.4-7, which is in accord with Origen, Against Celsus 1.9-10).
118. See James Tabor, Things Unutterable: Paul’s Ascent to Paradise in its Greco-Roman, Judaic, and Early Christian Contexts (Lanham, MD: University Press of America, 1986), p. 122.
119. Though we do not have conclusive evidence that Clement’s four-stage system was already in place under Paul, I believe it is not unreasonable to suspect that it was, or something approaching it. That is not necessary to my point (since we do have conclusive evidence of at least two stages in Paul’s time and that’s sufficient to establish this element as fact), but the existence from the very start of the system Clement describes should be seriously considered. Not only because such systems might already have been employed in earlier Jewish sects (and thus simply been adapted to the new gospel), but also because this is how religions develop: their originators elaborate systems and hierarchies within a matter of years, not centuries. Hence I should not have to respond to the objection that developed systems and hierarchies within Christianity didn’t arise for another century. That assumption has always been implausible on its face. Any community that organizes and expands over three continents (as Paul’s letters show Christianity already had) will rapidly need a clear hierarchy and organization within a matter of years. To assume that no one thought of this or saw any need for it for a whole century (much less three) is absurd. Likewise, since Paul reveals there were already at least two levels of initiation in the cult, there is no reason to assume there were not more. If there were already two, there could just as easily have been four (as Josephus attests the Essenes already had). Paul’s letters just never had an occasion to discuss the details of this.
120. For further support of this last point see the analysis of Margaret Barker, ‘The Secret Tradition’, Journal of Higher Criticism 2 (Spring 1995), pp. 31-67; and Margaret Barker, ‘The Temple Roots of the Christian Liturgy’, in Christian Origins: Worship, Belief and Society (ed. Kieran O’Mahony; Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press, 2003), pp. 29-51. On secrets and initiations in Judaism see previous notes.
121. Plutarch, On Isis and Osiris 1.351c and 351f (this Clea was also the dedicatee of his book on The Bravery of Women 1.242e-f). Another discourse on this topic was delivered by Maximus of Tyre, in his fourth oration, ‘Poetry and Philosophy on the Gods’ (sometime in the second century), which also explicitly links allegorical mythmaking to mystery cult practice.
122. Plutarch, On Isis and Osiris 11.355b.
123. Plutarch, On Isis and Osiris 12.355d–19.358e.
124. Plutarch, On Isis and Osiris 20.358e-359a.
125. Plutarch, On Isis and Osiris 21.359c–24.360d.
126. Plutarch, On Isis and Osiris 25.360d-f.
127. 2 Cor. 1.5 and Phil. 3.10. Likewise 1 Pet. 1.11; 4.13; 5.1 (on which see Chapters 7 and 11).
128. Plutarch, On Isis and Osiris 26.361b–27.361e.
129. Plutarch, On Isis and Osiris 32.363d–46.369e; 49.371a–80.384c.
130. Plutarch, On Isis and Osiris 45.369a-d.
131. Plutarch, On Isis and Osiris 64.376f–67.378a (see also 70.379b–71.379e).
132. Plutarch, On Isis and Osiris 46.369d.
133. See Robert Lamberton, Homer the Theologian: Neoplatonist Allegorical Reading and the Growth of the Epic Tradition (Berkeley, CA: University of California Press, 1986). For broader analysis of this whole trend among pagans see J. Gwyn Griffiths, Plutarch’s De Iside et Osiride (Cardiff: University of Wales Press, 1970), pp. 100-101 and 419-20, and Luc Brisson, How Philosophers Saved Myths: Allegorical Interpretation and Classical Mythology (trans. Catherine Tihanyi; Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2004); for pagans, Jews, and Christians see Annewies van den Hoek, ‘Allegorical Interpretation’, in Dictionary of Biblical Criticism and Interpretation (ed. Stanley Porter; New York: Routledge, 2007), pp. 9-12; and Jean Pépin, Mythe et allégorie: les origines grecques et les contestations judéo-chrétiennes (Paris: Études Augustiniennes, 1976). See also Chilton, ‘Commenting on the Old Testament’.
134. Philo, On Flight and Discovery 22.121-22.
135. Philo, On Abraham 41.236 and 41.243. See also Philo, On the Descendants of Cain 7 and On Abraham 98-102.
136. Philo, On the Creation 55.157.
137. Philo, On Dreams 1.58 and On Mating with the Preliminary Studies 6-7.
138. We have three of his books On Allegorical Interpretation; for other examples of his reliance on the procedure, see On the Change of Names 28.152, On Dreams 1.27.172, etc. See Jean Pépin (ed.), La tradition de l’allégorie de Philon d’Alexandrie à Dante: Études historiques (Paris: Études Augustiniennes, 1987).
139. Plutarch, On Isis and Osiris 78.382e.
140. Plutarch, On Isis and Osiris 78.382f-383a (and see Elements 31 and 34-38).
141. Philo, On the Giants 58-60. See also Philo, On Providence 2.40-41 (translated and discussed in Lamberton, Homer the Theologian, pp. 49-51).
142. For discussion of this point see Peter Struck, Birth of the Symbol: Ancient Readers and the Limits of their Texts (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2004); Bruce Malina, The Social Gospel of Jesus: The Kingdom of God in Mediterranean Perspective (New York: Routledge, 2000); and Bruce Malina, The New Jerusalem in the Revelation of John: The City as Symbol of Life with God (Collegeville, MN: Liturgical Press, 2000), with Bruce Malina and John Pilch, Social Science Commentary on the Book of Revelation (Minneapolis, MN: Fortress Press, 2000). See also John Dominic Crossan, The Power of Parable: How Fiction by Jesus became Fiction about Jesus (New York: HarperOne, 2012); Thomas Thompson, The Messiah Myth: The Near Eastern Roots of Jesus and David (New York: Basic Books, 2005); Thomas Brodie, The Birthing of the New Testament: The Intertextual Development of the New Testament Writings (Sheffield: Sheffield Phoenix Press, 2004); and Randel Helms, Gospel Fictions (Amherst, NY: Prometheus Books, 1988).
143. Origen, Against Celsus 4.48-49 (see also 1.42). Origen is not alone. The pagan critic Porphyry observed that all Christians and Jews treated their text this way, and Eusebius concurs: Eusebius, History of the Church 6.19.4 (quoting Porphyry, Against the Christians 3).
144. Origen, Against Celsus 4.50. See also Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 90.
145. Origen, Against Celsus 4.51-52. Thus, Origen asks that Celsus ‘seek the help of one who is capable of initiating him into the actual meaning of the narratives’ before judging their veracity: Origen, Against Celsus 6.23; that is, he asks that Celsus become a Christian, as then he will be taught these secrets.
146. Origen, Commentary on the Gospel according to John 1.9-11 and 10.2-6.
147. Joseph Trigg, ‘Divine Deception and the Truthfulness of Scripture’, in Origen of Alexandria: His World and his Legacy (ed. Charles Kannengiesser and William Peterson; Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press, 1988), pp. 147-64; Gunnar Hällström, Fides simpliciorum according to Origen of Alexandria (Helsinki: Societas Scientiarum Fennica, 1984).
148. Eusebius, Preparation for the Gospel 12.31. The passage he quotes is Plato, Laws 663e. Note that the section heading could possibly be by a later editor, though I doubt it, and it accurately describes the argument Eusebius makes nevertheless.
149. Plato, Laws 663e-664b. See also Plato, Republic 2.414-17.
150. Plato, Republic 2.378a-e.
151. Maximus of Tyre, Orations 4.3.
152. Plato, Letters 2.312d; 2.314a-14c. See Julius Elias, Plato’s Defense of Poetry (Albany, NY: State University of New York Press, 1984); Radcliffe Edmonds III, Myths of the Underworld Journey: Plato, Aristophanes, and the ‘Orphic’ Gold Tablets (New York: Cambridge University Press, 2004), pp. 161-71 (in context, pp. 159-220); Kathryn Morgan, Myth and Philosophy from the Presocratics to Plato (New York: Cambridge University Press, 2000).
153. Augustine, City of God 4.27 vs. Augustine, Confessions 5.14. See also Augustine, On Lying 7 and 24-26.
154. Origen, Homilies on Jeremiah 18.4.2.
155. Origen, Against Celsus 5.19 (see also 5.14-16).
156. Origen, Against Celsus 1.9-10 and 3.45-46.
157. Clement of Alexandria, Who Is the Rich Man That Shall Be Saved 5.
158. Euripides, Bacchae 479-480.
159. I will discuss the other phenomena shortly, but the phenomenon of psychosomatic illness and its cultural framing is discussed in Edward Shorter, From Paralysis to Fatigue: A History of Psychosomatic Illness in the Modern Era (New York: Maxwell Macmillan International, 1992), and in the Journal of Psychosomatic Research (e.g. J. Stone et al., ‘Conversion Disorder: Current Problems and Potential Solutions for DSM-5’, Journal of Psychosomatic Research 71 [2011], pp. 369-76). For its connection to hallucinators and ‘possession’ phenomena in modern cults, see Horst Figge, ‘Spirit Possession and Healing Cult among the Brasilian Umbanda’, Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics 25 (1975), pp. 246-50; and E.D. Wittkower, ‘Spirit Possession in Haitian Vodun Ceremonies’, Acta psychotherapeutica et psychosomatica 12 (1964), pp. 72-80.
160. Felecitas Goodman, Speaking in Tongues: A Cross-Cultural Study in Glossolalia (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1972); Watson Mills, Speaking in Tongues: A Guide to Research on Glossolalia (Grand Rapids, MI: William B. Eerdmans, 1986); Gerald Hovenden, Speaking in Tongues: The New Testament Evidence in Context (London: Sheffield Academic, 2002). On this and the other ‘signatory’ behaviors of the original cult (including visions and hearing voices) see Gordon Fee, The First Epistle to the Corinthians (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans, 1987), pp. 590-99, 652-713; and Ronald Kydd, Charismatic Gifts in the Early Church (Peabody, MA: Hendrickson Publishers, 1984). For a good and accessible summary of the scientific literature on glossolalia see Scott Semenyna and Rodney Schmalz, ‘Glossolalia Meets Glosso-Psychology: Why Speaking in Tongues Persists in Charismatic Christian and Pentecostal Gatherings’, Skeptic 17 (2012), pp. 40-43.
161. See Miranda Aldhouse-Green and Stephen Aldhouse-Green, The Quest for the Shaman: Shape-Shifters, Sorcerers and Spirit-Healers of Ancient Europe (London: Thames & Hudson, 2005); and I.M. Lewis, Ecstatic Religion: A Study of Shamanism and Spirit Possession (New York: Routledge, 1989). For Mediterranean antiquity see Peter Green, Alexander to Actium: The Historical Evolution of the Hellenistic Age (Berkeley, CA: University of California Press, 1990), pp. 408-13, 594-95; Robin Lane Fox, ‘Seeing the Gods’, in Pagans and Christians (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1987), pp. 102-67; E.R. Dodds, ‘Dream-Pattern and Culture-Pattern’, in The Greeks and the Irrational (Berkeley, CA: University of California Press, 1951), pp. 102-34 (with more on prophetic trances and ecstasies in ‘The Blessings of Madness’, pp. 64-101). Crucial context is also provided by A.D. Nock, Conversion: The Old and the New in Religion from Alexander the Great to Augustine of Hippo (Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1933). On the role of dreams as authoritative communications from the gods: John Hanson, ‘Dreams and Visions in the Graeco-Roman World and Early Christianity’, Aufstieg und Niedergang der römischen Welt II 23 (New York: W. de Gruyter, 1980), pp. 1395-1427 and William Harris, Dreams and Experience in Classical Antiquity (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2009).
162. The role of hallucination in world religion is discussed from both a historical and scientific perspective in John Horgan, Rational Mysticism: Dispatches from the Border between Science and Spirituality (Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 2003); Robert Buckman, Can We Be Good without God? Biology, Behavior, and the Need to Believe (Amherst, NY: Prometheus Books, 2002); Eugene D’Aquili and Andrew Newberg, Why God Won’t Go Away: Brain Science and the Biology of Belief (New York: Ballantine, 2001); and Eugene D’Aquili and Andrew Newberg, The Mystical Mind: Probing the Biology of Religious Experience (Minneapolis, MN: Fortress Press, 1999); Pascal Boyer, Religion Explained: The Evolutionary Origins of Religious Thought (New York: Basic Books, 2001); and Joseph Giovannoli, The Biology of Belief: How our Biology Biases our Beliefs and Perceptions (Rosetta Press, 2000). See also: William James, The Varieties of Religious Experience: A Study in Human Nature (London: Longmans, Green, 1902), with Charles Taylor, Varieties of Religion Today: William James Revisited (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2002); and Ernst Arbman, Ecstasy, or Religious Trance, in the Experience of the Ecstatics and from the Psychological Point of View (3 vols.; Stockholm: Bokförlaget 1963-70). For surveys of the modern science of hallucination generally, see later note (e.g. Sacks, etc.).
163. On sleep paralysis and hallucination (from which many UFO abduction claims originate, for example), see Bruce Bower, ‘Night of the Crusher: The Waking Nightmare of Sleep Paralysis Propels People into a Spirit World’, Science News 168 (July 9, 2005), pp. 27-29; and A. Mavromatis, Hypnagogia: The Unique State of Consciousness between Wakefulness and Sleep (London: Routledge, 1987). For my own experience with this phenomenon see Carrier, ‘Spiritual Body’, in Empty Tomb (ed. Price and Lowder), pp. 184-88. I assume the reader is already well enough familiar with the ability of natural chemicals to induce hallucination as well (from cannabis and hemp to ergot and mushrooms), but for that and other causes see Oliver Sacks, Hallucinations (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 2012).
164. Mt. 9.15; Mk 2.18-20; Lk. 5.33-35 (also, e.g., 2.37; 18.12); Acts 13.2-3; 14.23; 27.21-23; 1 Cor. 7.5; 2 Cor. 6.5; 11.27. On early Christian visionary tradition and its possible link to rituals of fasting see Andrew Lincoln, ‘The “Philosophy” Opposed in the Letter [to the Colossians]’, in The New Interpreter’s Bible: New Testament Survey (ed. Fred Craddock; Nashville, TN: Abingdon Press, 2005), pp. 242-47.
165. For my own experience with this see Richard Carrier, Sense and Goodness without God: A Defense of Metaphysical Naturalism (Bloomington, IN: AuthorHouse, 2005), pp. 11-14.
166. See Alan Segal, ‘Religiously-Interpreted States of Consciousness: Prophecy, Self-Consciousness, and Life After Death’, Life after Death: A History of the Afterlife in the Religions of the West (New York: Doubleday, 2004), pp. 322-50; and Alan Segal, ‘Heavenly Ascent in Hellenistic Judaism, Early Christianity and their Environment’, Aufstieg und Niedergang der römischen Welt II.23.2 (New York: W. de Gruyter, 1980), pp. 1333-94; and James Tabor, Things Unutterable: Paul’s Ascent to Paradise in its Greco-Roman, Judaic, and Early Christian Contexts (Lanham, MD: University Press of America, 1986).
167. Gordon Claridge and Charles McCreery, ‘A Study of Hallucination in Normal Subjects’, Personality and Individual Differences 2 (November 1996), pp. 739-47; see also Gordon Claridge, ‘Schizotypy and Schizophrenia’, in Schizophrenia: The Major Issues (ed. Paul Bebbington and Peter McGuffin; London: Heinemann Professional, 1988), pp. 187-200; Gordon Claridge (ed.), Schizotypy: Implications for Illness and Health (New York: Oxford University Press, 1997); and: L.C. Johns et al., ‘Prevalence and Correlates of Self-Reported Psychotic Symptoms in the British Population’, British Journal of Psychiatry 185 (2004), pp. 298-305; and Maurice M. Ohayon, ‘Prevalence of Hallucinations and their Pathological Associations in the General Population’, Psychiatry Research 97 (December 27, 2000), pp. 153-64; Charles McCreery and Gordon Claridge, ‘Healthy Schizotypy: The Case of Out-of-the-Body Experiences’, Personality and Individual Differences 32 (January 5, 2002), pp. 141-54; C.A. Ross, S. Joshi and R. Currie, ‘Dissociative Experiences in the General Population’, American Journal of Psychiatry 147 (1990), pp. 1547-52; Richard Bentall, Gordon Claridge and Peter Slade, ‘The Multi-Dimensional Nature of Schizotypal Traits: A Factor Analytic Study with Normal Subjects’, British Journal of Clinical Psychology 28 (1989), pp. 363-75; T.B. Posey and M.E. Losch, ‘Auditory Hallucinations of Hearing Voices in 375 Normal Subjects’, Imagination, Cognition and Personality 3 (1983), pp. 99-113. See also Arbman, Ecstasy.
168. See S. Day and E. Peters, ‘The Incidence of Schizotypy in New Religious Movements’, Personality and Individual Differences 27 (July 1999), pp. 55-67; Mike Jackson and K.W.M. Fulford, ‘Spiritual Experience and Psychopathology’, Philosophy, Psychiatry, and Psychology 4 (1997), pp. 41-65 (with discussion, same issue, pp. 66-90); Roland Littlewood, ‘From Elsewhere: Prophetic Visions and Dreams among the People of the Earth’, Dreaming 14 (June–September 2004), pp. 94-106; Felicitas Goodman, Jeanette Henney and Esther Pressel, Trance, Healing, and Hallucination (New York: Wiley, 1974). On culture making the difference between isolation vs. integration of schizotypals: Richard Castillo, ‘Trance, Functional Psychosis, and Culture’, Psychiatry 66 (Spring 2003), pp. 9-21. On schizotypals gaining leadership roles in contemporary cults see Figge, ‘Spirit Possession’, and Wittkower, ‘Spirit Possession’, with Alexander Moreira-Almeida, Francisco Lotufo Neto and Bruce Greyson, ‘Dissociative and Psychotic Experiences in Brazilian Spiritist Mediums’, Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics 76 (2007), pp. 57-58.
169. See Bruce Bower’s excellent summary article on all of this in ‘Visions for All’, Science News 181 (April 7, 2012), pp. 22-25, which summarizes the state of the latest research on normal hallucination in religious communities, especially in light of its recent examination by Tanya Luhrmann in When God Talks Back (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 2012). See also Ethan Watters, Crazy Like Us: The Globalization of the American Psyche (New York: Free Press, 2010), for evidence of the fact that many ‘mental illnesses’ are socially constructed, and often what is ‘insane’ in one culture is welcomed as ‘normal’ in another, often without detriment.
170. See my discussion in Carrier, ‘Spiritual Body’, in Empty Tomb (ed. Price and Lowder), pp. 184-88. This is also discussed in Goodman, Henney and Pressel, Trance, Healing, and Hallucination.
171. Peter Slade and Richard Bentall, Sensory Deception: A Scientific Analysis of Hallucination (Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1988), pp. 69-108 (80). See also Leonard Zusne and Warren Jones, Anomalistic Psychology: A Study of Extraordinary Phenomena of Behavior and Experience (Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum Associates, 1982); Fred Johnson, The Anatomy of Hallucinations (Chicago: Nelson-Hall, 1978); and the recent popular summary of the science of hallucination in Sacks, Hallucinations.
172. For example, schizotypals appear to have held positions of respect or authority in both Bacchic and Jewish fringe sects of the time: Joan Taylor, Jewish Women Philosophers of First-Century Alexandria: Philo’s ‘Therapeutae’ Reconsidered (New York: Oxford University Press, 2003), pp. 339-40 (which becomes especially poignant in light of the work of Evan Fales on St. Teresa: see later note). See also Harry Angus Alexander Kennedy, St Paul and the Mystery-Religions (London: Hodder & Stoughton, 1913), pp. 31-67, and scholarship cited in a previous note (e.g. E.R. Dodds, etc.).
173. Phillip Wiebe, Visions of Jesus: Direct Encounters from the New Testament to Today (New York: Oxford University Press, 1997); John Cornwell, The Hiding Places of God: A Personal Journey into the World of Religious Visions, Holy Objects, and Miracles (New York: Warner Books, 1991); C. Green and C. McCreery, Apparitions (London: Hamish Hamilton, 1975); Katharine Holden and Christopher French, ‘Alien Abduction Experiences: Some Cues from Neuropsychology and Neuropsychiatry’, Cognitive Neuropsychiatry 7 (2002), pp. 163-78; W.D. Rees, ‘The Hallucinations of Widowhood’, British Medical Journal 4 (1971), pp. 37-41; Vaughan Bell, ‘Ghost Stories: Visits from the Deceased’, Scientific American Online (December 2, 2008), http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=ghost-stories-visits-from-the-deceased. See also Nicholas Spanosa, Cheryl Burgessa and Melissa Faith Burgessa, ‘Past-Life Identities, UFO Abductions, and Satanic Ritual Abuse: The Social Construction of Memories’, International Journal of Clinical and Experimental Hypnosis 42 (1994), pp. 433-46.
174. As one can learn from reference works in psychology: priming is where recent exposure (even subconsciously) to ideas, words, images and other perceptual context will influence what is hallucinated; anchoring is when someone focuses on particular concepts (such as a set of expectations or things they were told) and then all subsequent memories and perceptions are anchored to that focus (hallucinations can thus become structured by and around that anchor); suggestion is where something a respected friend or leader says you remember or experience becomes in fact what you remember or experience (and people are highly susceptible to suggestion when in a trance state); and cultural framing is the obvious effect of one’s upbringing and background knowledge and expectations structuring what one hallucinates (e.g. in antiquity people routinely hallucinated journeying up through seven levels of heaven, because culturally that’s how everyone believed the cosmos was organized). Cultural framing does not prevent innovative ideas from appearing in hallucinations, not only because of the other factors that can be overriding (priming, anchoring and suggestion), but also because hallucinations can be highly desire-driven: to resolve certain anxieties or cognitive dissonance, or to express certain creative thoughts, revisions to the status quo can even be what someone wants most to hallucinate, and so they will (e.g. if ever it became socially or politically important that there be only four heavens, a percipient might hallucinate that and report it as confirmation that previous beliefs had been wrong, or were even the cause of social problems the percipient wants most to solve). For some of the conditions under which hallucination is facilitated and guided, and its susceptibility to suggestion and cultural framing, in both normals and schizotypals, see Alfred Heilbrun Jr, ‘Hallucinations’, in Symptoms of Schizophrenia (ed. Charles Costello; New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1993), pp. 56-91.
175. See Carrier, Not the Impossible Faith, pp. 259-96, and ‘Burial of Jesus’, in Empty Tomb (ed. Price and Lowder), pp. 387-88 (and notes there on p. 392).
176. But for an anthropologically informed defense of that possibility, see Evan Fales, ‘The Road to Damascus’, Faith and Philosophy 22 (2005), pp. 442-59, supported by the referenced discussions in the preceding note, and by Evan Fales, ‘Scientific Explanations of Mystical Experiences, Part I: The Case of St. Teresa’, Religious Studies 32 (1996), pp. 143-63; and Evan Fales, ‘Scientific Explanations of Mystical Experiences, Part II: The Challenge to Theism’, Religious Studies 32 (1996), pp. 297-313; and Evan Fales, ‘Can Science Explain Mysticism?’, Religious Studies 35 (1999), pp. 213-27. Note that Fales believes pretense might not even be required, that persons can convince themselves that they have seen or heard what they claim, or that their own inner thoughts and feelings can legitimately be described in terms of seeing and hearing more substantive things than mere thoughts and feelings. Sometimes no distinction was made between dreams and waking visions (e.g. compare the Greek text of Longus, Daphnis and Chloe 2.8.4 with 1 Cor. 15.5-8). See William Harris, Dreams and Experience in Classical Antiquity (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2009).
177. The following points derive from the analyses of Goodman, Henney and Pressel, Trance, Healing, and Hallucination (on Shaker and other modern cults) and other studies of hallucination in social and religious contexts. See also Carrier, ‘Spiritual Body’, in Empty Tomb (ed. Price and Lowder), pp. 194-95.
178. It’s much more difficult to scientifically study pretenders, but we know enough in psychology to confirm that people do engage in conforming behaviors, arguably far more often than hallucinatory behaviors, so this will also have been a factor in early Christianity, no less than in any other cult in history. This means actual hallucination is often not even necessary. Many members of a cult will claim to have seen or heard things, when in fact they didn’t, and pretend to go along, because (a) they want to belong (and this is the only way to fulfill their desire to fit in), or they need the benefits the community provides (such as food, shelter, love, companionship), or (for reasons of dysphoria or dissonance outside the cult) they want to believe its claims are true because they are ultimately comforting (such as giving their lives hope or meaning that they did not previously have), or they want the power and influence that being a revered spiritual leader affords them (if they can be adequately convincing and also effective at winning support). These psychological motivations can be quite powerful, and have certainly been documented to compel people to engage in conforming behavior in other contexts, so it can surely happen in this context as well. These members will pick up all the social cues and simply agree with everyone, to both fit in and convince themselves, which if sustained can even alter their memory so that they honestly believe they saw or heard things they didn’t (or else they will delusionally refuse to acknowledge, even to themselves, that they didn’t).
On these and other psychological features of cults see Christopher Partridge (ed.), UFO Religions (New York: Routledge, 2003); Marc Galanter, Cults: Faith, Healing, and Coercion (New York: Oxford University Press, 1989); and Marc Galanter, ‘Cults and Charismatic Group Psychology’, in Religion and the Clinical Practice of Psychology (ed. Edward Shafranske; Washington, DC: American Psychological Association, 1996), pp. 269-96; Philip Zimbardo and Robert Vallone (eds.), Persuasion, Coercion, Indoctrination and Mind Control (Lexington, MA: Glenn Custom, 1983); Leon Festinger, Henry Riecken and Stanley Schachter, When Prophecy Fails: A Social and Psychological Study of a Modern Group That Predicted the Destruction of the World (Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press, 1956); also relevant are the more general analyses of the psychology of belief: Robert Cialdini, Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion (New York: William Morrow, 1993); Richard Petty and John Cacioppo, Attitudes and Persuasion: Classic and Contemporary Approaches (Dubuque, IA: William C. Brown, 1981); and Muzafer Sherif and Carl Hovland, Social Judgment: Assimilation and Contrast Effects in Communication and Attitude Change (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1961). On the relevant memory science (and how we can change and fabricate our own memories through suggestion, habituation and wishful thinking), see scholarship cited in Carrier, Proving History, p. 322 n. 104.
179. So 1 John 4; Gal. 1.6-12; 1 Thess. 5.19-24; 2 Cor. 13 and 10.3-6; 1 Timothy 6; 2 Thess. 2.11; 1 Tim. 4.1 and 2 Tim. 3.5.
180. For evidence of Christians ‘thought-policing’ themselves in just this way: Carrier, Not the Impossible Faith, pp. 385-406.
181. See Jack Kent, The Psychological Origins of the Resurrection Myth (London: Open Gate, 1999); James Crossley, ‘Against the Historical Plausibility of the Empty Tomb Story and the Bodily Resurrection of Jesus’, Journal for the Study of the Historical Jesus 3 (June 2005), pp. 171-86; Michael Goulder, ‘The Baseless Fabric of a Vision’, in Resurrection Reconsidered (ed. Gavin D’Costa; Oxford: Oneworld Publications, 1996), pp. 48-61; and Michael Goulder, ‘The Explanatory Power of Conversion Visions’, in Jesus’ Resurrection: Fact or Figment: A Debate between William Lane Craig and Gerd Lüdemann (ed. Paul Copan and Ronald Tacelli; Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press, 2000), pp. 86-103. For an argument supporting this conclusion from the overall nature of how Christianity began and developed see Carrier, ‘Christianity’s Success Was Not Incredible’, in End of Christianity (ed. Loftus); and from the evidence for the ‘resurrection’ specifically: Carrier, ‘Why the Resurrection Is Unbelievable’, in Christian Delusion (ed. Loftus).
182. On the belief that one’s intuition can have the authority of the Holy Spirit (a belief held by many Jews and Christians) see Jn 14.26; Wis. 9.13-18; Dan. 2.19-22; and Exodus 31; see Philo, On the Giants 19-27, for an attempt at supplying an underlying theory.
183. On the authenticity of this passage, see following note.
184. I discuss this reliance on inspired thoughts, visions and spirit communications in forming beliefs in the early church in Carrier, Not the Impossible Faith, pp. 385-406. See also Hanson, ‘Dreams and Visions’, pp. 1421-25.
185. Goodman, Henney and Pressel, Trance, Healing, and Hallucination, p. 351.
186. I am, of course, presuming the authenticity of this passage (as I shall continue to do): see Chapter 7 (§7). It may be of the Pauline school rather than by Paul himself (since much the same is said in Eph. 3). But as such it would still represent the thinking of Pauline Christianity. Its sentiments are well enough corroborated elsewhere in Paul’s writings (see Element 15).
187. I further demonstrate this aspect of early Christian ‘faith-based’ epistemology in Carrier, Not the Impossible Faith, pp. 281-85 and 385-406 (with support in pp. 329-68).
188. See, e.g., D.E. Aune, ‘Christian Prophecy and the Messianic Status of Jesus’, in The Messiah (ed. Charlesworth), pp. 404-22.
189. Aune, ‘Christian Prophecy’.
190. For example, G.K. Beale and D.A. Carson (eds.), Commentary on the New Testament Use of the Old Testament (Grand Rapids, MI: Apollos, 2007); Craig Evans (ed.), From Prophecy to Testament: The Function of the Old Testament in the New (Peabody, MA: Hendrickson Publishers, 2004); Steve Moyise (ed.), The Old Testament in the New Testament (Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press, 2000); John Court (ed.), New Testament Writers and the Old Testament: An Introduction (London: SPCK, 2002); Stanley Porter (ed.), Hearing the Old Testament in the New Testament (Grand Rapids, MI: William B. Eerdmans, 2006).
191. See also Earl Doherty, Jesus: Neither God nor Man (The Case for a Mythical Jesus) (Ottawa: Age of Reason, 2009), pp. 83-96.
192. See Proving History, pp. 131-34 and 139-41, and Carrier, ‘Spiritual Body’, in Empty Tomb (ed. Price and Lowder), pp. 158-61.
193. 1 Corinthians 5 implies the Lord’s Supper is the Passover, which would mean the role of ‘remembrance’ in 1 Cor. 11.23-26 is intended to reflect the same role of remembrance in Exod. 12.14, and therefore 1 Cor. 11.23-26 also confirms that Christ’s death was understood as a Passover sacrifice (the body of both sacrifices was eaten to procure salvation from death, and both involve a ritual use of the blood from the same body being eaten: see Chapter 11, §7). And of course the Gospels unanimously link the two.
194. Clement of Alexandria, Miscellanies 4.25. This was a logical progression in ancient cultic thinking, from an occasional to a permanent state of holiness (see Carrier, Not the Impossible Faith, p. 137), and from a proximate to a direct communion with God: see Carrier, ‘Spiritual Body’, in Empty Tomb (ed. Price and Lowder), pp. 145-47.
195. See Alan Segal, ‘Conversion and Messianism: Outline for a New Approach’, in The Messiah (ed. Charlesworth), pp. 296-340; W.D. Davies, ‘The Jewish Sources of Matthew’s Messianism’, in The Messiah (ed. Charlesworth), pp. 494-511; David Sim, The Gospel of Matthew and Christian Judaism: The History and Social Setting of the Matthean Community (Edinburgh: T. & T. Clark, 1998); and my discussion of this same point in Carrier, Proving History, pp. 170-72. The Pseudo-Pauline letters of Ephesians (3.3-12) and Colossians (1.24-29) also report that Paul originated this innovation. The original sect survived for a few centuries but never significantly grew; for example, Epiphanius, in Panarion 29, discusses a sect called ‘the Nazoreans’, which we know to have been the original name for the Christians (Acts 24.5; Jerome, Letters 112.13), ‘who confess that Christ Jesus is Son of God, but all of whose customs are in accordance with the [Torah] Law’ (on these Christians see Chapter 8, §1).
196. This last point hardly needs defense, but does require qualification: there are comparatively few exceptions of texts (1) preserved by Jews and Muslims, but none of those both date prior to the fourth century and pertain (in any direct sense) to the origins and development of Christianity; and (2) recovered archaeologically (e.g. in papyri, inscriptions, coins), but almost none of those pertain (in any direct sense) to the origins and development of Christianity, while those that do are extremely few, extremely sparse in content, and late (mid-second century at the earliest, and most much later).
197. For example, Heb. 13.8-9; 2 Thess. 2.2-15; 1 Tim. 1.3-7; 4.1-16; 2 Tim. 3.5; Tit. 3.9; 1 Jn 2.18-26 and 4.1; 2 John 7; 3 John 9-10; Jude 3-4, 8-16; 2 Pet. 1.15-21; 3.16; Rev. 2.2, 6, 14, 15, 20; Acts 20.29-30; Mk 13.22; Mt. 7.15-23; 24.11, 24; etc.
198. See my discussion of this problem in Carrier, Proving History, pp. 129-34.
199. See, e.g., David Brakke, The Gnostics: Myth, Ritual, and Diversity in Early Christianity (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2010); and Marvin Meyer, The Gnostic Discoveries: The Impact of the Nag Hammadi Library (San Francisco, CA: HarperSanFrancisco, 2005). A lot of this weirdness was already catalogued by the early third century: Tertullian, Prescription against Heretics; Irenaeus, Against Heresies; Hippolytus, Refutation of All Heresies.
200. Eusebius, History of the Church 3.
201. Robert Funk, ‘Do the Gospels Contain Eyewitness Reports?’, in Finding the Historical Jesus: Rules of Evidence (ed. Bernard Brandon Scott; Santa Rosa, CA: Polebridge, 2008), pp. 31-39 (38).
202. Tacitus, Annals 15.44 (which claims perhaps hundreds were captured and confessed to arson and executed). Although that might have suffered interpolation (see following note), Suetonius, Nero 16.2, corroborates a Neronian purge of Christianity—unless that, too, is an interpolation, although by the second century, Christians certainly believed Nero had purged the Christian leadership at Rome (in apocryphal Christian legend, Nero executed Peter and Paul and their peers at Rome, as told in the Acts of Peter and the Acts of Paul). We have no conclusive evidence of any Christians surviving this.
203. Of course, if this event never happened (and I suspect it didn’t: see Chapter 8, §10), then we are even more in the dark about the fate and progress of Christianity at Rome.
204. Josephus, Jewish War 6.420-34 and book 7 relates the destruction of Jerusalem and its inhabitants.
205. Acts 11.27-30; Josephus, Jewish Antiquities 20.50-53; it may have lasted several years and affected even the food supply of the city of Rome: Suetonius, Life of Claudius 18; Dio Cassius, Roman History 60.11.1-5. On Christianity’s slow growth in this period (vs. exaggerated numbers in Christian propaganda) see Carrier, Not the Impossible Faith, pp. 407-48. There were probably of course additional persecution events (in this early period mostly led by Jewish authorities) that we should also add as factors increasing mortality beyond the average. Although we mustn’t exaggerate that factor: see Candida Moss, The Myth of Persecution: How Early Christians Invented a Story of Martyrdom (New York: HarperOne, 2013).
206. Read Eusebius, History of the Church 3.23 in light of his more critical observations at 3.39.
207. On this and following statistical remarks I follow the data provided in T.G. Parkin, Demography and Roman Society (Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1992), p. 144. You can see some calculations for survival odds at http://www.richardcarrier.info/lifetbl.html (‘Estimated Life Expectancy in the Ancient World’). If John was around 15 when he was made an apostle, he would be around 85 by the year 100, which has a probability of survival less than 1 in 200; if John was 25 at the start, then he would be 95 by year 100, which would have odds of thousands to one against; the odds only decline exponentially from there. And again, this is without factoring in the war, famine and persecutions.
<
0 comentarios:
Publicar un comentario